Run any Skill in Manus with one click

autoacad-review

Stars0

Forks0

UpdatedApril 5, 2026 at 21:44

Use when stress-testing a paper or experiment package for methodology-evidence consistency, reviewer objections, baseline quality, and rebuttal readiness.

Installation

Install with Codex or Claude Copy this prompt, paste it into Codex, Claude, or another assistant, and let it review the skill page and install it for you.

Run Skill in Manus

Source

zinknovo

zinknovo/autoacad

View GitHub Repository View Creator Repositories

Download

Run Skill in Manus

Related occupationsSOC

Based on SOC occupation classification

Biological Scientists, All OtherLife, Physical, and Social Science Occupations·SOC 19-1029

SKILL.md

readonly

name	autoacad-review
description	Use when stress-testing a paper or experiment package for methodology-evidence consistency, reviewer objections, baseline quality, and rebuttal readiness.

AutoAcad Review

Overview

Use this stage for adversarial review. Treat unsupported claims as critical failures, not editing suggestions.

Review Focus

Topic discipline: does every section connect back to the core research problem?
Method-evidence consistency: do claimed trials, tests, metrics, and baselines match the actual code and results?
Baseline strength: were comparators tuned fairly?
Ablation coverage: does each claimed component have an ablation?
Length and depth: are all major sections substantial enough for a top-tier submission?
Reviewer defense: what is the harshest plausible objection and how should the paper answer it?

Output

Produce a reviewer-style report with strengths, weaknesses, critical fabrications if any, and concrete revision actions.

More from this repository

same repository

autoacad

zinknovo/autoacad

Use when running an end-to-end academic paper project or upgrading a research idea into a submission-grade workflow with literature review, experiments, writing, review, and export.

2026-07-200

autoacad-prepare

zinknovo/autoacad

Use when starting a paper project and needing to inventory local code, docs, datasets, constraints, and source materials before literature review or experiment planning.

2026-06-150

autoacad-analyze

zinknovo/autoacad

Use when interpreting experiment outputs, checking whether data supports the claims, and deciding whether to proceed, refine, or pivot.

2026-04-050

autoacad-draft

zinknovo/autoacad

Use when outlining, drafting, or revising a conference paper with explicit evidence links, section word budgets, and figure planning.

2026-04-050

autoacad-export

zinknovo/autoacad

Use when preparing the final paper package, checking citations and archives, and exporting a submission-ready LaTeX or markdown deliverable.

2026-04-050

autoacad-ideate

zinknovo/autoacad

Use when turning literature synthesis into testable hypotheses, research questions, contribution framing, or pivot decisions for a paper.

2026-04-050

name	autoacad-review
description	Use when stress-testing a paper or experiment package for methodology-evidence consistency, reviewer objections, baseline quality, and rebuttal readiness.

AutoAcad Review

Overview

Use this stage for adversarial review. Treat unsupported claims as critical failures, not editing suggestions.

Review Focus

Topic discipline: does every section connect back to the core research problem?
Method-evidence consistency: do claimed trials, tests, metrics, and baselines match the actual code and results?
Baseline strength: were comparators tuned fairly?
Ablation coverage: does each claimed component have an ablation?
Length and depth: are all major sections substantial enough for a top-tier submission?
Reviewer defense: what is the harshest plausible objection and how should the paper answer it?

Output

Produce a reviewer-style report with strengths, weaknesses, critical fabrications if any, and concrete revision actions.