write-mcp-host-eval

name	write-mcp-host-eval
description	Generate LLM host simulation evals for MCP servers. Use when asked to test tool discoverability, write mcp_host evals, or validate tool descriptions with real LLM calls. Produces eval datasets and test runners where an LLM discovers and calls tools from natural language scenarios.
metadata	{"author":"gleanwork","version":"1.0.0"}

Write MCP Host Simulation Evals

Generate LLM host simulation evals for MCP servers using @gleanwork/mcp-server-tester. In mcp_host mode, a real LLM receives a natural language scenario and decides which MCP tools to call — testing tool discoverability, parameter clarity, and description quality.

When to Use mcp_host Mode

Use mcp_host mode when you need to verify:

• Does the LLM know which tool to call for a given task?
• Does the LLM fill in parameters correctly without hints?
• Does the tool description accurately represent what the tool does?

Use direct mode instead for:

• Regression testing known inputs/outputs (faster, free, deterministic)
• Testing tool logic and error handling
• Schema validation

mcp_host mode calls a real LLM API. Each test costs ~$0.003–0.02 depending on the provider and tool count.

Prerequisites

Install the Vercel AI SDK and your provider package:

# Pick your provider
npm install ai @ai-sdk/anthropic    # Anthropic
npm install ai @ai-sdk/openai       # OpenAI
npm install ai @ai-sdk/google       # Google
npm install ai @ai-sdk/mistral      # Mistral
npm install ai @ai-sdk/azure        # Azure OpenAI
npm install ai @ai-sdk/deepseek     # DeepSeek
npm install ai @ai-sdk/xai          # xAI (Grok)
npm install ai @ai-sdk/google-vertex  # Vertex AI (Anthropic models)
npm install ai @openrouter/ai-sdk-provider  # OpenRouter

Set the corresponding API key environment variable (e.g., ANTHROPIC_API_KEY, OPENAI_API_KEY).

Step 1 — Understand the Case Structure

mcp_host cases differ from direct mode cases:

Field	Direct mode	mcp_host mode
mode	"direct" (default)	"mcp_host" (required)
toolName	Required	Not used
args	Required	Not used
scenario	Not used	Required — natural language prompt
mcpHostConfig	Not used	Provider, model, host type
expect	Response assertions	Tool call assertions + response assertions

The LLM receives the scenario as a prompt along with all available MCP tools, then decides which tools to call and with what arguments.

Step 2 — Write the Eval Dataset

Basic mcp_host case

{
  "name": "tool-discovery-evals",
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "search-trigger",
      "mode": "mcp_host",
      "description": "LLM should use the search tool for document queries",
      "scenario": "Find recent documents about quarterly planning",
      "mcpHostConfig": {
        "provider": "anthropic",
        "model": "claude-sonnet-4-20250514"
      },
      "expect": {
        "toolsTriggered": {
          "calls": [{ "name": "search", "required": true }]
        }
      }
    }
  ]
}

mcpHostConfig options

"mcpHostConfig": {
  "provider": "anthropic",
  "model": "claude-sonnet-4-20250514",
  "temperature": 0,
  "maxToolCalls": 10,
  "maxTokens": 4096
}

Field	Default	Description
provider	—	Required. One of: anthropic, openai, google, vertex-anthropic, mistral, azure, deepseek, openrouter, xai
model	Provider default	Model identifier (e.g., gpt-4o, claude-sonnet-4-20250514)
hostType	"sdk"	"sdk" (programmatic) or "cli" (spawns CLI process)
temperature	0	LLM temperature (0 = most deterministic)
maxToolCalls	10	Maximum tool call steps
maxTokens	—	Max response tokens
apiKeyEnvVar	—	Override default env var name

CLI host type

For testing with CLI-based hosts like Claude Code:

"mcpHostConfig": {
  "hostType": "cli",
  "cli": {
    "command": "claude",
    "args": ["-p", "{{scenario}}", "--output-format", "stream-json"],
    "outputFormat": "stream-json",
    "timeout": 120000
  }
}

The {{scenario}} placeholder is replaced with the case's scenario value.

Step 3 — Tool Call Assertions

toolsTriggered — Assert which tools were called

"expect": {
  "toolsTriggered": {
    "calls": [
      { "name": "search", "required": true },
      { "name": "get_document", "required": false }
    ],
    "order": "any",
    "exclusive": false
  }
}

Field	Default	Description
calls[].name	—	Tool name to expect
calls[].required	true	Whether this tool MUST have been called
calls[].arguments	—	Expected arguments (partial match)
order	"any"	"any" or "strict" (must appear in listed order)
exclusive	false	If true, no tools outside the list may be called

Argument matching

Exact match (partial — extra keys in the actual call are allowed):

"calls": [{
  "name": "search",
  "arguments": { "query": "quarterly planning" }
}]

Regex match with $pattern:

"calls": [{
  "name": "search",
  "arguments": {
    "query": { "$pattern": "quarterly.*planning" }
  }
}]

Case-insensitive regex with $flags:

"calls": [{
  "name": "search",
  "arguments": {
    "query": { "$pattern": "quarterly", "$flags": "i" }
  }
}]

Mix exact and regex matching:

"calls": [{
  "name": "search",
  "arguments": {
    "query": { "$pattern": "planning" },
    "limit": 10
  }
}]

Strict order

"expect": {
  "toolsTriggered": {
    "calls": [
      { "name": "search", "required": true },
      { "name": "get_document", "required": true }
    ],
    "order": "strict"
  }
}

The LLM must call search before get_document.

Exclusive tool calls

"expect": {
  "toolsTriggered": {
    "calls": [{ "name": "search", "required": true }],
    "exclusive": true
  }
}

The LLM must call ONLY search — any other tool call fails the test.

toolCallCount — Assert number of tool calls

"expect": {
  "toolCallCount": { "min": 1, "max": 3 }
}

"expect": {
  "toolCallCount": { "exact": 2 }
}

Combining tool call and response assertions

"expect": {
  "toolsTriggered": {
    "calls": [{ "name": "search", "required": true }]
  },
  "toolCallCount": { "min": 1, "max": 5 },
  "containsText": "results"
}

Step 4 — Multi-Iteration Accuracy

LLM responses are non-deterministic. Run each case multiple times and measure accuracy:

{
  "id": "search-accuracy",
  "mode": "mcp_host",
  "scenario": "Find documents about MCP testing",
  "mcpHostConfig": { "provider": "anthropic" },
  "iterations": 5,
  "accuracyThreshold": 0.8,
  "expect": {
    "toolsTriggered": {
      "calls": [{ "name": "search", "required": true }]
    }
  }
}

• iterations: 5 — run the case 5 times
• accuracyThreshold: 0.8 — pass if search was triggered in at least 4 of 5 runs (80%)
• Result includes assertionPassRate (0–1) and iterationResults[]

Use iterations for:

• Measuring tool calling reliability across runs
• Setting realistic accuracy thresholds (start with 0.6, tighten over time)
• Comparing tool description variants (A/B testing)

Step 5 — Write the Test Runner

import { test, expect } from '@gleanwork/mcp-server-tester/fixtures/mcp';
import { loadEvalDataset, runEvalDataset } from '@gleanwork/mcp-server-tester';

test('tool discovery evals', async ({ mcp }, testInfo) => {
  const dataset = await loadEvalDataset('./data/host-evals.json');
  const result = await runEvalDataset({ dataset }, { mcp, testInfo });
  expect(result.passed).toBe(result.total);
});

Important: runEvalDataset takes two arguments:

1. Options object — { dataset, concurrency?, ... } — what to run and how
2. Context object — { mcp, testInfo } — Playwright fixtures from your test

Step 6 — Runtime Tool Override Experiments

When comparing tool description or input schema variants, do not mutate the eval dataset. Keep the dataset as the behavioral contract and pass variant data dynamically through runEvalDataset({ toolOverrides }).

Primary path: runVariantExperiment wraps the whole loop — baseline, variant injection, comparison, metric ranking, regression guarding, and a structured apply/reject/inconclusive proposal — in one call, with a proposeVariants callback for iterative agent-driven rounds. Use the optimize-mcp-tool-metadata skill for the full workflow:

import { runVariantExperiment } from '@gleanwork/mcp-server-tester';

const result = await runVariantExperiment(
  {
    dataset,
    variants: [variant],
    metric: 'passRate',
    defaultLlmIterations: 10,
  },
  { mcp, testInfo }
);
console.log(JSON.stringify(result.proposal, null, 2));

The manual two-run path below remains available when you need full control over each run:

import { compareEvalRuns } from '@gleanwork/mcp-server-tester';

const baseline = await runEvalDataset(
  { dataset, defaultLlmIterations: 10 },
  { mcp, testInfo }
);

const variant = {
  id: 'search-description-v2',
  description: 'Clarify that search is for internal docs and policies.',
  tools: {
    search: {
      description:
        'Search internal company documents, policies, wiki pages, and announcements. Use this when the user asks to find company information by topic.',
    },
  },
};

const candidate = await runEvalDataset(
  {
    dataset,
    defaultLlmIterations: 10,
    toolOverrides: variant,
  },
  { mcp, testInfo }
);

const comparison = compareEvalRuns({
  baseline,
  candidate,
  labels: {
    baseline: 'baseline',
    candidate: variant.id,
  },
});

For agent-driven remediation loops:

• Generate variants as runtime data, not eval dataset edits.
• Compare baseline and candidate results with compareEvalRuns.
• Report pass-rate delta, tool precision/recall/F1 deltas, improved cases, regressed cases, and unchanged failures.
• Emit a structured override proposal. Do not edit MCP server source unless the user explicitly asks for source remediation.

Step 7 — Project-Based A/B Testing

Use project-based A/B testing when the variant is not limited to runtime tool metadata. This is the right path for changed tool behavior, changed auth/config/transport, different server builds, changed response shapes, or any experiment that needs to run against a real MCP server variant.

// playwright.config.ts
export default defineConfig({
  projects: [
    {
      name: 'baseline',
      use: {
        mcpConfig: {
          transport: 'stdio',
          command: 'node',
          args: ['./dist/server-v1.js'],
        },
      },
    },
    {
      name: 'server-v2',
      use: {
        mcpConfig: {
          transport: 'stdio',
          command: 'node',
          args: ['./dist/server-v2.js'],
        },
      },
    },
  ],
});

The MCP reporter groups results by project, letting users compare pass rates side-by-side.

Choose the comparison mode deliberately:

• Use toolOverrides for descriptions and input schemas only.
• Use project-based A/B testing for real server, config, behavior, or response changes.

Complete Example

data/host-evals.json

{
  "name": "tool-discovery-evals",
  "description": "Validate that LLMs can discover and use tools correctly",
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "search-basic",
      "mode": "mcp_host",
      "description": "LLM triggers search for document queries",
      "scenario": "Find recent documents about quarterly planning",
      "mcpHostConfig": { "provider": "anthropic" },
      "tags": ["discovery", "search"],
      "expect": {
        "toolsTriggered": {
          "calls": [{ "name": "search", "required": true }]
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "search-with-args",
      "mode": "mcp_host",
      "description": "LLM passes appropriate search arguments",
      "scenario": "Search for onboarding documents for new engineers",
      "mcpHostConfig": { "provider": "anthropic" },
      "tags": ["discovery", "search", "args"],
      "expect": {
        "toolsTriggered": {
          "calls": [
            {
              "name": "search",
              "required": true,
              "arguments": {
                "query": { "$pattern": "onboarding.*engineer", "$flags": "i" }
              }
            }
          ]
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "multi-tool-workflow",
      "mode": "mcp_host",
      "description": "LLM chains search then get_document",
      "scenario": "Find the latest onboarding guide and show me its contents",
      "mcpHostConfig": {
        "provider": "anthropic",
        "maxToolCalls": 5
      },
      "tags": ["workflow", "multi-tool"],
      "expect": {
        "toolsTriggered": {
          "calls": [
            { "name": "search", "required": true },
            { "name": "get_document", "required": true }
          ],
          "order": "strict"
        },
        "toolCallCount": { "min": 2, "max": 5 }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "search-accuracy",
      "mode": "mcp_host",
      "description": "Search tool is reliably triggered",
      "scenario": "Find documents about MCP testing best practices",
      "mcpHostConfig": { "provider": "anthropic" },
      "iterations": 5,
      "accuracyThreshold": 0.8,
      "tags": ["accuracy", "search"],
      "expect": {
        "toolsTriggered": {
          "calls": [{ "name": "search", "required": true }]
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "no-tool-abuse",
      "mode": "mcp_host",
      "description": "LLM only calls search, not unrelated tools",
      "scenario": "What documents do we have about API design?",
      "mcpHostConfig": { "provider": "anthropic" },
      "tags": ["precision"],
      "expect": {
        "toolsTriggered": {
          "calls": [{ "name": "search", "required": true }],
          "exclusive": true
        }
      }
    }
  ]
}

tests/host-evals.spec.ts

import { test, expect } from '@gleanwork/mcp-server-tester/fixtures/mcp';
import { loadEvalDataset, runEvalDataset } from '@gleanwork/mcp-server-tester';

test.describe('mcp host simulation evals', () => {
  test('all tool discovery cases pass', async ({ mcp }, testInfo) => {
    const dataset = await loadEvalDataset('./data/host-evals.json');
    const result = await runEvalDataset({ dataset }, { mcp, testInfo });
    expect(result.passed).toBe(result.total);
  });

  test('accuracy cases meet thresholds', async ({ mcp }, testInfo) => {
    const dataset = await loadEvalDataset('./data/host-evals.json');
    const result = await runEvalDataset(
      { dataset, filterTags: ['accuracy'] },
      { mcp, testInfo }
    );
    expect(result.passed).toBe(result.total);
  });
});

Cost Considerations

Provider	Approximate cost per test
Anthropic Claude Sonnet	~$0.003–0.01
OpenAI GPT-4o	~$0.005–0.02
Google Gemini	~$0.001–0.005

Costs scale with tool count (more tools = larger system prompt) and maxToolCalls.

Recommendations:

• Use mode: "direct" for regression testing (free, fast)
• Use mode: "mcp_host" selectively for tool description quality validation
• Set temperature: 0 for most reproducible results
• Start with iterations: 3 and accuracyThreshold: 0.6, tighten as descriptions improve
• Use exclusive: true to catch tool confusion early

Checklist

Before finishing, verify:

• Every case has "mode": "mcp_host"
• Every case has a scenario (natural language prompt, not tool args)
• mcpHostConfig.provider matches an installed @ai-sdk/<provider> package
• The corresponding API key env var is set (e.g., ANTHROPIC_API_KEY)
• $pattern regex strings are valid (test with new RegExp(pattern))
• iterations and accuracyThreshold are set together (one without the other is a mistake)
• exclusive: true cases have all expected tools in the calls array
• Test runner imports from @gleanwork/mcp-server-tester/fixtures/mcp
• runEvalDataset receives two separate arguments: options object and context object
• Dataset file runs: npx playwright test tests/my-host-evals.spec.ts