argocd

name

argocd

description

Deep ArgoCD operational intuition — sync waves and hook lifecycle, ApplicationSet generators, Sync vs Health, drift root causes, sync options, AppProject constraints, rollback, multi-cluster. Load for sync ordering, hook design, drift diagnosis, generator selection, rollback planning, or multi-cluster registration. Skip for "what is GitOps", install walkthroughs, or basic Application YAML. Triggers on: "sync wave", "presync hook", "syncfail", "applicationset generator", "matrix generator", "hpa replicas drift", "ignoreDifferences", "ServerSideApply", "Replace=true", "self-heal", "app-of-apps cascade".

ArgoCD Operational Guide

Concise operational pointers for deep ArgoCD troubleshooting and design.

Assumes you already know Kubernetes, GitOps, and basic Application/ApplicationSet shape. This skill covers the operational layer — sync-wave/hook ordering, drift root causes, sync-option semantics, ApplicationSet pitfalls, multi-cluster, rollback caveats — the parts models tend to gloss over.

When to use

Load when the question is about:

• Sync waves, hook phases, hook deletion policies, leftover-Job pitfalls
• Drift diagnosis (HPA, mutating/defaulting webhooks, status fields, Helm randomness)
• Sync option choice — Replace vs ServerSideApply, RespectIgnoreDifferences, PruneLast
• Sync vs Health distinction; custom Lua health for CRDs
• ApplicationSet generator selection, templating, regeneration semantics
• AppProject scoping (sourceRepos, destinations, sync windows, RBAC tokens)
• Rollback semantics, auto-sync vs manual revert, app-of-apps cascade
• Multi-cluster registration and discovery
• Image-updater and built-in notifications

Do NOT load for: explaining what GitOps is, first-time ArgoCD install walkthroughs, vanilla Application CRD authoring without operational tension. Those don't need this skill.

Sync waves and phases

• Phases run in fixed order: PreSync → Sync → PostSync. On failure of any of those: SyncFail. On Application deletion (with finalizer): PostDelete.
• Wave annotation: argocd.argoproj.io/sync-wave: "N" — integer, negatives allowed (run before wave 0). Default for resources/hooks without the annotation is wave 0.
• Within a phase, ArgoCD orders by: phase → wave (lower first) → kind (Namespaces first, then native, then CRs) → name. Same wave + same kind → applied together (no further ordering guarantee).
• Use waves for fine-grained ordering inside a phase, hooks for coarse-grained phase placement. Combine: a PreSync Job with sync-wave: "-5" runs before another PreSync Job with wave 0.
• CRDs before CRs: put the CRD in an early wave (e.g., -10) and the CR in wave 0, or use PruneLast=true so deletion order reverses cleanly.

Hooks

• Hook annotation: argocd.argoproj.io/hook: PreSync|Sync|PostSync|SyncFail|PostDelete|Skip. Skip tells ArgoCD not to apply the manifest at all (useful for resources you want present in the repo but managed elsewhere).
• Sync-phase hook runs concurrently with the regular Sync apply. Pre/PostSync hooks are gates: PostSync only runs once all Sync resources are Healthy.
• Deletion policy (argocd.argoproj.io/hook-delete-policy:):
  • BeforeHookCreation (default since v1.3): delete prior hook resource before re-creating. Idempotent re-runs.
  • HookSucceeded: delete after success.
  • HookFailed: delete after failure.
  • Omitting any policy + immutable Job spec → leftover Job/Pod accumulation, sync hangs reapplying the immutable resource. Always set one.
• Common pattern: PreSync DB migration Job (wave -10, BeforeHookCreation) + PostSync smoke-test Job (wave 10, HookSucceeded).
• PostDelete (since v2.10): runs when the Application is deleted and the deletion finalizer (resources-finalizer.argocd.argoproj.io) is set. Adds two extra finalizers (post-delete-finalizer.argocd.argoproj.io and .../cleanup); known issues with ApplicationSet-generated apps stuck in Deletion state — manually remove finalizers if hung.
• Hook resource naming: use generateName: so each invocation gets a unique name; using name: plus BeforeHookCreation re-creates with the same name and is fine, but HookSucceeded + name: will collide on re-sync if the prior hook still exists.

Sync options

Set per-app via spec.syncPolicy.syncOptions: [Opt=value, ...] or per-resource via annotation argocd.argoproj.io/sync-options: Opt1=true,Opt2=false.

• Replace=true: uses kubectl replace/create (not three-way merge). Destructive — drops fields ArgoCD didn't write (annotations from controllers, status, etc.). Recreates resources that fail to patch. Takes precedence over ServerSideApply=true. Use only for objects that legitimately need rewriting (Jobs with immutable spec).
• ServerSideApply=true: delegates to Kubernetes server-side apply with field manager argocd-controller (override via argocd.argoproj.io/client-side-apply-migration-manager). Conflicts with other field managers surface as sync errors; use Force=true on the same resource to overwrite.
• RespectIgnoreDifferences=true: makes spec.ignoreDifferences[] apply at sync time, not just diff time. Without this, Argo will re-write the field you said to ignore on the next sync (e.g., replicas for HPA). Only effective once the resource exists — initial creation still uses Git values. Pair with ServerSideApply=true for HPA-managed deployments.
• PruneLast=true: defers prunes to the end of the Sync phase, after creates/updates are Healthy. Avoids deleting CRDs before CRs, or Services before workloads. Per-resource annotation common for the resource that must die last.
• PrunePropagationPolicy=foreground|background|orphan: Kubernetes deletion propagation. foreground (default for prune) blocks until garbage-collected; orphan leaves children intact (rarely what you want for namespaces).
• CreateNamespace=true: creates spec.destination.namespace if absent. Note this only sets the bare namespace; for labels/annotations on the namespace, manage it as its own manifest.
• ApplyOutOfSyncOnly=true: skips re-applying already-in-sync resources. Reduces controller load on large apps. Sync hooks still run regardless.
• FailOnSharedResource=true: fail sync if another Application already manages a resource (otherwise, last-writer wins silently).
• Validate=false: skip kubectl validation. Almost never needed; usually a workaround for CRD conversion bugs.
• SkipDryRunOnMissingResource=true: skip dry-run when the CRD isn't installed yet. Required when the same Application installs the CRD and a CR of that kind in adjacent waves.
• Server-side diff is a separate concept from ServerSideApply: enable per-app via argocd.argoproj.io/compare-options: ServerSideDiff=true or controller-wide via controller.diff.server.side: "true". Delegates diff computation to API server (sees defaulting webhooks, server defaults). Won't run on resource creation (resource doesn't exist yet to compare).

Sync vs Health (orthogonal)

• Sync = "live state matches Git" — boolean Synced/OutOfSync/Unknown.
• Health = "resource is operationally OK" — Healthy, Progressing, Degraded, Suspended, Missing, Unknown.
• A Synced app can be Degraded (CrashLoopBackOff) and an OutOfSync app can be Healthy (someone scaled a Deployment in-cluster, replicas differ from Git but pods run).
• App-level health rollup: worst child wins, priority Healthy > Suspended > Progressing > Missing > Degraded > Unknown. Parent CRDs do not automatically inherit child status — the parent must surface child state in its own status fields, or you need a custom health check.
• Custom health for a CRD via Lua in argocd-cm:

  data:
    resource.customizations.health.<group>_<kind>: |
      hs = {}
      if obj.status ~= nil and obj.status.phase == "Ready" then
        hs.status = "Healthy"
      else
        hs.status = "Progressing"
      end
      hs.message = obj.status and obj.status.message or ""
      return hs
  

  ArgoCD ships defaults for many common CRDs (cert-manager, Argo Rollouts, Flux); only override when defaults misclassify.

Drift root causes

Live ≠ Git on apparently boring resources. Almost always one of:

• HPA mutates spec.replicas of Deployment/StatefulSet. Fix: omit replicas from Git and set ignoreDifferences with jsonPointers: ["/spec/replicas"] and RespectIgnoreDifferences=true (otherwise sync rewrites it).
• Mutating admission webhooks (Istio/Linkerd sidecar injection, Vault injector, Kyverno) add containers/volumes post-apply. Fix: ignoreDifferences with jqPathExpressions for the injected paths, or managedFieldsManagers: [linkerd-proxy-injector].
• Defaulting webhooks / server-side defaults populate fields absent in Git (e.g., volumeName on PVC, clusterIP on Service, caBundle on webhook configs). Fix: server-side diff (ServerSideDiff=true) — API server returns the defaulted state for comparison, drift disappears.
• CRD status fields shipped in Git: ArgoCD diffs include status by default for CRDs. Fix: resource.compareoptions.ignoreResourceStatusField: crd in argocd-cm (system-wide) or ignoreDifferences per-app.
• Helm non-determinism: randAlphaNum, now, secret-generation templates produce different output every render → permanent OutOfSync. Fix: stable inputs, or store generated values in a Secret outside Helm.
• CRD apiVersion conversion: declared as v1beta1, served as v1. Fix: write Git in the served version.
• System-wide ignore for a noisy field across all kinds: resource.customizations.ignoreDifferences.all in argocd-cm with managedFieldsManagers.

ApplicationSet

• Generators (canonical names): list, cluster, git (directory mode and file mode), matrix, merge, scmProvider, pullRequest, clusterDecisionResource, plugin.
• matrix combines two generators into the cartesian product. Limits: only two child generators, only one level of matrix/merge nesting. The consumer generator must come after the producer in the list. Same-named parameters from the inner override the outer.
• merge unions parameter sets by a mergeKeys field; later generators override earlier on key conflict. Use for "extend baseline list with overrides".
• cluster generator selects ArgoCD-registered clusters via selector.matchLabels against the cluster Secret labels (label your cluster Secrets env=prod, then select). Out of the box: name, nameNormalized, server, metadata.labels.*, metadata.annotations.* parameters.
• pullRequest (and scmProvider) hits SCM APIs — beware GitHub's 5,000/hour authenticated rate limit. Use requeueAfterSeconds (default 30 min) to throttle.
• goTemplate: true plus goTemplateOptions: ["missingkey=error"] is recommended — default fasttemplate silently leaves {{ key }} literal on missing values; missingkey=error fails the generation. Go template uses dot notation {{ .name }}. Sprig functions available except env/expandenv/getHostByName. Plus ArgoCD-specific normalize and slugify.
• applyNestedSelectors: true applies selectors inside nested generators. In ArgoCD 3.0+ the field is ignored — behavior is always "as if true".
• preservedFields controls which Application annotations/labels survive ApplicationSet regeneration. Default preserved set covers ArgoCD's own notifications.argoproj.io/* and refresh annotations. Anything else added out-of-band (e.g., team-added skip-reconcile) is wiped on the next reconcile unless listed:

  spec:
    preservedFields:
      annotations: ["my.org/skip-reconcile"]
      labels: ["my.org/team"]
  

• applicationsSync policy: create-only (no updates, no deletes), create-update (updates yes, deletes no), sync (default: full). Use create-update to prevent runaway deletes during testing.
• syncPolicy.preserveResourcesOnDeletion: true: deleting the ApplicationSet does not delete the child Application's managed resources. Important for "destroy ApplicationSet but keep prod" disasters.

AppProject

• Restrictions (CR AppProject.spec):
  • sourceRepos: [...] — allowed repo URLs (glob).
  • destinations: [{server, namespace}] — allowed cluster+namespace pairs.
  • clusterResourceWhitelist / clusterResourceBlacklist — cluster-scoped kinds (e.g., allow only Namespace).
  • namespaceResourceBlacklist / namespaceResourceWhitelist — namespace-scoped kinds.
  • permitOnlyProjectScopedClusters: true — bars cluster bypass via other projects.
• Roles + JWT tokens: roles[] define policies (p, proj:foo:role, applications, sync, foo/*, allow) and can mint per-project JWT tokens for CI/CD without touching SSO.
• Sync windows: windows[].kind: allow|deny with schedule (cron) + duration + optional timeZone. Deny overrides allow when both active. Selectors (applications, namespaces, clusters) are OR'd. manualSync: true lets users override deny via CLI/UI — defaults to false.
• Orphaned resources: orphanedResources.warn: true flags resources in destination namespaces not owned by any Application; useful for audit.

Rollback and auto-sync

• argocd app rollback APPNAME ID where ID is the history ID from argocd app history APPNAME (a small integer, not a git SHA). ArgoCD records the manifest snapshot at each sync and rolls back to that snapshot.
• Hard precondition: rollback is rejected if automated sync is enabled. Workflow: argocd app set APPNAME --sync-policy none → argocd app rollback APPNAME 42 → fix Git → argocd app set APPNAME --sync-policy automated --self-heal.
• Rollback is temporary if auto-sync is on — even after disabling, the next manual sync (or re-enabled auto) pulls HEAD again. Permanent fix is git revert of the bad commit.
• automated.prune: true: deletes resources no longer in Git. Without it, removed-from-Git resources persist as orphans.
• automated.selfHeal: true: reverts in-cluster mutations within ~5s (reconciliationTimeoutSeconds). Off by default; without it, drift is detected but not auto-fixed.
• automated.allowEmpty: true: permits sync to a state with zero resources. Off by default — guards against an empty-repo accident wiping prod.

Multi-cluster

• Register a cluster: argocd cluster add CONTEXT [--name X] [--in-cluster]. Creates a ServiceAccount + ClusterRole + ClusterRoleBinding in the target cluster (default name argocd-manager), extracts the bearer token, stores a Secret in the ArgoCD namespace labeled argocd.argoproj.io/secret-type: cluster. The Secret carries name, server, and config (JSON: bearer token, TLS, IAM/AWS/GCP auth).
• Cluster generator discovers these Secrets and matches via selector.matchLabels — label the cluster Secret (metadata.labels.env=prod) and the generator templates per cluster.
• Per-cluster auth modes in the Secret config: bearerToken, awsAuthConfig (IRSA), execProviderConfig (GCP, Azure AD), tlsClientConfig. Use IRSA/Workload Identity over long-lived tokens.
• Project-scoped clusters: set project: on the cluster Secret to bind it to one AppProject only.
• Topology: one ArgoCD controlling many clusters scales to ~50–100 clusters with appropriate sharding (controller.sharding.algorithm); beyond that, federation/ArgoCD-per-cluster.
• RBAC split: argocd-server only needs SSO/UI permissions; argocd-application-controller needs the broad cluster admin scope on remote clusters. Don't conflate the two ServiceAccounts.

Auxiliary components

• argocd-image-updater (separate component, argoproj-labs/argocd-image-updater): bumps image tags. Annotate the Application:

  argocd-image-updater.argoproj.io/image-list: app=registry/myapp
  argocd-image-updater.argoproj.io/app.update-strategy: semver|latest|digest|name
  argocd-image-updater.argoproj.io/write-back-method: argocd|git
  

  • argocd write-back: imperative param override stored in Application spec → lost on argocd app delete, not visible in Git.
  • git write-back: commits to repo (Helm values.yaml or Kustomize image overrides). Required for true GitOps; needs SCM credentials Secret.
  • Update strategies — semver: respects ranges; latest: most recent build date; digest: pin to mutable tag (e.g., latest) and update on digest change; name: lexical sort.
  • Conflict on overlapping image-list patterns across multiple Applications causes ping-pong rewrites.
• Notifications (built-in since 2.3, was a separate argocd-notifications project): argocd-notifications-cm ConfigMap holds triggers, templates, services. Subscribe per-app via annotation notifications.argoproj.io/subscribe.<trigger>.<service>: <recipient> (e.g., notifications.argoproj.io/subscribe.on-sync-failed.slack: my-channel). Services: slack, email, webhook, pagerduty, pagerdutyv2, teams, telegram, etc.

Common pitfalls

• Stuck OutOfSync from defaulting webhooks → switch to ServerSideDiff=true (server-side diff sees the defaulted live state).
• automated.prune: true deletes a namespace and everything in it when you remove the namespace from Git → use PruneLast=true on critical resources, or split namespace management out of the app.
• Hook Job left behind every sync → missing hook-delete-policy. Always BeforeHookCreation or HookSucceeded.
• App-of-apps deletion wipes children when finalizer resources-finalizer.argocd.argoproj.io is set on the parent. Use cascade: false on the manual delete (argocd app delete --cascade=false) or non-cascade Application delete.
• HPA and replicas in Git fight forever → omit replicas, add ignoreDifferences for /spec/replicas, RespectIgnoreDifferences=true. All three.
• Replace=true to "fix" diff loops → masks the real problem and rewrites runtime fields. Reach for ServerSideApply=true + RespectIgnoreDifferences=true first.
• PostDelete hook hangs Application in Deleting state (known issue v2.10+): manually remove post-delete-finalizer.argocd.argoproj.io and post-delete-finalizer.argocd.argoproj.io/cleanup from Application metadata.
• ApplicationSet wipes user-added annotations on next reconcile → add to preservedFields.annotations.
• argocd app rollback rejected → app has automated sync. Disable first.
• Cluster Secret missing argocd.argoproj.io/secret-type: cluster label → ArgoCD won't see the cluster, and Cluster generator won't list it either.

Authoritative references

Official ArgoCD docs (argo-cd.readthedocs.io/en/stable):

• Sync Phases and Waves
• Resource Hooks (canonical hook reference)
• Sync Options
• Diffing / ignoreDifferences
• Diff Strategies (ServerSideDiff)
• Resource Health
• Automated Sync Policy
• App Deletion / Finalizers
• AppProject Spec
• Sync Windows
• Declarative Cluster Setup
• ApplicationSet Generators (overview)
• Matrix Generator
• Go Templates in ApplicationSet
• Controlling Resource Modification (preservedFields)
• Notifications
• argocd app rollback

Image Updater (separate component): argocd-image-updater.readthedocs.io

GitHub issue tracker (canonical for known bugs): argoproj/argo-cd — search before assuming behavior, especially around PostDelete hooks and ApplicationSet regeneration.

Guardrails

Before recommending a non-trivial operational change (sync option flip, ignoreDifferences, AppProject restriction, multi-cluster topology):

1. Quote the specific annotation/field path and its default
2. Cite the official ArgoCD doc section
3. State the observed symptom that justifies the change — never blanket-tune

Drift "fixed" by Replace=true is drift hidden, not resolved. Diagnose the root cause (which manager owns which fields) before reaching for the destructive switch.