issue-to-pr

name	issue-to-pr
description	Use when you have a GitHub issue and want to open a PR carrying an implementation plan — guides fetching the issue, brainstorming an approach with the user, writing a plan file, and pushing a plan-only PR ready for implementation (manual or automated).

Issue to PR

Convert a GitHub issue into an actionable PR whose only content is an implementation plan. The implementation itself happens in a follow-up commit (by you, a teammate, or an automated agent triggered by the PR body).

When to use

• An issue has been triaged and you want to capture an approach before writing code.
• Your repo runs an automated executor that watches PRs for a trigger token in the body.
• You want a reviewable plan that lives in Git history, not just a Slack thread.

When NOT to use

• Trivial one-line fixes — go straight to a PR.
• Spike / experimental work that doesn't yet warrant an issue.
• Work where the plan is the implementation (e.g., a docs PR) — write the docs.

Workflow

1. Receive issue number or URL.
2. Fetch the issue with gh.
3. Brainstorm with the user (clarify intent, explore approaches, agree on scope).
4. Write a plan file.
5. Create a branch, commit the plan, push, and open a PR.

Step 1: Parse input

Accept any of these forms:

• 123 → issue #123 in the current repo
• https://github.com/<owner>/<repo>/issues/123 → issue #123
• <owner>/<repo>#123 → issue #123 in a specific repo

Step 2: Fetch the issue

gh issue view <number> --json title,body,labels,assignees

Summarize for the user: title, current state, what the issue is asking for, any open questions.

Step 3: Brainstorm

REQUIRED: invoke a brainstorming skill (superpowers:brainstorming if available) before writing the plan. Otherwise have an explicit discussion with the user.

The goal is to:

• Confirm user intent (the issue may be ambiguous).
• Surface multiple approaches and their tradeoffs.
• Lock down the scope of this PR (what is in, what is deferred).

Do not skip brainstorming. Do not write a plan without prior discussion.

Step 4: Write the plan file

Save to docs/plans/issue-<number>-<slug>.md (adjust the path to whatever the repo uses):

# <Title from brainstorming>

Issue: #<number>

## Context

<Brief problem statement — what's broken or missing.>

## Approach

<The chosen approach from brainstorming and why it was chosen over the alternatives.>

## Tasks

1. <Specific, ordered implementation task>
2. <Another task>
3. ...

## Acceptance Criteria

- <Observable criterion from the issue or brainstorming>
- <Another>

## Out of scope

- <Anything explicitly deferred>

Keep tasks small and ordered. Each task should be a clear unit a reviewer can check off.

Step 5: Create the branch and PR

NUMBER=<issue-number>
SLUG=<short-kebab-slug>
TITLE=<title>

git checkout -b "issue-${NUMBER}-${SLUG}"
git add "docs/plans/issue-${NUMBER}-${SLUG}.md"
git commit -m "Add plan for #${NUMBER}: ${TITLE}"
git push -u origin "issue-${NUMBER}-${SLUG}"

gh pr create --title "Fix #${NUMBER}: ${TITLE}" --body "$(cat <<EOF
[action]

## Summary

<1-3 sentence summary from brainstorming.>

Closes #${NUMBER}
EOF
)"

Important:

• Commit only the plan file. No implementation code in this commit.
• If your repo uses an automation trigger (e.g., [action], /claude implement), put it as the first line of the PR body. Many trigger-watchers only parse the first line.
• The branch name pattern issue-<n>-<slug> matches the convention from CONVENTIONS.md.

Trigger token note

Different teams use different automation triggers. Check the repo's CLAUDE.md or .github/workflows/ to confirm what (if anything) parses the PR body. Common patterns: [action], /agent run, claude: implement. If no automation is configured, you can drop the trigger line — the PR is still useful as a reviewable plan.

Common mistakes

Mistake	Fix
Skipping brainstorming	Always brainstorm before planning. The issue text is rarely complete.
Trigger token not on line 1	If your automation expects it first, putting it elsewhere silently does nothing.
Committing code along with the plan	Plan-only PR. Implementation goes in a follow-up commit.
Generic plan	Use specifics from the brainstorming. "Refactor X" is not a plan; "Extract function foo from bar.rs lines 40-90" is.
Wrong issue ref in PR body	Closes #<n> only auto-closes if the PR's base is the default branch.