القائمة
Resolves stuck review findings via a put-up-or-concede exchange. Invoked by the facilitator when a finding survives arbitration without new evidence.
التثبيت باستخدام Codex أو Claude انسخ هذا Prompt والصقه في Codex أو Claude أو مساعد آخر ليراجع صفحة Skill ويثبّتها لك.
استنادا إلى تصنيف SOC المهني
Independent review loop run before delivery in code work. An independent reviewer (Codex, or fresh Codex-style subagents) reads the whole PR against the approved outcome; the lead fixes in-scope functional findings and re-reviews until none remain. Its differentiator is independence and exhaustiveness — a reviewer that fails differently from the authors, run to clean — distinct from the recursive-refinement ladder. Invoked by the team lead from the unified pre-ship gate (code-mode and /swarm:refine) after the ship steps.
Returns the universal governance spec for swarm team runs — hard rules, briefing templates, gate presentation contract, launch mechanics, and pulse setup. The canonical source: invoked by launch.md at Step 1 and by user-authored shortcut commands that cannot read launch.md directly. Per-gate constants live in swarm:gate-presentation.
Returns the frozen gate constants — question, header, option labels and descriptions, digest field-list, and preview content — for every catalog gate. Invoked by the team lead fresh on arrival at each gate and on pulse re-emissions, in the same turn as the render. The transport contract, three renders, partition rule, and authoring rubric live in swarm:workflow-rules.
Code mode operational spec for the team lead. Returns lead identity, facilitator identity, mode-specific rules, suggest-members guidance, and phase arc for code-mode teams.
General mode operational spec for the team lead. Returns lead identity, facilitator identity, suggest-members guidance, and phase arc for general-purpose teams. The silent fallback when outcomes fit no specific mode, and a wrapper base for custom workflows — it has no shortcut command.
Triage mode operational spec for the team lead. Returns lead identity, facilitator identity, mode-specific rules, suggest-members guidance, and phase arc for triage teams that diagnose an issue without changing it.
| name | resolve-dispute |
| user-invocable | false |
| description | Resolves stuck review findings via a put-up-or-concede exchange. Invoked by the facilitator when a finding survives arbitration without new evidence. |
A review finding is stuck. Structure its resolution in three steps.
Step 1 — Frame the dispute. Identify and state aloud:
Step 2 — Send the reviewer this message, substituting [finding] with the actual finding:
Your finding — [finding] — was arbitrated. To keep it open, you must provide ONE of: (a) A concrete failure scenario: specific inputs or conditions that produce wrong behavior (b) A source citation: file, line number, and what it shows (c) A direct counterexample to the arbitration reasoning
One response. No response counts as concession. After that, the facilitator rules and the finding is DECIDED.
Step 3 — Rule and tag.
After the reviewer responds:
DECIDED findings cannot be re-raised without new substance. This enforces the existing "Don't regurgitate decided points" rule.
What this skill must not do:
