| name | paper-audit |
| description | Unified paper audit for Chinese and English papers. Use when reviewing paper quality, pre-submission checks, or doing adversarial reviews. |
| metadata | {"category":"academic-writing","tags":["audit","review","paper","pdf","latex","typst","chinese","english","scoring","checklist"]} |
| argument-hint | [paper.tex|paper.typ|paper.pdf] [--mode MODE] [--pdf-mode MODE] [--style STYLE] [--journal VENUE] |
| allowed-tools | Read, Glob, Grep, Bash(python *), Task |
Paper Audit Skill
Unified academic paper auditing across formats and languages.
Steps
- Parse the paper path and mode from
$ARGUMENTS. If missing, confirm the target .tex, .typ, or .pdf file.
- Review evaluation criteria in
$SKILL_DIR/references/REVIEW_CRITERIA.md and $SKILL_DIR/references/CHECKLIST.md.
- Run the orchestrator:
python $SKILL_DIR/scripts/audit.py $ARGUMENTS.
- Present the MD report directly to the user. Distinguish between automated findings and LLM-judgment scores.
- If in
review mode, read $SKILL_DIR/references/SCHOLAR_EVAL_GUIDE.md and formulate LLM assessments for Novelty, Significance, Ethics, and Reproducibility.
- If in
polish mode, read .polish-state/precheck.json and spawn nested tasks for the Critic Agent and Mentor Agents as defined in the original workflow specifications.
Examples
- Run
python $SKILL_DIR/scripts/audit.py $ARGUMENTS.
- Run
python $SKILL_DIR/scripts/audit.py paper.pdf --mode review.
Troubleshooting
- Provide a valid
.tex, .typ, or .pdf path when arguments are missing.
- Report command output and exit code when audit execution fails.
