migrate-widgets

name	migrate-widgets
description	Generates C# IWidgetMigration and IWidgetPropertyMigration extension code for custom widget and section type transformations (rename, restructure, consolidate, property conversion) during KX13→XbyK migration. Use when the user needs to change widget types, restructure widget data, or convert section types.
compatibility	Requires dotnet CLI and the Migration.Tool.Extensions project structure.
argument-hint	[migration-plan-path]

Widget Transformation Code Generation

Produces ready-to-use C# code files for the Migration.Tool.Extensions project. Takes the migration plan output from the migrate-plan skill — or a direct text description — as input.

Workflow

Step 1: Read Reference Materials

• Read widget-migration-api.md for the complete API patterns, annotated code samples, and decision guides.
• If you need pattern examples for implementation, read WIDGET_MIGRATION_EXAMPLE.cs for a complete annotated reference implementation showing all patterns.
• If you need context on the migration tool's extension points or configuration, read migration-tool.md.
• If you need documentation links for further research, read migration-docs.md.
• If a Kentico documentation lookup tool is available, use it for additional context on widget migration APIs, Page Builder JSON structure, or advanced patterns like content item creation during migration.

Step 2: Analyze Input

• If a migration plan file path is provided → read it and extract from the Widget Transformations section: Section Type Mappings, Custom Widget Type Mappings, Widget Restructuring, and Widget Property Transforms tables. Also check the Code Extensions to Implement table for rows where Type = IWidgetMigration or IWidgetPropertyMigration.
• If a direct text description is provided → identify source widget/section identifiers, target identifiers, property mappings, and transformation needs.
• Ask clarifying questions if the target widget types, property mappings, or value transformation logic are ambiguous.

Step 3: Identify Code Units to Generate

Determine the set of classes needed:

• One IWidgetMigration class per source widget or section type (or per consolidation group when multiple source types map to one target).
• One IWidgetPropertyMigration class per distinct property transformation pattern that is reusable across widgets or needs to be delegated via the propertyMigrations dictionary.
• One ServiceCollectionExtensions class (or addition to existing) for DI registration.
• Skip code generation for:
  • Built-in widgets with direct XbyK equivalents (Kentico.Widget.RichText, Kentico.FormWidget) — these migrate automatically.
  • Widgets that are unchanged (same identifier and properties in XbyK) AND have no properties requiring IWidgetPropertyMigration transforms.
  • Widgets explicitly excluded in the migration plan.
• Always generate an IWidgetMigration for any widget that needs property transforms via IWidgetPropertyMigration — even if the widget identifier is unchanged. The migration tool only invokes standalone IWidgetPropertyMigration classes when API Discovery provides EditingFormControlModel metadata for the property. If a KX13 widget property lacks an [EditingComponent(...)] attribute, EditingFormControlModel is null and the property migration is silently skipped. An IWidgetMigration that delegates properties via the propertyMigrations dictionary uses a separate code path (explicitMigrations) that does not depend on API Discovery.
• Recommend inline conversion in MigrateWidget when the property transformation is simple and specific to one widget (e.g., int→string ratio). Only create a separate IWidgetPropertyMigration when the transformation is reusable or needs to be delegated.
• Consider built-in property migrations first: WidgetFileMigration (media files, Rank 100,000), WidgetPathSelectorMigration (path selectors, Rank 100,001), and WidgetPageSelectorMigration (page selectors, Rank 100,002) handle common conversions automatically. Only create a custom IWidgetPropertyMigration to override a built-in when the default conversion target is wrong (e.g., page selector → ContentItemReference instead of WebPageRelatedItem).

Step 4: Generate Widget Migration Code

For each migration, generate a class implementing IWidgetMigration:

• Rank — use values < 100,000 (built-in defaults use 100,000+). Use small integers (1, 2, 3...) with gaps for future insertions.
• ShallMigrate — match on identifier.TypeIdentifier using string.Equals with StringComparison.InvariantCultureIgnoreCase. For multi-site scenarios, also filter on context.SiteId.
• MigrateWidget — change value["type"] to the target identifier, restructure value["variants"][0]["properties"] as a new JObject, populate the propertyMigrations dictionary for properties needing further conversion.
• Include a per-migration IServiceCollection extension method for DI registration in a separate static class (not inside the migration class itself — migration classes use primary constructors for DI injection, which makes them non-static, and C# requires extension methods to be in static classes).

For IWidgetPropertyMigration classes:

• ShallMigrate — match on propertyName or context.EditingFormControlModel?.FormComponentIdentifier. Do NOT use context.ComponentIdentifier — this property does not exist on WidgetPropertyMigrationContext. The context record only has SiteId and EditingFormControlModel.
• MigrateWidgetProperty — transform the JToken value and return a WidgetPropertyMigrationResult.
• Include a per-migration IServiceCollection extension method for DI registration in a separate static class (same rule as IWidgetMigration — see above).

Step 5: Generate Service Registration

Generate or update the ServiceCollectionExtensions static class:

• Call each migration's extension method.
• AddTransient<IWidgetMigration, T>() for each widget migration (NOT AddSingleton).
• AddTransient<IWidgetPropertyMigration, T>() for each property migration (NOT AddSingleton).
• Include comment noting that built-in widgets (Kentico.Widget.RichText, Kentico.FormWidget) do not need custom code.
• Include comment noting the QuerySourceInstanceApi appsettings prerequisite.

Step 6: Build Verification

1. Build the Migration.Tool.Extensions project to verify the generated code compiles without errors.
2. If the build fails, analyze the error messages, fix all issues in the generated code, and rebuild.
3. Repeat up to 3 attempts. If the build still fails after 3 attempts, present the full build output and error details to the user for manual resolution.

6b. Verify Registration Completeness

After a successful build, verify all generated migrations are properly registered:

1. Read the ServiceCollectionExtensions class and confirm every IWidgetMigration has a corresponding AddTransient<IWidgetMigration, T>() call (NOT AddSingleton — widget migrations are not safe as singletons).
2. Read the ServiceCollectionExtensions class and confirm every IWidgetPropertyMigration has a corresponding AddTransient<IWidgetPropertyMigration, T>() call.
3. Cross-reference against the migration plan's "Widget Transformations" section and "Code Extensions to Implement" table — every widget type listed with a custom mapping must have a generated file and a registration.
4. If any migration is missing registration or uses AddSingleton instead of AddTransient, fix and rebuild.

Step 7: Present and Refine

• Save files to the user-specified path (default: Migration.Tool.Extensions/WidgetMigrations/ — generated code belongs in the Migration.Tool.Extensions project, matching the Migration.Tool.Extensions.WidgetMigrations namespace).

• Provide a summary table using this format:

  File	Pattern	Rank	Handles
  HeroContentWidgetMigration.cs	IWidgetMigration	1	Maps Acme.HeroWidget → Acme.HeroBanner, creates content item for image

• Ask if any migrations need adjustment and iterate on feedback.

Rules

• Follow exact API patterns from widget-migration-api.md — do not invent methods or types that don't exist.
• Handle both structured (migration plan) and free-text input.
• Widget JSON access pattern: value["type"] for the type identifier, ((JArray)value["variants"]!)[0]["properties"] for the property bag.
• Reference built-in WidgetFileMigration (media files) and WidgetPageSelectorMigration (page selectors) in the propertyMigrations dictionary rather than reimplementing conversion logic.
• Namespace: Migration.Tool.Extensions.WidgetMigrations (user can override).
• File naming convention: {TargetWidgetName}WidgetMigration.cs for widget migrations, {Concern}PropertyMigration.cs for property migrations.
• Use string constants for source/target identifiers, following the Source_/Target_ prefix convention from the example.
• Add TODO comments for values unknown at generation time (e.g., media GUID lookups, resource key resolution dictionaries, content item GUIDs).
• If a Kentico documentation lookup tool is available, verify uncertain API details before generating code.
• When overriding a built-in property migration, use Rank < 100,000 to take priority over the built-in (100,000+). The ShallMigrate of the custom migration should match the same FormComponentIdentifier (via Kx13FormComponents constants) as the built-in it replaces.
• This skill generates IWidgetMigration and IWidgetPropertyMigration code only — IClassMapping, IFieldMigration, ContentItemDirectorBase, and appsettings configuration are separate extension points covered by other skills.

Gotchas

• Use AddTransient for DI registration — never AddSingleton. Widget migrations are not safe to reuse as singletons.
• ShallMigrate must use StringComparison.InvariantCultureIgnoreCase — widget type identifiers are case-insensitive.
• Never write custom code for built-in widgets (Kentico.Widget.RichText, Kentico.FormWidget) — they migrate automatically.
• Check built-in property migrations (WidgetFileMigration, WidgetPathSelectorMigration, WidgetPageSelectorMigration) before writing custom IWidgetPropertyMigration classes — only override when the default conversion target is wrong.
• Section types use the same IWidgetMigration interface as widgets — there is no separate section migration interface.
• WidgetPropertyMigrationContext only has SiteId and EditingFormControlModel — there is no ComponentIdentifier property. Do not try to filter by widget type in IWidgetPropertyMigration.ShallMigrate. If you need widget-type-scoped property transforms, do them inline in the IWidgetMigration.MigrateWidget method or delegate via the propertyMigrations dictionary (which is already widget-scoped).
• Standalone IWidgetPropertyMigration requires API Discovery — the migration tool's VisualBuilderPatcher only calls GetWidgetPropertyMigration (rank-based lookup) when the property has a non-null EditingFormControlModel from API Discovery. KX13 widget properties without [EditingComponent(...)] attributes produce null EditingFormControlModel, silently skipping all property migrations. Always pair standalone IWidgetPropertyMigration classes with an IWidgetMigration that explicitly delegates via propertyMigrations to guarantee execution regardless of API Discovery metadata.
• Extension methods must be in separate static classes — migration classes that use primary constructors (for DI injection of ILogger, ModelFacade, etc.) are non-static. C# requires extension methods to be defined in non-generic static classes. Place the Add{MigrationName} extension method in a companion static class {MigrationName}Extensions in the same file.