mold

name	mold
description	Iterative thinking amplifier for fuzzy ideas. Routes input to the right starting mode (Explore, Ground, Shape, Sketch, Grill, Diagnose), runs Validate Cycles to anchor claims, locks down interfaces in pseudocode, and only curdles a spec (and optional issues) after a two-key handshake plus a coherence self-check.
license	MIT
compatibility	Works in markdown-based coding harnesses with sub-agent support. Heavy delegation to /briesearch and cheez-* skills. When tilth MCP is absent, substitute the host Read tool for local file references — the no-speculation invariant (Operating Principle 2) still holds.
metadata	{"owner":"cheese-flow","category":"planning"}
allowed-tools	["read","write","bash","subagent"]

/mold

Use this skill when the user has a fuzzy idea and wants to converge — through dialogue, evidence, and interface lockdown — on a coherent spec (and optional issues) that downstream /cheese and /cook can consume without re-asking design questions.

Do not use this skill for one-shot implementation, free-form rubber-ducking without artifact intent (use /culture), or library-only research (use /briesearch directly).

What /mold is

A thinking amplifier, not a pre-prompt. The dialogue is the point; artifacts are the by-product. The terminal step curdles whatever the dialogue actually produced — never more, never less.

Companion	Boundary
/culture	Same dialogue feel; never writes. Use it when there is no artifact intent.
/briesearch	External evidence dispatcher. /mold calls it through the Validate Cycle.
/nih-audit	Whole-repo build-vs-buy sweep. /mold calls it from Sketch when multiple library-shaped categories are in play, or offers it at Curdle for migration-style specs.
/cook	Implements a curdled spec. /mold ends with a hand-off offer, never an auto-invoke.

Operating principles

1. No fixed entry point. Inspect input shape and pick a starting mode. Announce the mode in one line. Low-confidence classifications default to Explore.
2. Ground every load-bearing claim. Never speculate about local code or external behavior without a cheez-* call or a Validate Cycle.
3. State a hypothesis before researching. A bare research dispatch is discouraged; the Validate Cycle frame forces commitment plus a judgment step.
4. Lock down interfaces before curdling. Every cross-slice seam gets a pseudocode signature with named unknowns, a recommended answer, and an explicit Sliced Bread slice (domains/<name>, adapters/<name>, app, or domains/common). Architecture rules in references/sliced-bread.md (repo root, not local to this skill).
5. Two-key handshake. Both the user (explicit verb) and the agent (coherence self-check) must agree before extraction.
6. Heavy delegation. /briesearch for external research, cheez-search / cheez-read for in-repo grounding. Do not reinvent.
7. No production writes during the loop. The only writes happen on Curdle, after explicit approval.

Routing — input shape to starting mode

Input shape	Start mode	Heuristic
Stack trace, "X is broken/slow/flaky"	Diagnose	error markers, file:line refs, symptom verbs
File path, PR ref, existing spec under .cheese/specs/	Ground	concrete artifact exists; read it first
Half-baked design doc with signatures or schemas	Sketch	already has interfaces; refine them
"I want to add X" with concrete nouns	Shape	named the thing → jump to options
"Should we do X? thinking about Y"	Grill	tentative plan exists → stress-test it
Vague noun, half-sentence, "thinking about"	Explore	no grounded artifact, no chosen direction

Detail in references/routing.md.

The six modes

Curdle is a terminal state, not a mode.

Explore — intent extraction

Job: collapse ambiguity with high-leverage questions. Borrow the Beat 0 framing (Job-To-Be-Done, Why Now, What This Unlocks, Who Has The Pain, Do Nothing). Use lettered options to compress decisions. Exit when: a problem statement plus one concrete pain point is articulated.

Ground — anti-hallucination

Job: anchor every claim to evidence — code, docs, prior research. Probe glossary conflicts against any harness convention files (CONTEXT.md, CLAUDE.md, project root agent guides) found on entry. Sharpen fuzzy language: when the user uses overloaded or ambiguous terms ("account", "session", "user"), pause and resolve with a canonical-term question (e.g. "you said 'account' — do you mean Customer or User? Those are different things"). Resolved terms get logged in the state file's Decisions block so later modes use the canonical name. Invariant: never say "I think the code does X" without a cheez-* call. Exit when: every load-bearing claim has a citation.

Shape — option generation

Job: turn a grounded problem into 2+ candidate approaches with trade-offs. Always include Do Nothing. Recommend with one-line rationale. Validate Cycle any load-bearing assumption behind a recommendation. Exit when: an option is picked (→ Sketch) or none survive (→ Explore).

Sketch — interface lockdown

Job: lock modules, responsibilities, I/O contracts, and seams in pseudocode signatures, anchored to Sliced Bread slices. Before drafting, parallel cheez-search for sibling signatures in the same slice so new ones fit conventions and respect the crust (the slice's public API). Run an NIH probe (single Validate Cycle) before locking any signature whose category is library-shaped — retry, validation, UUID, debounce, date, argparse, clone, string-case, crypto, sanitizer, format, deep-equality. If 2+ such categories are in play, call /nih-audit once instead. Exit when: every public seam has a signature and a declared slice field; every cross-slice call imports from the target slice's crust, never its internals; library-shaped categories have an NIH probe verdict in Decisions. Detail in references/sketch-mode.md; architecture rules in references/sliced-bread.md (repo root, not local to this skill).

Grill — adversarial clarification

Job: stress-test the chosen approach plus sketched interfaces. One question at a time, paired with the agent's recommended answer. The recommendation is non-optional. Traverse decision branches and contract corners. When grill surfaces an unverified assumption, pause and run a Validate Cycle. Exit when: every branch and contract corner is touched and agent confidence is at least user confidence.

Diagnose — symptom inputs

Job: entry mode for stack traces and "X is broken". Phases: Build a Loop → Reproduce → Hypothesize (3-5 ranked, falsifiable, parallel Validate Cycles) → Confirm root cause. Phase 0 (Build a Loop) is the core discipline — agree on a fast, deterministic, falsifiable feedback technique (failing test, curl/CLI script, headless browser, replay, bisection harness, differential loop, ...) before chasing hypotheses. The chosen loop becomes the Reproduction block in the bug-shaped spec, so /cook can verify the fix against the same signal the diagnosis used. Diagnose is diagnostic-only — hand-off to Shape ("what's the fix?") then Curdle emits a bug-shaped spec plus optional follow-up issues. Loop menu and discipline in references/diagnose-mode.md.

The Validate Cycle (cross-mode sub-pattern)

Any mode can invoke it. Always announce the cycle before dispatching.

Launching a validate cycle on hypothesis: "<single declarative sentence>"

Plan:
  /briesearch  — fetch evidence
  Judge        — support, contradict, or refine?
  Settle       — accept, revise, or reject. Continue from current mode.

Outcomes write to the state file's Validate cycles block:

• SUPPORTED — evidence aligns; hypothesis becomes a decision.
• CONTRADICTED — evidence disagrees; surface as [CONFLICT <id>] (e.g. [CONFLICT cf-1]); revise or abandon.
• REFINED — evidence partially aligns; restate with new precision and re-validate or accept.

Diagnose's parallel hypothesis ranking is the cycle, parallelized.

Cap: max two /briesearch calls per session unless the user requests more. Cycles backed by cheez-* evidence alone are unbudgeted.

Detail in references/validate-cycle.md.

Sub-agent dispatch

Tool	When	Cap
/briesearch (via Validate Cycle)	hypothesis needs external evidence	2/session
/nih-audit	Sketch surfaces 2+ library-shaped categories, or the spec smells migration-shaped	1/session
cheez-search	symbol mention, dependency claim, callers/imports lookup, sibling lookup	unbudgeted
cheez-read	file mention, spec read on entry	unbudgeted

cheez-search covers blast-radius work via its kind: "callers" mode and tilth_deps tool — use it instead of looking for a separate dependency skill.

Parallel sweeps:

• Shape Sweep — one turn fans out 3-4 cheez-search reads (symbol + callers + deps) plus optional /briesearch before drafting Options.
• Sketch Sweep — parallel cheez-search for nearby siblings before drafting signatures for a module.
• Hypothesis Probe (Diagnose) — parallel Validate Cycles, one per ranked hypothesis.

State tracking

Scratch state file at ${TMPDIR:-/tmp}/cheese-flow-mold-<run_id>/state.md. Mirrors /briesearch's scratch pattern: portable, auto-evicted post-session.

The file records mode, input summary, decisions, locked sketches, validate cycles with outcomes, open questions with markers, and mode history. Schema in references/state-schema.md.

User knobs (free-form interrupts)

explore, ground, shape, sketch, grill, diagnose, validate <hypothesis>, nih, curdle, pause, enough. The agent honours these immediately. curdle initiates the handshake; it does not skip the Sketch gate unless the user follows up with curdle anyway. nih forces an NIH probe at the current sketch even when the category does not match the library-shaped trigger words.

Uncertainty markers

Marker	Meaning
[?]	Agent uncertain; needs validation
[TBD]	User uncertain; decision deferred
[BLOCKED]	External dependency unresolved
[CONFLICT <id>]	Codebase contradicts a stated assumption; <id> (e.g. cf-1) links back to the contradicted validate cycle's conflict_id

Termination — two-key handshake

User key: explicit curdle, ship it, extract, that's enough. Never inferred.

Agent key: structured coherence self-check. Print this checklist and require every box checked before extraction (or an explicit override):

Coherence self-check before curdle:
- [ ] Problem statement: grounded, agreed
- [ ] At least 2 options weighed (Do Nothing included)
- [ ] Chosen option grounded in codebase evidence
- [ ] Interface sketches: every public seam has a pseudocode signature
- [ ] Each sketch declares a Sliced Bread slice; cross-slice calls go through the crust
- [ ] Validate cycles: all launched cycles judged
- [ ] Chosen option Grilled (>=1 `Grill turns` entry per major branch)
- [ ] Open questions all marked [TBD] / [BLOCKED] / [?] (none silent)
- [ ] Quality gates specified (>=1 `Quality gates` entry, runnable command)
- [ ] Reproduction loop captured if Diagnose ran (or `[BLOCKED]` if no loop is possible)

Guard conditions are mandatory before Curdle except where noted:

• Ground gate — at least one Ground pass with a citation before Shape's options. Exception: pure greenfield (the agent must say so).
• Shape gate — at least one Option block weighed (Do Nothing counts).
• Sketch gate — mandatory when the chosen option touches more than one module or introduces a new public interface. Skip only for trivial single-function changes (the agent must say so).
• Grill gate — mandatory for high-blast-radius decisions, where blast radius is measured by cheez-search callers/imports for the touched symbols.
• Open hypotheses must settle — any Validate Cycle launched but unjudged blocks Curdle unless the user accepts it as [TBD].

If any box is unchecked, name it and propose the smallest move to fill it. The user can override with curdle anyway.

Curdle — artifact extraction

Two artifact types:

• Spec — the rich container; absorbs problem framing, requirements, approach, decisions, interface sketches, risks, gates. Always present unless the dialogue produced only standalone bug tickets. Template in references/spec.md.
• Issue (1..N) — separate, GitHub-flavored, when the dialogue surfaced actionable items independent of the main spec scope. Template in references/issue.md.

Format selection table:

Dialogue signal	Output
Any meaningful design discussion	Spec
Side-channel actionables (out-of-scope bugs, follow-ups)	Spec + Issues (bug/chore flavor)
Plan broke down into independently-grabbable atoms	Spec + Issues (slice flavor — vertical slices, AFK/HITL, blocked-by graph)
Diagnose root cause + fix design	Spec (bug-shaped) + optional Issues
Pure decision-only (no design)	Spec with only Decisions populated

Confirm in one approval prompt covering the artifact set, the slug, and the target paths. Render drafts inline first if the user wants to iterate before any disk writes.

Output paths (relative to the project root):

Output	Path
Spec only	.cheese/specs/<slug>.md
Issues only	.cheese/issues/<slug>-001.md, -002.md, ...
Spec + Issues	spec at .cheese/specs/<slug>.md; issues at .cheese/issues/<slug>-001.md, ...

Slug derivation: lowercase the working problem statement, drop stopwords, kebab-case, cap at 5 words. Honour user-passed slugs verbatim.

Collisions:

Existing	Action
Same slug, status draft	Overwrite (default) or rev (<slug>-v2)
Same slug, status approved	Default rev; never silently overwrite
Existing spec, new issues for same slug	Append issues to that slug's series

Confidence is tagged twice — document-level in spec frontmatter (mechanical formula in references/spec.md) and inline at decision points in the spec body.

Write atomically: stage to a temp directory, then move into place. Never leave partial files on a write failure.

Hand-off

After writing, offer the next step inline. Never auto-invoke.

Artifact	Suggested next step
Spec	/cook .cheese/specs/<slug>.md
Migration-shaped spec (≥1 NIH probe verdict of accept or revise)	/nih-audit <scope> first, then /cook
Issues	gh issue create --body-file <path> (per file)

"Migration-shaped" is defined in references/sketch-mode.md (Migration hand-off).

Loop detection

The session can stall. The agent watches for:

• Drift — 4 consecutive turns without a new Decisions, Sketches, or Validate cycles entry → surface, propose summary or pause.
• Bored user — terse responses, repeated meh → surface escape hatches.
• Rabbit hole — 3+ mode transitions in the last 5 turns and no new state entries → forced synthesis turn.

Rules in references/loop-detection.md.

Rules

• Do not write to production paths during the dialogue. Only Curdle writes files, only after the two-key handshake.
• Do not direct-call /briesearch for unstated questions; wrap external evidence in a Validate Cycle.
• Do not skip the Sketch gate for non-trivial features without an explicit declaration.
• Do not silently drop open hypotheses; they must settle or be marked [TBD].
• Do not overwrite an approved spec without explicit user opt-in.
• Do not attempt to implement code; pseudocode signatures are plan, not code.