haipipe-board-page-for-literature

name	haipipe-board-page-for-literature
description	The VARIANT contract for a LITERATURE evidence Page: an evidence page declaring `route: outward` in its metadata head, whose questions face OUTWARD, toward published knowledge. Its Content is organized BY EXECUTOR: one `### E<n> · <question>` division per Q-executor conversation, each owning one QA-probe record below probes/, its collected consumers, and an answer digest, plus the standing `### E0 · incoming` queue. It loads haipipe-board-page for the base frame and the shared topic-entry core for the anatomy, then adds only the outward route's translation layer: what a legal consumer row carries here, what a returned answer must become (a citation binding: a real key, a positioning sentence, a novelty verdict), and when the page may close. Use when writing or fixing a Literature evidence page, when a consumer row carries no positioning stake, when an answer landed but never became a citation record, or when a novelty claim rests on nothing traceable. Trigger: literature evidence, evidence page, literature topic, S-Literature, discovery route, positioning, novelty, citation binding, related work evidence, /haipipe-board-page-for-literature.
metadata	{"version":"0.4.0","last_updated":"2026-08-06","summary":"Evidence pages organize BY EXECUTOR (JL 260806): the head route: line is the type key, one E<n> Content division per Q-executor conversation with its QA-probe pointer, #### consumers, and #### answer digest, plus the E0 incoming queue; the flat Q-consumer register is retired."}

/haipipe-board-page-for-literature · the outward route: what is already known

LOAD TWO THINGS FIRST. The base frame is haipipe-board-page, and the E-division and QA-probe anatomy is haipipe-board/ref/topic-entry-contract.md, stated once for both evidence routes so they cannot drift apart (QB6 §4, JL 260805). A QA-probe is a hidden source record named <n>-<slug>.md, never a board page (JL ruling B, 260806); it is the paper's stub that points at the QA-bank, the original. This file is the outward route's dictionary and nothing more: what a question aimed at the published record carries, and what a found result must become before this page may lean on it. Any sentence here that seems to describe the page's shape belongs to the core, not to this file.

The kind this variant covers: an evidence page whose questions face OUTWARD.

kind        resolved by                          closes when
────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
Literature  the REQUIRED `route: outward`        every E<n> division's consumers
evidence    line in the metadata head            are SUPPORTED, DEFERRED, or
            (base, type resolution step ②)       WITHDRAWN, AND E0 is empty

"Literature" names a DIRECTION, not a paper section: any family may ask what is already known. The paper family's projection files these pages as S-Literature-<n>-<topic> under its discovery group with L<n> probe folders; those letters are family vocabulary and stay in the paper projection. The filename looks like a stage page's, so only the head route: outward line routes the page here.

🧬 The page organizes BY EXECUTOR

One ### E<n> · <the executor question> Content division per Q-executor conversation; one division owns exactly one QA-probe. ### E0 · incoming is the collect queue: a Q-consumer born on ANY page is COLLECTED into the owning topic's E0 first, and PROBE later promotes it into a new E and opens its QA-probe. The division's #### consumers block is where the collected Q-consumers live, one row each: source page id, the stake in one line, then the A-consumer interpretation and the row state. Its #### answer digest is 2-3 lines from the A-executor; the full text stays in the QA-probe record. The anatomy is the core's; this route only says what its rows mean.

🗣 What a legal consumer row carries HERE

A Literature Q-consumer carries a POSITIONING STAKE: what the work claims to add, and what published result would strengthen or break that claim.

✅  "Is our review-text trait measure novel, or did <field> already do it?
     H1's contribution claim dies if a published precedent exists."
🚫  "Find papers about physician reviews."          no stake · a reading list
🚫  "Confirm nobody has done this."                 a verdict ordered in advance

The stake stays on this page. The QA-probe's Q-executor carries the neutral question only, and the wall between them is PROBE's (page-phases/haipipe-board-page-probe).

📥 What a returned answer must BECOME: the citation binding

An answer that stays in the QA-probe's #### A-executor is not yet evidence the page can use. The consumer row's write-back is a typed record with three parts:

1  a real key          resolvable in the bibliography, never a title from memory
2  a positioning       one sentence stating how this work stands NEXT TO the
   sentence            found result: extends, contradicts, first-in-setting
3  a novelty verdict   supported · threatened · broken, with the source named

🚫 Never write "novelty confirmed" from an ABSENCE of findings alone. Absence after a bounded search is written as "no precedent found within <the search's own scope>", because the search's limits are part of the fact.

🚪 When the page closes

The terminal row states, and the rule that the gate reads the E divisions rather than the QA-probes, live in the core (topic-entry-contract.md). The close rule on this route: every E division's consumers are terminal AND E0 · incoming is empty. This file only says what SUPPORTED takes here: named, real sources standing behind the positioning, which is the citation binding above, written onto the consumer row. A search that came back empty supports nothing by itself; the row either carries the bounded no-precedent finding, scope and all, or it stays open.

The template. template.md, beside this file. ONE template serves every page of this type: two pages of it differ in what they say, never in what shape they are, so nothing has to be resolved before writing one. Copy it, fill every <slot>, and delete each RULE comment as you satisfy it.

📂 Files

haipipe-board-page-for-literature/
├── SKILL.md            this route dictionary
└── CHANGELOG.md        version history

This folder holds prose only. The anatomy lives in haipipe-board/ref/topic-entry-contract.md and its checker in haipipe-board/src/topic_entry_contract.py; a literature question crosses to the discovery bank through page-phases/haipipe-board-page-probe. A question about what this project must PRODUCE, rather than what the field already holds, belongs on a haipipe-board-page-for-value page instead. The paper family's projection of the shape is paper/haipipe-paper/probe/topic-entry-contract.md.