reviewer-simulator

name	reviewer-simulator
description	Simulate critical top-conference reviewers for a draft, producing likely strengths, weaknesses, score drivers, clarity objections, missing experiments, novelty concerns, and rebuttal-preparation notes.
version	0.1.0

Reviewer Simulator

Use this skill for adversarial pre-submission review.

Workflow

1. Read the abstract, intro, method, experiments, and limitations if available.
2. Simulate at least three reviewer lenses: supportive expert, skeptical expert, and broad-area reviewer.
3. Score novelty, correctness, significance, clarity, reproducibility, and fit.
4. Convert critiques into fixable paper tasks.

Output

Return Simulated reviews, Likely score drivers, Fatal risks, Fix list, and Rebuttal traps.