| name | judge-v2 |
| description | Board of Judges v2 — tool-grounded, eval-backed panel code review. Invokes the `boj` CLI; returns a structured verdict report. Usage: /judge-v2 <target> [--panel X] [--solo X] [--all] [--post-to-pr]
|
Board of Judges — v2 Coordinator
You are the v2 coordinator. You do NOT roleplay judges. Each judge is run by
the boj Python CLI, which dispatches real parallel LLM calls, grounds every
finding in static-analysis tool output, verifies line-number citations, and
emits structured JSON.
Step 1 — Parse invocation
Extract:
target: file path (required — ask if missing).--panel <tags>: comma-separated tag filter.--solo <judge-id>: run a single judge.--all: no 10-judge cap.--post-to-pr: after review, post to current branch's PR via gh.
Step 2 — Confirm boj is installed
Run boj version. If it fails:
boj not installed. Install from the repo root:
uv sync --dev (preferred)
pip install -e . (alternative)
Then set ANTHROPIC_API_KEY / GOOGLE_API_KEY / OPENAI_API_KEY.
Do not proceed until boj is available.
Step 3 — Run the review
boj judge <target> \
[--panel <tags>] \
[--solo <id>] \
[--all] \
--output judgements/<timestamp>-<slug>.json \
--markdown judgements/<timestamp>-<slug>.md
Capture exit code. 0 = PASS/WARN, 1 = FAIL, 2 = usage error.
Step 4 — Render the report
The markdown report at judgements/<timestamp>-<slug>.md contains:
- Verdict table with scores, confidence, issue counts
- Individual judge verdicts with issues, fix hints, tool citations
- Run manifest (fingerprint, models, cost, duration)
- Disagreements (surfaced, not collapsed)
Read the markdown and display it to the user. Do not add your own commentary
on top of the judges' verdicts.
Step 5 — Post to PR (if requested)
Only if --post-to-pr was passed and gh pr view succeeds:
gh pr comment $(gh pr view --json number -q .number) \
--body-file judgements/<timestamp>-<slug>.md
Report the PR URL.
Rules
- Never fabricate judge verdicts. The
boj output is authoritative.
- If
boj judge errors, show stderr and stop — do not improvise a review.
- The 88 legacy agents under
.claude/agents/extended/ are NOT part of v2.
Use them only if the user explicitly invokes @judge-... directly.
