writing-precis-reviewer

name	writing-precis-reviewer
description	Legacy-only conversion helper for archived writing précis episodes. It is never selected in a canonical writing episode.
user-invocable	false
disable-model-invocation	true
allowed-tools	Read, Grep, Glob, Agent

Legacy Precis Conversion Reviewer

This helper exists only to inspect an archived, legacy-only .planning/PRECIS.md as conversion input. A canonical writing episode uses one receipt-selected immutable generated plan and whole-plan review; it must not invoke this skill, create a précis review marker, or treat a précis as active authority.

Admission

Before dispatching, use the layout classifier. Proceed only when it reports legacy-only and the caller is preparing conversion. If canonical state exists, stop and use the canonical writing plan-review flow. If legacy and canonical files conflict, fail closed; never merge them.

Procedure

1. Read the legacy précis solely as provenance.
2. Dispatch a read-only reviewer to identify thesis, distinct claims, counterarguments, scope, audience, source support, placeholders, and contradictions.
3. Return findings to the caller; do not write .planning/PRECIS_REVIEWED.md, modify the legacy file, or authorize outlining/drafting.
4. The caller carries the usable findings into a newly authored native plan with ## Writing Intent, ## Claims, ## Counterarguments, ## Source Plan, and related required sections.
5. Require fresh native approval and the canonical independent whole-plan review before implementation.

Return format

Legacy précis conversion findings
- Legacy input: [path]
- Reusable intent / claims / counterarguments: [findings]
- Gaps to resolve in the new plan: [findings]
- Next action: author and approve a fresh canonical writing plan

Red flags

About to	Stop because	Do instead
Invoke this in a canonical episode	It revives retired authority	Use the whole-plan reviewer.
Write a précis review marker	It creates a competing gate	Return findings to the converter.
Draft or outline from the legacy précis	Conversion input is not approved current intent	Create and approve a native plan first.