Menu
Simulate peer review on an academic LaTeX paper draft. Generates 5 reviewer personas, runs independent reviews with 5-dimension scoring, devils-advocate stress tests, editorial synthesis decision.
Install with Codex or Claude Copy this prompt, paste it into Codex, Claude, or another assistant, and let it review the skill page and install it for you.
Based on SOC occupation classification
Remove AI writing patterns from English text with academic-aware overrides. Auto-detects LaTeX context for passive voice, hyphenated compounds, title case, curly quotes handling.
Placeholder for Phase C bilingual annotator. Adds sentence-level Chinese %-comments to English LaTeX source files. Currently not implemented.
Process external reviewer comments on an academic paper submission. Parses comments, classifies Major/Minor/Editorial, builds RevisionRoadmap, drafts response letter in Reviewer-Action-Change format.
Manage references.bib in an academic LaTeX paper project. Add bibtex entries, validate natbib citation commands, check citation compliance (orphan citations, self-citation ratio, source currency).
Compile an academic LaTeX paper project with pdflatex and bibtex. Diagnoses LaTeX errors, checks page-limit compliance, runs bibtex, fixes undefined references and overfull-hbox warnings.
Generate publication-quality matplotlib or seaborn figures for an academic LaTeX paper. 11 EECS chart types (bar, line, heatmap, ROC, ablation, scaling). Output to figures/*.pdf.
| name | paper-review |
| description | Simulate peer review on an academic LaTeX paper draft. Generates 5 reviewer personas, runs independent reviews with 5-dimension scoring, devils-advocate stress tests, editorial synthesis decision. |
| argument-hint | [--sections=<list>] |
| paths | ["**/main.tex","**/sections/*.tex","**/.paper-config.yml"] |
| allowed-tools | Read Skill |
Simulate peer review on an academic LaTeX paper draft. Runs the full review pipeline: 5 reviewer personas -> 5-dimension scoring -> devils-advocate stress test -> editorial synthesis decision -> revision roadmap.
Same as paper-draft. If no .paper-config.yml is found, stop.
$ARGUMENTS for optional --sections=<comma-list> to limit review
to specific sections (default: review the whole paper).peer_reviewer agent. The agent:
subfieldReviewReport with
5-dimension scores (originality, rigor, evidence, coherence, writing)ReviewReport includes recommendation (accept/minor/major/reject)devils_advocate agent to run 7 stress tests on the same
draft (counter-arguments, cherry-picking detection, "So What?" test,
etc.). Output is a 6th ReviewReport with reviewer_id: DA.editorial_synthesizer agent to weight all 6 reports by
confidence and produce a final decision plus a RevisionRoadmap.build/review_report.md (using the
templates/review_report.md template format).This skill orchestrates multiple agents that produce:
ReviewReport (one per reviewer, 5+1 total)RevisionRoadmap (final, from editorial_synthesizer)See references/handoff_schemas.md for full schemas.
/paper-revise (when external reviewer comments arrive) to compare with
this simulated review/paper-draft <section> to address the highest-priority items from the
RevisionRoadmap