القائمة
Spawn 3 axis-specific reviewers (A/B/C)
التثبيت باستخدام Codex أو Claude انسخ هذا Prompt والصقه في Codex أو Claude أو مساعد آخر ليراجع صفحة Skill ويثبّتها لك.
استنادا إلى تصنيف SOC المهني
Install Pasture binaries (pastured, pasture, pasture-release) from GitHub Releases, go install, or Nix
Pasture protocol reference documentation — 12-phase workflow, agent roles, constraints, and coding standards. Read when you need to understand the full workflow or look up conventions.
Create handoff document and transfer to supervisor
Create PROPOSAL-N task with full technical plan
Ratify proposal, mark old proposals pasture:superseded
Specification writer and implementation designer
| name | architect-request-review |
| description | Spawn 3 axis-specific reviewers (A/B/C) |
Command: pasture:architect:request-review — Spawn 3 axis-specific reviewers (A/B/C)
-> Full workflow in PROCESS.md <- Phase 4
[arch-review-spawn-3-axes]
[arch-review-provide-context]
Plan draft complete, ready for review.
Reviews are named PROPOSAL-N-REVIEW-{axis}-{round} where:
| Axis | Focus | Key Questions |
|---|---|---|
| A | Correctness (spirit and technicality) | Does it faithfully serve the user? Are technical decisions consistent with rationale? |
| B | Test quality | Integration over unit? SUT not mocked? Shared fixtures? Assert outcomes? |
| C | Elegance and complexity matching | Right API? Not over/under-engineered? Complexity proportional to problem? |
Task(description: "Reviewer A: correctness", prompt: "Review PROPOSAL-1 task <task-id>. URD: <urd-id> (read for requirements context). You are Reviewer A (Correctness). Focus: Does it faithfully serve the user? Are technical decisions consistent with rationale? Create review task titled PROPOSAL-1-REVIEW-A-1...", subagent_type: "general-purpose")
Task(description: "Reviewer B: test quality", prompt: "Review PROPOSAL-1 task <task-id>. URD: <urd-id> (read for requirements context). You are Reviewer B (Test quality). Focus: Integration over unit? SUT not mocked? Shared fixtures? Assert outcomes? Create review task titled PROPOSAL-1-REVIEW-B-1...", subagent_type: "general-purpose")
Task(description: "Reviewer C: elegance", prompt: "Review PROPOSAL-1 task <task-id>. URD: <urd-id> (read for requirements context). You are Reviewer C (Elegance). Focus: Right API? Not over/under-engineered? Complexity proportional to problem? Create review task titled PROPOSAL-1-REVIEW-C-1...", subagent_type: "general-purpose")
All 3 reviewers must vote ACCEPT. Max revision rounds until consensus.
bd show <proposal-id>
bd comments <proposal-id>
# Add comment to notify that review is ready
bd comments add <proposal-id> "Review requested — 3 reviewers spawned"
# Check for review votes
bd comments <proposal-id>
For FOLLOWUP_PROPOSAL-N reviews, use the same procedure:
FOLLOWUP_PROPOSAL-N-REVIEW-{axis}-{round}