Menu
Independent roadmap review gate for discovery. Checks roadmap quality and returns PASS or REQUEST_CHANGES.
Install with Codex or Claude Copy this prompt, paste it into Codex, Claude, or another assistant, and let it review the skill page and install it for you.
Produce the high-level architecture overview used by downstream product design and engineering.
Independent high-level architecture review gate for discovery.
Capture and structure raw ideas through guided interview or quick note. Produces a structured idea document ready for research or PRD pass. Focuses purely on product intent — no technical decisions.
Entry-point product workflow from raw idea to validated product design artifacts. Stops at reviewed PRD readiness and does not include engineering implementation.
Write the per-feature PRD from the ranked requirements contract using the mandatory PRD template.
Dedicated analyze gate for PRD and UI brief consistency. Runs script extraction first, then semantic review with evidence-backed findings.
Based on SOC occupation classification
| name | woos-roadmap-review-gate |
| description | Independent roadmap review gate for discovery. Checks roadmap quality and returns PASS or REQUEST_CHANGES. |
| version | 1.0.0 |
| author | Hermes Profile |
| license | MIT |
| metadata | {"hermes":{"tags":["product","roadmap","review","gate"],"related_skills":["woos-product-discovery","woos-roadmap-authoring"]}} |
PASS, REQUEST_CHANGES, BLOCKED, NOT_RUNcritical, high, medium, low, warning[ASSUMPTION: ...], [NEEDS CLARIFICATION: ...], [NEEDS INPUT: ...]P0 … P11, P2a, Phase A, Phase Binternal-tool, single-operator, consumer-product, multi-stakeholder, CLIstrong, adequate, thin, broken## Background, ## Functional Requirements, ## Assumptions Index) — translations break downstream structural checks**Consequences (testable):**, **Out of Scope:**, **User value:**, Given … When … Then …)Review the roadmap in fresh context before architecture work continues.
references/persona-prd-validator.mddocs/product/<project>-roadmap.mdideas/<slug>/00-idea-capture.mdIf any required file is not loaded, return BLOCKED.
docs/reviews/<project>-roadmap-review-rN.md| # | Criterion | Fix Hint |
|---|---|---|
| R1 | Vision differentiated | Add a distinct angle compared with alternatives |
| R2 | Versioning logical | Keep V1 independently shippable |
| R3 | Metrics measurable | Replace vague claims with observable thresholds |
| R4 | Non-goals effective | State concrete exclusions |
| R5 | Decision Log sound | Record real alternatives and rationale |
| R6 | Personas grounded | Tie personas to evidence or observed behavior |
Every row must have a finding and status.