| name | evaluate-reviews |
| description | Evaluate review comments from the conversation and determine which are valid |
The conversation already contains one or more sets of review comments from previous review steps (e.g. /review-changes, /review-style). Your job is to evaluate all of them and determine which points are actually valid.
For each review point raised in the conversation:
- Look at the actual code (not just the diff) to determine whether the point is truly valid
- Discard any points that are false positives — but keep nitpicks, since even small improvements matter
Remember: we want the best and cleanest possible code long term. We do not want to introduce any technical debt. If something could be improved, it should be improved now — not deferred for later.
Present your evaluation as a list. For each original review point, state whether it is valid or not, and briefly explain why. Do not make any changes to the code.