القائمة
Adversarial self-review gate that re-reads a literature review, comparison, or idea list before it's presented as final, hunting for overclaiming, cherry-picking, and gaps.
التثبيت باستخدام Codex أو Claude انسخ هذا Prompt والصقه في Codex أو Claude أو مساعد آخر ليراجع صفحة Skill ويثبّتها لك.
استنادا إلى تصنيف SOC المهني
Analyzes or compares 2+ papers or methods. Triggers on "compare these papers", "analyze this method", "which is better?".
Verifies every Markdown link citation in `_papers/` and `_ideas/` notes resolves to the correct paper and that the attributed claim actually matches what the paper says. Gate skill — run before finalizing literature_review/go/check outputs.
Documentation generator for public APIs, functions, and modules. Use when exports, signatures, or new modules are added or changed.
Evidence-hierarchy enforcer for research and analysis. Rates every claim by its evidence tier (primary > peer-reviewed > secondary > anecdotal) and refuses to overstate. Use when synthesizing findings or answering factual questions.
Reads and summarizes ONE specific paper. Triggers on "read this paper", "summarize X", or when the user gives a specific paper title/link.
Searches online for ML/AI papers relevant to a topic. Triggers on "find papers about X", "recent research on X", "any papers on this topic?".
| name | critic |
| description | Adversarial self-review gate that re-reads a literature review, comparison, or idea list before it's presented as final, hunting for overclaiming, cherry-picking, and gaps. |
A critic pass is complete when: overclaim check, cherry-pick check, and coverage-gap check have each been explicitly performed and their outcome (found issues or none) is reported.
