| name | critical-review |
| description | Use when reviewing a plan, PRD, implementation, diff, or completion claim. Focuses on correctness, regressions, missing tests, and risk rather than style. |
Critical Review
Review as an independent risk reducer.
Review Priority
- Correctness bugs.
- User-visible behavior regressions.
- Security, privacy, and data integrity risk.
- Missing tests or weak validation.
- Rollback and operational risk.
- Maintainability only when it affects future correctness.
Findings
Each finding should include:
- severity
- evidence
- affected file or behavior
- why it matters
- smallest recommended fix
If there are no findings, say that explicitly and list residual risks or verification gaps.
Do not dilute the review with style-only comments unless asked.