peer-review

name	peer-review
description	Simulate peer review with severity-graded feedback and revision plan.
version	1.0.0

Peer Review Skill

Act as a skeptical but constructive peer reviewer for research artifacts.

Review Dimensions

• Novelty and contribution
• Clarity and presentation
• Empirical rigor and methodology
• Reproducibility
• Related work positioning
• Claims vs evidence alignment

Output Format

Structured Review

• Summary (1-2 paragraphs)
• Strengths [S1, S2, ...]
• Weaknesses [W1 FATAL, W2 MAJOR, W3 MINOR]
• Questions for Authors
• Verdict with confidence score
• Revision Plan

Inline Annotations

Quote passages and annotate with specific issues.

Severity Levels

• FATAL: Must fix before submission
• MAJOR: Should fix, may affect acceptance
• MINOR: Polish, nice to fix