cross-leader-synthesis

name	cross-leader-synthesis
description	Synthesize perspectives from multiple opinion leaders on a shared topic into a cross-referenced wiki index page. Use when the user wants to consolidate different viewpoints on the same concept.
category	wiki
version	1.0.0
metadata	{"hermes":{"tags":["wiki","synthesis","opinion-leaders","cross-reference"],"homepage":"https://github.com/kzinmr/ai-topics"}}

Cross-Leader Synthesis

Purpose

When multiple opinion leaders discuss the same topic (e.g., Agentic Engineering, AI Evaluation), consolidate their perspectives into a single synthesis index page that maps convergences, divergences, and unresolved questions.

When to Use

• User asks to "集約" (aggregate) different leaders' views on a topic
• Multiple wiki pages exist for the same concept from different sources
• The topic is emerging and has no single authoritative source
• Building a cross-reference hub for a subdirectory of concept pages

Workflow

1. Identify the Theme and Leaders

# Search wiki for pages on the topic
search_files "<theme>" path="~/wiki/" target="content"
# Check entity pages for related opinion leaders

2. Extract Per-Leader Perspectives

For each leader's entity page or concept pages:

• Core philosophy/stance on the topic
• Named frameworks or patterns they've coined
• Direct quotes (>30% for L3 quality)
• Practical examples or implementations
• Sources and dates

3. Build Synthesis Structure

Create <theme>/_index.md with:

• リーダー別コンセプト一覧 — table mapping each leader to their key concepts
• テーマ別議論 — group by sub-themes (e.g., evaluation, cognitive load, autonomy)
• 収束点 — what everyone agrees on
• 対立点 — where opinions diverge
• 未解決課題 — open questions across all leaders
• 概念マップ — ASCII/mermaid diagram showing relationships
• 関連ページ — links to deeper concept pages

4. Cross-Reference

Every synthesis page must:

• Link to each leader's entity page via [[wikilinks]]
• Link to related concept pages in the subdirectory
• Be linked FROM each concept page back to the synthesis index
• Be added to wiki/index.md under the appropriate section
• Be logged in wiki/log.md

5. Update Navigation

• Add _index.md to the top of the subdirectory as the entry point
• Update parent concept page (if exists) to link to the synthesis index
• Run lint check: no orphan pages, all wikilinks resolve

Template Structure

---
title: "Topic Name — Cross-Leader Synthesis"
aliases: [topic-index, topic-synthesis]
created: YYYY-MM-DD
updated: YYYY-MM-DD
tags: [concept, index, topic-name]
status: draft
---

# Topic Name — 主要オピニオンリーダーの視点統合

## リーダー別主要コンセプト
| リーダー | コアコンセプト | 関連ページ |
|---------|--------------|-----------|
| [[person-a]] | ... | ... |

## 主要テーマ別議論
### 🧪 Theme 1
- **Person A**: [summary](link.md)
- **Person B**: [summary](link.md)
- **共通教訓**: "..."

## 議論の収束点
### ✅ 全員が同意していること
1. ...
2. ...

### ⚡ 意見が分かれる領域
1. ...

### 🔍 未解決の課題
- ...

## 概念マップ
(ASCII/mermaid diagram)

## 更新履歴
| 日付 | 変更内容 |

Pitfalls

• Don't create synthesis without substantive content — each leader needs actual sourced perspectives, not just names
• Don't claim consensus without evidence — only list convergences that are directly stated by multiple leaders
• Don't paraphrase quotes — use exact wording with source URLs for L3 quality
• Always update index.md and log.md — synthesis pages are navigational hubs
• Frontmatter must include status: draft until all leader perspectives are filled in
• Subdirectory convention — place _index.md at the root of the concept subdirectory (e.g., concepts/agentic-engineering/_index.md)