Menu
Plan-phase Review Gate debate — pi-messenger threads, lane YAML, bus tools for parent orchestrator.
Install with Codex or Claude Copy this prompt, paste it into Codex, Claude, or another assistant, and let it review the skill page and install it for you.
Based on SOC occupation classification
Commit staged git changes with configurable message format and Co-authored-by trailer from .pi/auto-commit.json. Use when the user asks to commit, when /harness-auto or harness run completion requires a commit, or before any git commit — never use raw git commit -m.
Compile task-specific harness context using context-mode and graphify. Use for architecture questions, large codebase context before harness-plan or harness-run. NEVER use lean-ctx on harness paths.
Structured user decisions via ask_user for harness setup, planning, and governance forks. Use with /harness-setup, /harness-plan, harness-auto plan phase, and when agents emit human_required.
Deprecated — use harness-review skill and /harness-review for the full post-run gate. This file remains as a pointer for older prompts.
Enforce harness governance phases, policy gates, budgets, and promotion rules. Use during execute, evaluate, merge, or when interpreting policy-gate / budget-guard messages.
Bootstrap ls-lint filename rules for harness projects — seed naming.manifest.json, generate merge-safe .ls-lint.yml, and document bootstrap vs --force sync. Use during /harness-setup, when adding ls-lint to a repo, or when .ls-lint.yml is missing or out of date.
| name | harness-debate-plan |
| description | Plan-phase Review Gate debate — pi-messenger threads, lane YAML, bus tools for parent orchestrator. |
Review Gate RACI: parent is chair; lane agents provide structured evidence in sequence.
Use when running Phase 5 of /harness-plan — Fagan-style structured inspection per focus (spec | wbs | schedule | quality). Parent is chair; within-round dialogue (claims → rebuttals → clarifications → counters → integrate).
| Agent | Role |
|---|---|
hypothesis-validator | Blind verifier (R1 only) |
plan-evaluator | Inspector (checklist) |
plan-adversary | Red team |
sprint-contract-auditor | DoD auditor (quality or round ≥4) |
review-integrator | Recorder / integration PM |
Do not add agents for fast profile — reduce focuses/rounds only.
| Profile | Mode | Focuses | When |
|---|---|---|---|
full | threaded | all four | High risk, fork, open questions |
standard | threaded | all four | Default med risk |
light | threaded | spec, quality | Low risk, high-confidence research |
fast | consolidated | spec, quality (one round) | Clear stack, no open questions; escalate to threaded on blockers |
Eligibility: harness_plan_debate_eligibility then harness_debate_open({ debate_profile, required_focuses }).
harness_debate_open({})
plan-<run_id> (tool normalizes wrong ids)..pi/harness/runs/<run_id>/debate-messenger/.Budget caps vary by profile (see plan-debate-eligibility.ts); standard plan profile uses min_focus_rounds=4, debate_global_cap=80000.
Call harness_debate_focus_coverage until all required focuses (from eligibility) appear in submitted review rounds and last review_gate_ready: true.
hypothesis-validator (blind verifier) before inspector.plan-evaluator (inspector) → lane + messenger claim.harness_messenger_read_round → plan-adversary (red team) → rebuttal.unresolved_claim_ids and exchange_count < max for profile.sprint-contract-auditor (DoD) when focus is quality or round ≥ 4.review-integrator (recorder) → harness_debate_submit_round.One subagent per subagent call — never batch debate lanes.
Lane YAML + messenger messages auto-apply on subagent complete (harness-debate-next-step). Fallback: harness_debate_apply_lane.
Resume: harness_debate_round_status({ round_index: N }) → run listed next_tool.
| kind | from | when |
|---|---|---|
| claim | PlanEvaluatorAgent | after evaluator lane |
| rebuttal | PlanAdversaryAgent | in_reply_to claim ids |
| clarification | PlanEvaluatorAgent | addresses open claims |
| counter | PlanAdversaryAgent | final pass; concede or dispute |
| integrate | ReviewIntegratorAgent | on submit_round |
harness_debate_consensus when focus coverage complete. approve_plan is hard-gated on lanes, messenger dialogue completeness, bus rounds, consensus not block.
Do not approve_plan on policy_decision: block. On human_required → ask_user first.
Rubrics: use the focus-specific checklist ids passed by the parent for the active round.