Menu
Run the Agentic Reviewer academic paper review pipeline for a paper and target journal or conference.
Install with Codex or Claude Copy this prompt, paste it into Codex, Claude, or another assistant, and let it review the skill page and install it for you.
Based on SOC occupation classification
| name | review-paper |
| description | Run the Agentic Reviewer academic paper review pipeline for a paper and target journal or conference. |
| license | MIT |
Run the repository's paper review workflow from prompts/editor-in-chief.txt.
Inputs required from the user:
papers/If either input is missing, ask for it before starting.
reports/<journal-slug>/<YYYY-MM-DD-HHMMSS>/.00-session-info.md.paper-converter agent to convert it.context/<journal-slug>/ for cached journal context.re-explore, reuse cached context only when all four files exist:
scope-and-criteria.mdrecent-papers-analysis.mdstyle-guide.mdreputation-profile.mdscope-explorerrecent-papers-explorerstyle-guide-explorerreputation-explorerscope-reviewermethodology-reviewerwriting-style-reviewerstatistics-reviewerethics-reviewerreport-compiler.All session artifacts must be written to the timestamped report directory:
reports/<journal-slug>/<YYYY-MM-DD-HHMMSS>/
Do not write review artifacts to reviews/.
Do not commit changes unless the user explicitly asks.
Merges all individual reviewer assessments into a single comprehensive review report with ratings, recommendations, and actionable feedback. Use when all five reviewer outputs exist and the final report needs to be compiled.
Converts non-Markdown papers (PDF, DOCX, PPTX, XLSX, HTML, etc.) to Markdown using markitdown. Use when a paper file needs to be converted before the review pipeline can process it.
Researches a journal's aims, scope, acceptance criteria, article types, target audience, and editorial policies. Use when journal scope context is missing or needs refreshing before a paper review.
Downloads and deeply analyzes the full text of recent papers from an academic journal using markitdown to convert PDFs to Markdown. Use when recent-papers context is missing or needs refreshing before a paper review.
Profiles a journal's reputation, impact factor, indexing status, editorial board, acceptance rates, and predatory status. Use when journal reputation context is missing or needs refreshing before a paper review.
Extracts detailed formatting and style requirements from a journal's author guidelines. Use when style-guide context is missing or needs refreshing before a paper review.