persona-probe

name	persona-probe
description	Start project 时用 8 种 stakeholder 视角（reviewer / PI / 同领域学生 / 跨领域学者 / 工业界 / 政策制定者 / 中文用户 / 复现者）各提 3 个问题，作为后续 AskQuestion 的弹药库。Use when user says "persona probe", "8 stakeholder", "reviewer 视角", "各角度问题", "stakeholder questions", "想问题".
argument-hint	[topic-or-proposal-md]
allowed-tools	Read, Write, Agent

/persona-probe — 8-Persona Stakeholder Probe

借鉴 autoresearch (uditgoenka) /probe。NOVELTY gate 必备产物。

Overview

8 个固定 persona × 3 question each = 24 question 弹药库。

Persona	关心点
Reviewer (顶会)	novelty / soundness / experiment rigor
PI (你导师)	story / position in lab roadmap
同领域 PhD	reproducibility / hyperparam sensitivity
跨领域学者	accessibility / 跨场景 generalization
工业界 ML engineer	inference cost / deployment friction
政策制定者 / ethicist	bias / dual-use / safety
中文社区用户	localization / Chinese-data 适配
复现者 (3 年后)	environment / data / ckpt 可获得性

When to Use

• Stage 1 NOVELTY gate 前
• 任何重大决策（如换 baseline）前

Workflow

1. Read input topic / proposal
2. 对每个 persona，prompt sub-agent: 「from $persona's POV, what are the 3 most uncomfortable questions you'd ask about $proposal?」
3. 汇总 → idea-stage/persona_questions.md
4. 每题给 placeholder answer (TBD by user/agent in Stage 4 verify)

Output

• idea-stage/persona_questions.md — 8 sections × 3 questions

Composition

• NOVELTY gate 检查本 skill 输出存在 + 行数 ≥ 24
• Stage 4 /sprint-contract verify 字段引用本 skill 输出
• Stage 8 /rebuttal 优先答 reviewer persona 的问题