| name | submit |
| description | Submission pipeline — journal targeting, replication package, audit, and final gate. Replaces /submit, /target-journal, /audit-replication, /data-deposit. |
| argument-hint | [mode: target | package | audit | final] [journal name (optional)] |
| allowed-tools | Read,Grep,Glob,Write,Bash,Task |
Submit
Submission pipeline with four modes covering journal selection through final verification.
Input: $ARGUMENTS — mode keyword, optionally followed by journal name.
Modes
/submit target — Journal Targeting
Get ranked journal recommendations.
Agent: Orchestrator (journal selection function)
Considers: contribution fit, methodology fit, audience fit, recent publications, desk rejection risk. Consults .claude/references/domain-profile.md for journal tiers.
Output: Ranked list of 3 target journals with rationale.
Save to quality_reports/journal_recommendations_[date].md
/submit package — Build Replication Package
Assemble AEA-compliant replication package.
Agents: Coder + Verifier
Produces:
- Master script that runs all analyses end-to-end
- README with data sources, computational requirements, instructions
- Data documentation and codebook
- Organized file structure per AEA standards
Save to
paper/replication/
/submit audit — Audit Replication Package
Verify replication package completeness.
Agent: Verifier (submission mode — 10 checks)
Checks:
- Master script exists and runs
- All tables reproduce
- All figures reproduce
- README complete
- Data documentation present
- Numbered script order
- Dependencies listed
- Runtime documented
- Output paths match paper references
- No hardcoded paths
/submit final [journal] — Final Submission Gate
Full verification + score enforcement + submission checklist.
Workflow:
- Run comprehensive review if not done recently
- Run replication audit
- Check score gate: aggregate >= 95, all components >= 80
- If PASS: generate cover letter draft + submission checklist
- If FAIL: list blocking issues and stop
Principles
- Score >= 95 + all components >= 80. No exceptions.
- Don't skip verification. Even if reports exist, check they're recent.
- If it fails, stop. Don't generate materials for a failing paper.
- Cover letter is a draft. User must review before sending.
