idea-evaluation

name	idea-evaluation
description	Evaluate and prioritize ideas using scoring frameworks with clear criteria. Trigger with "evaluate these ideas", "prioritize these options", "which idea is best", or "rank these ideas".

Idea Evaluation

Score and prioritize ideas with structured criteria.

When to Use

• After a brainstorming session to select top ideas
• Comparing multiple options for a decision
• Prioritizing a backlog of ideas

Steps

1. Confirm the list of ideas to evaluate
2. Define evaluation criteria (or suggest appropriate ones)
3. Score each idea against criteria
4. Create a prioritization matrix (impact vs. effort or custom)
5. Recommend top ideas with reasoning

Output Format

## Idea Evaluation

### Criteria
| Criterion | Weight | Description |
|-----------|--------|-------------|
| Impact | [X%] | [What impact means here] |
| Effort | [X%] | [What effort means here] |
| Confidence | [X%] | [How sure we are it will work] |

### Scoring
| # | Idea | Impact | Effort | Confidence | Total |
|---|------|--------|--------|------------|-------|
| 1 | [idea] | [1-10] | [1-10] | [1-10] | [weighted] |

### Priority Matrix
**Quick Wins** (High Impact, Low Effort): [ideas]
**Big Bets** (High Impact, High Effort): [ideas]
**Fill-Ins** (Low Impact, Low Effort): [ideas]
**Skip** (Low Impact, High Effort): [ideas]

### Recommendation
Top 3 to pursue:
1. [Idea] -- [Why this is #1]
2. [Idea] -- [Why]
3. [Idea] -- [Why]