arc-journaling

name	arc-journaling
description	Use when the user asks to journal session reflections (/arcforge:arc-journaling), when the PreCompact hook triggers, or at end of a significant work session

Session Diary Capture

Overview

Capture session reflections as structured diary entries for the learning cycle (diary → reflect → instincts). This is for deliberate reflection and pattern extraction — NOT for session continuity. For saving/resuming work across sessions, use /arc-managing-sessions save and /arc-managing-sessions resume instead.

Quick Reference

Task	Command
Get diary path	node "${SKILL_ROOT}/scripts/diary.js" path --project {p} --date {d} --session {s}
Save diary	node "${SKILL_ROOT}/scripts/diary.js" save --project {p} --date {d} --session {s} --content "{content}"
Key principle	Reflect from memory, NOT by reading files
Permission	NEVER auto-save - always ask first
Template location	See "Template" section below

Infrastructure Commands

Node.js utilities handle file paths and directory creation. Optional but recommended.

Set SKILL_ROOT from skill loader header (# SKILL_ROOT: ...):

: "${SKILL_ROOT:=${ARCFORGE_ROOT:-}/skills/arc-journaling}"
if [ ! -d "$SKILL_ROOT" ]; then
  echo "ERROR: SKILL_ROOT=$SKILL_ROOT does not exist. Set ARCFORGE_ROOT or SKILL_ROOT manually." >&2
  exit 1
fi

Save diary to correct location:

node "${SKILL_ROOT}/scripts/diary.js" save \
  --project {project} \
  --date {YYYY-MM-DD} \
  --session {sessionId} \
  --content "{diary_content}"

Verify path (for debugging):

node "${SKILL_ROOT}/scripts/diary.js" path \
  --project {project} \
  --date {YYYY-MM-DD} \
  --session {sessionId}

Core distinction:

• Diary = observations, context, decisions made (stored in session directory)
• Evolve = instinct combination (the dashboard Evolve action — arcforge learn dashboard — combines related instincts into a successor candidate)

Storage: ~/.arcforge/diaries/{project}/{YYYY-MM-DD}/diary-{sessionId}.md

Pre-Diary Check (Noise Gate)

Before creating a diary entry, verify at least ONE of these criteria is met:

• Non-trivial decision was made (architecture, tool choice, approach)
• Challenge was solved (debugging, workaround found)
• User preference was expressed (explicit or implicit)
• Technique was discovered (new pattern, integration insight)

Auto-skip these sessions (no diary needed):

• Pure Q&A (answering questions without making changes)
• Retrying the same operation (build failures, test reruns)
• Pure exploration (reading files without decisions)
• Trivial fixes (typos, formatting, single-line changes)

This is a soft gate: Claude judges based on conversation memory. User can always override by invoking arc-journaling explicitly.

When to Use

• User invokes /arcforge:arc-journaling
• PreCompact hook triggers (conversation getting long)
• End of significant work session
• After important design decisions
• When user says "remember this" or "note this down"

When NOT to Use

• Quick Q&A sessions (< 5 tool calls)
• Pure research without decisions
• Already captured in previous diary entry this session
• Pattern extraction needed (use arc-recalling instead)
• Fails Pre-Diary Check — unless user explicitly requests

Process

1. Reflect on Conversation (Context-First)

Review the conversation from memory. DO NOT read files to gather context.

Ask yourself:

• What decisions were made and why?
• What preferences did the user express?
• What worked well? What didn't?
• What context would help next session?

2. Fill Template Sections

Use this diary template:

# Session Diary: {project}

**Date:** {YYYY-MM-DD}
**Session ID:** {sessionId}

## Decisions Made

- [Decision]: [Rationale]

## User Preferences Observed

- [Preference observed]

## What Worked Well

- [Technique or approach that succeeded]

## Challenges & Solutions

- **Challenge**: [What went wrong]
- **Solution**: [How resolved]
- **Generalizable?**: [Yes/No - pre-flags for arc-reflecting]

## PR/Review Feedback (if any)

- [Feedback]: [Action taken]

## Context for Next Session

- [Key context to remember]

---

_Captured at {timestamp}_

3. Save to Session Directory

1. Ensure session directory exists
2. Write to ~/.arcforge/diaries/{project}/{date}/diary-{sessionId}.md
3. Confirm save location with path

4. Offer Follow-up

After saving, briefly mention:

"Diary saved. If you noticed reusable patterns, run /arcforge:arc-reflecting to extract them."

Key Principles

Observation Over Prescription

Record what happened, not rules. Patterns that should become rules belong in arc-reflecting.

User Intent Over Implementation

Focus on WHY decisions were made, not just WHAT was done.

Minimal Effort

Keep entries focused. Don't over-document routine work.

Common Mistakes

Reading Files for Context

Wrong: Reading project files to "understand" what to write Right: Reflect on conversation memory only

Capturing Implementation Details

Wrong: "Changed line 42 of app.js to use const" Right: "Decided to prefer const over let for immutability"

Creating Diary for Trivial Sessions

Wrong: Diary for "fixed a typo" session Right: Skip diary, or note "No significant reflections this session"

Duplicating Learn Content

Wrong: Same pattern in both diary and instinct Right: Diary captures context; learn extracts reusable pattern

Not Asking Permission

Wrong: Auto-saving without confirmation Right: Present draft, ask "Should I save this diary entry?"

Skipping the Generalizable Marker

Wrong: Leaving Generalizable? empty or omitting it Right: Always mark solutions as Yes/No - helps arc-reflecting identify patterns

Template Variables

Variable	Source
{project}	CLAUDE_PROJECT_DIR or path.basename(process.cwd())
{YYYY-MM-DD}	Current date
{sessionId}	CLAUDE_SESSION_ID or generated
{timestamp}	ISO timestamp

Output Location

~/.arcforge/diaries/{project}/{YYYY-MM-DD}/
└── diary-{sessionId}.md      # Diary entry (from arc-journaling)

~/.arcforge/sessions/{project}/{YYYY-MM-DD}/
└── {sessionId}.json          # Session data (auto-generated)

Diary files live under ~/.arcforge/diaries/ (not ~/.claude/sessions/) because Claude Code v2.1.78+ blocks subprocess writes to ~/.claude/. The Stop-hook background enricher needs to be able to write there.

Example Diary Entry

# Session Diary: my-api-project

**Date:** 2025-01-24
**Session ID:** abc123-def456

## Decisions Made

- Chose PostgreSQL over MySQL: JSON column support needed for flexible schema
- Connection pooling with PgBouncer: scalability requirement for multi-tenant

## User Preferences Observed

- Prefers explicit error handling over try-catch blocks
- Likes detailed commit messages with context

## What Worked Well

- TDD approach helped catch edge case early
- Breaking large migration into smaller steps

## Challenges & Solutions

- **Challenge**: Docker networking issues blocked local development
- **Solution**: Used host network mode instead of bridge
- **Generalizable?**: Yes - applies to any Docker-based local dev

- **Challenge**: Prisma limitation with composite keys
- **Solution**: Workaround using @@id directive with custom naming
- **Generalizable?**: No - specific to this Prisma version

## PR/Review Feedback (if any)

- "Add rollback logic to migration": Added down() method to all migration files

## Context for Next Session

- Migration is half-complete; start with users table
- Test database needs to be reset before next run

---

_Captured at 2025-01-24T15:30:00Z_