implementation

name	implementation
description	Use when implementing any feature, adding code, or modifying existing code in this Java/Spring project. Triggers on write operations like adding entities, services, facades, controllers, or any domain logic.

Implementation Guide

Overview

This project follows responsibility assignment, object collaboration, and expression consistency.

Quick Decision

digraph layer {
    "Single domain?" [shape=diamond];
    "Service" [shape=box];
    "Multiple domains?" [shape=diamond];
    "Facade" [shape=box];
    "HTTP?" [shape=diamond];
    "Controller" [shape=box];

    "Single domain?" -> "Service" [label="yes"];
    "Single domain?" -> "Multiple domains?" [label="no"];
    "Multiple domains?" -> "Facade" [label="yes"];
    "Multiple domains?" -> "HTTP?" [label="no"];
    "HTTP?" -> "Controller" [label="yes"];
}

Critical Rules (Non-negotiable)

1. Controller Flow

ALWAYS: Controller -> Facade -> Service (never Controller -> Service)

@RestController
public class ProductV1Controller implements ProductV1ApiSpec {

    private final ProductFacade productFacade;  // Facade, NOT Service

    public ProductV1Controller(ProductFacade productFacade) {
        this.productFacade = productFacade;
    }
}

See references/layer-boundaries.md for detailed patterns.

2. Layer Responsibilities

Layer	@Transactional	Horizontal Dependencies	Why
Facade	When atomicity needed	Multiple Services OK	Wraps multiple Services in single transaction
Service	When atomicity needed	No other Services	Ensures atomicity within single domain

readOnly usage: Master/Slave DB routing. Use readOnly=true for read-only queries to route to Slave DB.

Facade = COORDINATION ONLY - No business logic (if/when/switch). Delegate to Service/Entity.

See references/layer-boundaries.md for transaction boundaries and anti-patterns.

3. Error Handling

Required: CoreException + ErrorType (single exception type)

throw new CoreException(ErrorType.NOT_FOUND, "[id = " + id + "] 엔티티를 찾을 수 없습니다.");

See references/error-handling.md for ErrorType enum and patterns.

4. DTO Flow

Request.toCriteria() -> Criteria.toCommand() -> Command -> Entity -> Info.from() -> Response.from()

See references/dto-patterns.md for complete layer structure.

5. Domain Events

Requirement	Pattern
Naming	{Action}EventV{n} (version suffix required)
Interface	Must implement DomainEvent
Fields	occurredAt: Instant required
Factory	public static from(entity)
Children	Use snapshots, not entity references

public record OrderCreatedEventV1(
    Long orderId,
    List<OrderItemSnapshot> items,  // Snapshot, not entity
    Instant occurredAt
) implements DomainEvent {
    public static OrderCreatedEventV1 from(Order order) {
        return new OrderCreatedEventV1(order.getId(), order.getItemSnapshots(), Instant.now());
    }
}

6. EventListener Pattern

Type	Phase	Error Handling
Sync	BEFORE_COMMIT	Failure rolls back tx
Async	AFTER_COMMIT	try-catch required, log errors

Always: @TransactionalEventListener(phase = TransactionPhase.XXX) - never plain @EventListener

Logging format: logger.info("[Event] {Action} start/complete - eventType: " + event.getClass().getSimpleName() + ", id: " + id)

7. Entity Encapsulation

Seven Rules:

1. BaseEntity: ALL entities extend BaseEntity (provides id, createdAt, updatedAt, deletedAt)
2. @Table indexes: ALWAYS define indexes for query optimization
3. private fields + @Getter: ALL mutable fields private, no @Setter
4. Behavior methods: State changes via domain verbs (use(), pay()), not setters
5. Immutable VOs: final fields, operations return new instances
6. Constructor/Factory validation: Validate in constructor or factory, never create invalid objects
7. registerEvent(): Publish events for business-significant state changes

8. Naming Conventions

Component	Pattern	Example
Controller	{Domain}V{n}Controller	ProductV1Controller
ApiSpec	{Domain}V{n}ApiSpec	ProductV1ApiSpec
Facade	{Domain}Facade	ProductFacade
Service	{Domain}Service	ProductService
Event	{Action}EventV{n}	OrderCreatedEventV1
Query	{Domain}PageQuery	ProductPageQuery

Methods: Domain verbs (use, expire, cancel), not technical (process, handle, execute)

Variables: Full names (totalAmount, quantity), not abbreviations (amt, qty)

Booleans: is{Adjective}, has{Noun}, canBe{Verb}

9. Domain Purity

Direction: interfaces -> application -> domain <- infrastructure

Domain imports NOTHING from other layers.

Allowed in Domain	Forbidden in Domain
JPA: @Entity, @Table, @Column	@Transactional
@Component on Service	@JsonProperty, @JsonIgnore
	Spring Data imports

Repository Abstraction: Interface in domain, implementation in infrastructure.

10. Null Safety

Rule	Pattern
Required fields	Non-nullable (never assign null)
Not found	if (x == null) throw new CoreException(ErrorType.NOT_FOUND, "[id = " + id + "] ...")
Optional	if (x != null) { ... }, Stream.of(a, b, c).filter(Objects::nonNull).toList()
Forbidden	Unchecked null dereference

11. API Patterns

• ApiSpec interface: Swagger annotations go here, Controller implements it
• Query/PageQuery: Encapsulate pagination with compact constructor validation

public record ProductPageQuery(int page, int size) {
    public ProductPageQuery {
        if (page < 0) throw new CoreException(ErrorType.BAD_REQUEST, "[page = " + page + "] 페이지는 0 이상이어야 합니다.");
        if (size < 1 || size > 100) throw new CoreException(ErrorType.BAD_REQUEST, "[size = " + size + "] 페이지 크기는 1~100이어야 합니다.");
    }
}

record vs class selection:

• Default: record + compact constructor — for 2–3 required parameters
• Allowed: class + @Getter + private constructor + static factory — when 4+ parameters AND optional parameters exist
• Validation must always occur in the constructor or static factory, regardless of choice

12. Messages

• Error messages: Korean, [field = value] prefix AT START
• Javadoc: Korean

// Correct
"[userId = " + userId + "] 사용자를 찾을 수 없습니다."

// Wrong (prefix at end)
"사용자를 찾을 수 없습니다. [userId = " + userId + "]"

13. Caching

Rule	Pattern
Layer	Application Layer(Facade) ONLY
Pattern	Manual Cache-Aside with CacheTemplate
Cache Key	Sealed interface + TTL embedded
Cache Model	CachedXxxV1 versioned DTO (never Entity/Response)
List Caching	IDs only + separate Detail cache
Invalidation	Domain Event + @TransactionalEventListener(AFTER_COMMIT)

See references/caching-patterns.md for detailed patterns, examples, and forbidden patterns.

Red Flags (Top 25)

Thought	Reality
"Controller calling Service directly"	Controller -> Facade -> Service is MANDATORY
"Facade is unnecessary for simple cases"	Facade is ALWAYS required
"Service calling Service"	Coordinate in Facade
"Facade->Facade dependency"	Use domain events
"@Transactional on Service"	Only readOnly or managed in Facade
"require() is fine"	Use CoreException: if (!cond) throw new CoreException(...)
"Domain exception per domain"	Single CoreException + ErrorType
"Return Entity directly"	DTO layer required
"English error message"	Korean with [field = value] prefix
"Entity without BaseEntity"	ALL entities MUST extend BaseEntity
"public field or @Setter"	ALL mutable fields need private + @Getter, no @Setter
"@Table without indexes"	ALWAYS define indexes
"Event without V1 suffix"	Version suffix required
"Just @EventListener"	Use @TransactionalEventListener with phase
"Async listener without try-catch"	Async failures must be caught and logged
"Inject JpaRepository directly"	Define interface in domain
"@JsonProperty in domain"	JSON is infrastructure concern
"Nullable for required fields"	Non-nullable by default
"Unchecked null dereference"	Use explicit null check + CoreException
"process/handle method names"	Use domain verbs
"Short variable names (amt, qty)"	Full descriptive names required
"Business logic in Facade"	Facade coordinates only, logic in Service/Entity
"External call inside @Transactional"	Use AFTER_COMMIT event listener
"Entity is just data holder"	Anemic domain model anti-pattern - entities MUST have behavior
"Skip validation in constructor/factory"	Invalid objects are forbidden
"@Cacheable is simpler"	Use CacheTemplate for control
"Cache in Service/Repository"	Caching belongs in Facade ONLY
"Cache Response directly"	Use CachedXxxV1 dedicated DTO
"String cache key"	Use sealed interface with TTL
"@CacheEvict allEntries"	Domain Event + selective evict

References

Load these files ONLY when working on specific areas:

File	When to Load
references/layer-boundaries.md	Code placement, Service vs Facade, transactions
references/error-handling.md	Exception creation, validation failures, ErrorType enum
references/dto-patterns.md	API endpoints, Request/Response/Criteria/Command/Info classes
references/domain-events.md	Event publishing, EventListener patterns, cross-domain communication
references/entity-patterns.md	Entity design, encapsulation rules, null safety, domain purity
references/naming-conventions.md	Method/variable/message naming, Korean messages
references/api-patterns.md	ApiSpec interface, Query/PageQuery patterns
references/caching-patterns.md	Cache-Aside in Facade, CacheKey sealed interface, CachedXxxV1 DTOs, invalidation