| name | verification-with-scenarios |
| description | How to integrate scenario evaluation into verification reports. |
| for | verifier |
Scenario Evaluation Section
Every verification report includes a ## Scenario Evaluation section placed
after the spec-matching section.
With Scenarios Present
For each scenario file found in scenarios/{project}/ (excluding _template.md
and satisfaction.md):
- State the scenario title.
- Describe how the implementation handles it.
- Judge whether the scenario is satisfied.
Failed scenarios are described with the same specificity as failed spec
requirements — state exactly what the implementation does and what it should do.
Without Scenarios
When no scenarios exist for the project, include the section with:
No scenario holdouts found for this project.
Scoring
Scenario evaluation contributes to but does not solely determine the satisfaction
score. A strong spec match with poor scenario coverage is still a concern worth
documenting in the report.
Meta-Scenario
Evaluate factory infrastructure tasks directionally against
scenarios/meta/factory-itself.md: does this change move the factory closer to
or further from the meta-scenario? Document the reasoning. Do not apply pass/fail.