Menu
Unified critique for plans, specs, OR task artifacts. Auto-detects target. Spawns auditors. Commits tasks to DB when READY. Use "critique", "review", "is this ready".
Install with Codex or Claude Copy this prompt, paste it into Codex, Claude, or another assistant, and let it review the skill page and install it for you.
Based on SOC occupation classification
Guide CLAUDE.md updates based on doc-guard suggestions. This skill should be used when updating documentation, fixing docs, addressing doc-guard suggestions, or updating CLAUDE.md. Activates when user requests "update documentation", "fix docs", "doc-guard suggestions", or "update CLAUDE.md".
Monitor blocked workers and help respond to them. Loop checks ft inbox, shows blocked workers, lets you respond naturally.
Adds tasks to FormalTask with mandatory discovery and validated criteria. Use when "add task", "create task", or "/task-add". For batch creation, use /epic-decompose instead.
Groups uncommitted changes into logical commits, walks through each grouping for approval, then optionally syncs with remote. Resolves merge conflicts interactively with context from recent remote and local history. Use when "commit my changes", "group commits", "smart commit", "commit and sync", or "organize my changes". Never resolves conflicts without user confirmation.
Systematic debugging with graded exploration and agent escalation. MUST BE USED when encountering errors, test failures, or unexpected behavior.
Decompose plan -> specs OR specs -> tasks. Auto-detects stage. Use when "decompose", "break down", or after /critique APPROVED. For initial planning, use /plan instead.
| name | critique |
| description | Unified critique for plans, specs, OR task artifacts. Auto-detects target. Spawns auditors. Commits tasks to DB when READY. Use "critique", "review", "is this ready". |
| argument-hint | <project-name|artifact-dir> [--skip-skeptic] [--force-necessity] |
| inherit | ["review"] |
| tools | ["auggie","warpgrep"] |
| spawns_subagents | true |
| ultrathink | true |
| required_todos | ["detect-target","read-target","check-regression-round-2-only","spawn-auditors","resolve-auditor-conflicts","synthesize","publish"] |
Steps declare dependencies via consumes/produces frontmatter.
Execute steps whose inputs are all satisfied — parallel when independent.
| Step | Consumes | Produces |
|---|---|---|
| detect-target | user-request | target-type, target-paths |
| read-target | target-type, target-paths | target-content, claims |
→ Read and follow: ~/.claude/skills/critique/steps/task-critique.md
STOP — task path complete.
| Step | Consumes | Produces | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| regression-check | target-content | regression-findings | Round 2+ only |
| spawn-auditors | target-content, target-type | auditor-findings | Parallel auditors |
| resolve-conflicts | auditor-findings | verified-findings | |
| synthesis | verified-findings, target-content | critique-verdict |
→ Execute in dependency order. For each step:
~/.claude/skills/critique/steps/<name>.md!cat ~/.claude/skills/_shared/review.md