consolidate-knowledge-base

name	consolidate-knowledge-base
description	Interactively review the OKF knowledge base to detect contradictions between Findings, mark contradicted/superseded Findings, propose Experiments to resolve open questions, and propose promotions of converged Findings into stable Concept/Structure/Principle documents. Every mutation is confirmed by a human before it is written. Use periodically or after a batch of recorded Findings.

consolidate-knowledge-base

Turn a pile of dated Findings into consolidated, trustworthy knowledge — without ever rewriting history. This skill is interactive: it proposes, the human confirms, then it writes.

When to use

• After a batch of Findings has been dumped by record-finding.
• Periodically, to keep the empirical layer coherent with the stable layer.
• When you suspect two findings disagree.

Guardrails

• NEVER edit or delete a Finding's body. Only append lifecycle frontmatter (status, contradicted_by, superseded_by).
• NEVER promote to a Principle without explicit human confirmation — principles are agreed with humans.
• Ask before every write, using vscode_askQuestions.

Procedure

1. Scan

Read knowledge/findings/, plus principles/, structures/, concepts/. Build a map of claims, tags, and existing contradicts/supersedes links.

2. Detect contradictions

Identify pairs where a newer Finding disagrees with an older Finding, or where a Finding conflicts with a Principle/Structure/Concept. Present each candidate contradiction to the human for confirmation.

3. Mark (on confirmation)

For each confirmed contradiction, append metadata-only fields:

• On the newer finding: contradicts: [<old-id>] (if not already present).
• On the older finding: status: contradicted and contradicted_by: [<new-id>]. Use the same pattern with supersedes/superseded_by for replacements. The body of both files stays untouched.

4. Propose Experiments

For unresolved or low-confidence contradictions, propose a new Experiment document (hypothesis, steps, expected_signals, max_runs: 1–2) that would settle the question. Write it to knowledge/experiments/ only on confirmation.

5. Propose promotions

When several Findings converge on a stable truth, propose promoting the insight into the stable layer:

• "how it works" → Structure in structures/
• "the idea" → Concept in concepts/
• "the standard/convention" → Principle in principles/ (always human-agreed) Link the promoted doc back to its supporting findings (supported_by / related_concepts). Write only on confirmation. Findings remain untouched.

6. Validate

just knowledge-lint
just knowledge-validate

Both must pass before finishing.

Output

A short chat summary: contradictions found and marked, experiments proposed, promotions made, and any open questions left for a future run.