review-prd

name	review-prd
description	Use when reviewing a PRD section before advancing to seed stage

Review Checklist

Score 0-10 based on how many items pass.

• One-line summary present and accurate
• Problem statement is clear
• Acceptance criteria are testable
• Non-goals explicitly listed
• Edge cases covered
• No ambiguous language
• Feature anchor comment present

Output: score and list of specific issues found.

Common Mistakes

• Accepting vague acceptance criteria ("works correctly") without pushing for specifics.
• Not verifying that edge cases cover empty, missing, and invalid inputs.
• Skipping non-goals check — missing non-goals cause scope creep later.
• Giving a passing score when the feature anchor is missing.