texture-packing-variant-stripping

name	texture-packing-variant-stripping
description	Channel packing, variant reduction, shader_feature vs multi_compile, and build size optimization for Unity

Texture Packing and Shader Variant Stripping for Unity Mobile

TRIGGER

Use this skill when the user is dealing with texture optimization, channel packing, shader variant bloat, build size, shader compilation time, or shader keyword management in Unity. Triggers include: "channel packing", "texture packing", "mask map", "MODS map", "RMA", "shader variants", "variant stripping", "multi_compile", "shader_feature", "build size", "shader keywords", "Always Included Shaders", "IPreprocessShaders", or complaints about slow shader compilation or large build sizes.

---

TEXTURE CHANNEL PACKING

Channel packing stores multiple grayscale maps in a single RGBA texture. This reduces both texture sample count and memory bandwidth — the primary bottleneck on mobile.

Standard URP Packing Convention

Mask Map (single RGBA texture):
  R = Metallic
  G = Occlusion (AO)
  B = Detail mask (or custom)
  A = Smoothness

Best Practices

1. Put the most visually important mask in the Green channel. Human vision is most sensitive to green, and most texture compression formats (ETC2, ASTC, DXT) allocate more bits to green.

2. Pack related data together. If metallic and smoothness are always sampled together, put them in the same texture.

3. Use linear color space (not sRGB) for packed mask textures. In Unity, uncheck "sRGB" in the texture import settings for any non-color data (roughness, AO, metallic, height).

4. One texture sample replaces four. Instead of:

   // BAD — 4 texture samples
   half metallic = SAMPLE_TEXTURE2D(_MetallicMap, sampler_MetallicMap, uv).r;
   half ao = SAMPLE_TEXTURE2D(_AOMap, sampler_AOMap, uv).r;
   half detail = SAMPLE_TEXTURE2D(_DetailMask, sampler_DetailMask, uv).r;
   half smooth = SAMPLE_TEXTURE2D(_SmoothnessMap, sampler_SmoothnessMap, uv).r;
   

   Use:

   // GOOD — 1 texture sample
   half4 masks = SAMPLE_TEXTURE2D(_MaskMap, sampler_MaskMap, uv);
   half metallic = masks.r;
   half ao = masks.g;
   half detail = masks.b;
   half smooth = masks.a;
   

Advanced: Terrain Packing

Unity's Shader Graph 17.4 terrain samples demonstrate advanced packing that reduces 12 texture samples to 5 for a 4-layer terrain:

• CNS packing: Color (RGB) + Normal (RG → reconstruct B) + Smoothness in a single set
• CHNOSArray: Texture arrays packing Color, Height, Normal, Occlusion, Smoothness

HLSL Channel Packing Helper

// Pack 4 grayscale values into RGBA
half4 PackChannels(half metallic, half ao, half detail, half smoothness)
{
    return half4(metallic, ao, detail, smoothness);
}

// Reconstruct normal Z from XY (for normal map packing)
half3 UnpackNormalRG(half2 normalRG)
{
    half3 n;
    n.xy = normalRG * 2.0h - 1.0h;
    n.z = sqrt(1.0h - saturate(dot(n.xy, n.xy)));
    return n;
}

---

SHADER VARIANT MANAGEMENT

The Variant Explosion Problem

Each multi_compile keyword doubles variant count multiplicatively:

#pragma multi_compile _ _A        → 2 variants
#pragma multi_compile _ _A _B     → 3 variants
#pragma multi_compile _ _A
#pragma multi_compile _ _B        → 2 × 2 = 4 variants
#pragma multi_compile _ _A
#pragma multi_compile _ _B
#pragma multi_compile _ _C        → 2 × 2 × 2 = 8 variants

With URP's built-in keywords (shadows, fog, additional lights, etc.), a single shader can generate thousands of variants.

Impact

• Build time: 20+ minutes for complex shaders
• Build size: 100MB+ shader data (critical for WebGL)
• Runtime memory: 20-40% extra draw calls from variant switching
• WebGL: Shader compilation blocks the main thread — more variants = longer freeze

shader_feature vs multi_compile

	shader_feature	multi_compile
Compiles	Only variants used by materials in build	ALL combinations
Use for	Material-specific toggles	Global state (fog, shadows)
Unused variants	Stripped automatically	Included regardless
Local version	shader_feature_local (64 max)	multi_compile_local (64 max)
Global version	shader_feature (256 max)	multi_compile (256 max)

Rule: Use shader_feature for everything you control (material toggles, feature flags). Only use multi_compile for things Unity controls globally (fog, lightmaps, instancing).

Recommended URP Keyword Stripping

Strip these keywords if you're not using the features:

// In an IPreprocessShaders implementation:
static readonly ShaderKeyword[] STRIP_KEYWORDS = new[]
{
    new ShaderKeyword("_ADDITIONAL_LIGHTS"),          // If using main light only
    new ShaderKeyword("_ADDITIONAL_LIGHT_SHADOWS"),   // If no additional light shadows
    new ShaderKeyword("_SHADOWS_SOFT"),               // If using hard shadows only
    new ShaderKeyword("_MIXED_LIGHTING_SUBTRACTIVE"), // If not using mixed lighting
    new ShaderKeyword("_SCREEN_SPACE_OCCLUSION"),     // If not using SSAO
    new ShaderKeyword("LIGHTMAP_SHADOW_MIXING"),      // If not mixing lightmaps + realtime
    new ShaderKeyword("_LIGHT_LAYERS"),               // If not using light layers
    new ShaderKeyword("_REFLECTION_PROBE_BLENDING"),  // If not blending reflection probes
    new ShaderKeyword("_REFLECTION_PROBE_BOX_PROJECTION"), // If not using box projection
};

URP Asset Feature Stripping

In URP Asset settings, disable unused features to prevent their variants from being compiled:

• Additional Lights → Off (if only using directional)
• Shadows → Reduce cascade count, disable soft shadows
• Post-Processing → Disable if not used
• HDR → Disable if not needed
• Environment Reflections → Disable if using baked reflections

Platform-Conditional Compilation

// Include features only on platforms that can handle them
#if defined(SHADER_API_MOBILE) || defined(SHADER_API_GLES) || defined(SHADER_API_GLES3)
    // Mobile/WebGL: simplified path
    #define MOBILE_SHADER 1
#else
    // Desktop: full features
    #define MOBILE_SHADER 0
#endif

half4 frag(Varyings i) : SV_Target
{
    half4 color = SampleAlbedo(i.uv);
    
    #if !MOBILE_SHADER
        // Desktop-only: normal mapping, specular, etc.
        color.rgb += SampleNormalAndLight(i);
    #endif
    
    return color;
}

---

TEXTURE COMPRESSION FOR MOBILE/WEB

Format	Platform	Bits/Pixel	Quality	Notes
ASTC 4×4	Android (ES 3.0+), iOS	8	Best	Preferred for all mobile
ASTC 6×6	Android (ES 3.0+), iOS	3.56	Good	Use for less important textures
ASTC 8×8	Android (ES 3.0+), iOS	2	Acceptable	Background/distant textures
ETC2	Android (ES 3.0+), WebGL 2.0	4-8	Good	WebGL 2.0 default
ETC1	Android (ES 2.0)	4	OK	No alpha channel support
PVRTC	iOS (older)	2-4	Variable	Legacy, prefer ASTC

For channel-packed textures: Use ASTC 4×4 or ETC2 with linear color space. Avoid PVRTC for mask maps — its block compression causes visible artifacts on sharp mask boundaries.

---

OPTIMIZATION CHECKLIST

• All grayscale maps packed into RGBA channels of shared textures
• Packed textures imported as Linear (not sRGB)
• Green channel used for most important mask data
• shader_feature used instead of multi_compile for material toggles
• Local keywords used where possible (shader_feature_local)
• Unused URP features disabled in URP Asset
• Always Included Shaders list cleaned (Project Settings > Graphics)
• IPreprocessShaders stripping script added for unused keywords
• Build log checked for variant count (look for "Compiled N shader variants")
• ASTC or ETC2 compression used for all mobile textures
• Standard Shader removed from project (use Simple Lit or custom)

---

SOURCES

• Unity 6 URP Channel-Packed Textures — https://docs.unity3d.com/6000.3/Documentation/Manual/urp/shaders-in-universalrp-channel-packed-texture.html
• Unity Learn: Texture Channel Packing for Mobile — https://learn.unity.com/course/3d-art-optimization-for-mobile-gaming-5474/
• Shader Graph 17.4: Terrain Packing — https://docs.unity3d.com/Packages/com.unity.shadergraph@17.4/manual/Shader-Graph-Sample-Terrain-Packing.html
• Polycount Wiki: Channel Packing — http://wiki.polycount.com/wiki/ChannelPacking
• Unity 6: Shader Variant Stripping — https://docs.unity3d.com/6000.3/Documentation/Manual/shader-variant-stripping.html
• Unity Blog: Stripping Scriptable Shader Variants — https://unity.com/blog/engine-platform/stripping-scriptable-shader-variants
• Unity Blog: Shader Variants Optimization Tips — https://unity.com/blog/engine-platform/shader-variants-optimization-troubleshooting-tips
• Unity Manual: shader_feature vs multi_compile — https://docs.unity3d.com/2020.2/Documentation/Manual/SL-MultipleProgramVariants.html
• TheGamedev.Guru: Shader Variant Stripping — https://thegamedev.guru/unity-cpu-performance/shader-variants-stripping/
• Unity Web: Remove Unused Resources — https://docs.unity3d.com/2022.3/Documentation/Manual/web-optimization-remove-resources.html
• Unity Learn: Optimizing Graphics — https://learn.unity.com/tutorial/optimizing-graphics-in-unity