public-review

name	public-review
description	This skill should be used when an architect needs to understand Taiwan's public review (公開閱覽) procedures for government procurement, including how to review tender documents, provide professional feedback, and evaluate project opportunities before formal bidding.
user-invocable	true
metadata	{"class":"C"}

Public Review (公開閱覽)

This skill covers Taiwan's public review (公開閱覽) process under the Government Procurement Act, a pre-tender procedure where procurement documents are made available for industry feedback. Invoke this skill when reviewing upcoming procurement opportunities, preparing feedback on tender documents, or evaluating whether to participate in subsequent formal bidding.

---

Section 1: Legal Framework

1.1 Governing Provisions

Law	Article	Content
Government Procurement Act (政府採購法)	Art. 34	Public review requirements for tender documents
Enforcement Rules	Art. 43	Detailed procedures for public review process
Public Construction Technical Service Contract Template	Full text	Standard contract clauses reference

1.2 When Public Review is Required

Condition	Requirement
Above announcement threshold (≧ NTD 1,000,000)	May conduct public review
Complex or large-scale projects	Recommended by PCC guidelines
Projects with novel technical requirements	Recommended to reduce disputes
Above audit threshold (≧ NTD 50,000,000)	Strongly recommended

---

Section 2: Public Review Process

2.1 Process Flow

1. Publication
   └─ Procuring entity posts notice on Government e-Procurement System
   └─ Documents made available for download/inspection

2. Review Period
   └─ Typically 5-7 working days
   └─ Minimum period per PCC guidelines

3. Feedback Submission
   └─ Written comments submitted by interested parties
   └─ Format: per procuring entity requirements (usually written/email)

4. Agency Response
   └─ Procuring entity compiles all feedback
   └─ Public response to each comment (accepted/rejected with rationale)

5. Document Revision
   └─ Tender documents revised based on accepted feedback
   └─ Revision history documented

6. Formal Tender
   └─ Revised documents used for formal bidding process

---

Section 3: Key Review Areas for Architects

3.1 Document Review Checklist

Area	What to Check	Common Issues
Scope Definition	Clear work items, deliverables	Ambiguous scope, missing items
Fee Calculation	Alignment with official fee standards	Below-standard fees, unclear payment schedule
Design Timeline	Reasonable duration per project complexity	Unrealistic deadlines
Evaluation Criteria	Weight distribution, objectivity	Over-emphasis on price vs. quality
Contract Terms	Risk allocation, liability clauses	Unfair risk transfer to service provider
Penalty Clauses	Delay penalties, liquidated damages	Excessive penalty rates
Technical Requirements	Specifications clarity	Restrictive specs limiting competition

3.2 Feedback Categories

Category	Priority	Example
Legal compliance	High	Contract clause contradicts Procurement Act
Fee adequacy	High	Fee below 機關委託技術服務廠商計費標準 minimum
Timeline feasibility	High	Design period insufficient for required regulatory reviews
Risk allocation	Medium	Unfair force majeure clause
Technical clarity	Medium	Ambiguous performance specifications
Competition fairness	Medium	Specs written for specific vendor

---

Section 4: Strategic Considerations

4.1 Benefits of Participation

• Influence tender conditions before they become binding
• Early insight into upcoming project opportunities
• Build relationship with procuring entities
• Demonstrate expertise and market awareness

4.2 Best Practices

Practice	Rationale
Submit specific, actionable feedback	Generic complaints are less likely to result in changes
Reference official standards and regulations	Strengthens the basis for requested changes
Coordinate through professional associations (建築師公會)	Collective feedback carries more weight
Maintain written records of all submissions	Documentation for potential future disputes
Attend pre-bid meetings if offered	Additional context beyond written documents

---

Section 5: MCP Tool Integration

# Search Government Procurement Act provisions on public review
taiwan-building-code_search_building_code(query="政府採購法 公開閱覽")

# Search interpretations on tender document requirements
taiwan-building-code_search_building_interpretations(query="招標文件 公開閱覽")

# Download procurement-related specifications
pcc-downloader_download_specification(chapter="procurement", keyword="公開閱覽", format="pdf")