critic-attack

name	critic-attack
description	Attack an advocate's case with multiple arguments rated by severity.
execution	subagent
prompt	./prompt.md
input	winner, advocate_case
dependencies	{"sops":["spawn-agent"]}

Critic Attack

Attacks an advocate's case from multiple angles, producing rated arguments that expose weaknesses, logical gaps, and unsupported claims. The critic's job is to find every legitimate vulnerability.

Execution

Spawns a subagent with the critic role. The subagent receives the winner context and the advocate's case, then attacks the case systematically.

Why Subagent

• Role isolation prevents sympathy with the advocate's position
• Critic must attack without mercy or compromise
• Separation ensures the attack is genuine, not performative

HARD-GATE

Output must include:

• = 3 distinct attack arguments

• Severity rating for each (HIGH/MEDIUM/LOW)
• Evidence or reasoning for each attack
• At least 1 attack targeting the advocate's strongest point

Available SOPs

Optional, no fixed order; the final leaf is always a sop.

SOP	When to use
spawn-agent	Spawn a customized CC subagent with full MCP tool access. Used by SOPs that declare execution: subagent.