| name | taste-critic-review |
| description | Use when judging whether a technically valid candidate has hook, tension, authored taste, screenshot value, and series potential. |
| version | 1.0.0 |
| author | Project Agents |
| license | Project-internal |
| metadata | {"hermes":{"tags":["evaluation","asset-review"],"related_skills":["asset-prompt-core","asset-metadata-writer"]}} |
taste-critic-review
Overview
judging whether a technically valid candidate has hook, tension, authored taste, screenshot value, and series potential.
When to Use
- During asset gacha scoring.
- Before promoting generated candidates.
- When repairing prompt drift.
Taste Dimensions
Score each 0–5: instant hook, emotional contrast, screenshot value, series potential, authored feeling, production taste.
Reject candidates that are technically valid but generic, samey, or AI-collage-like.
Output Contract
candidate_id:
score:
subscores: {}
keep_reasons: []
reject_reasons: []
required_mutations: []
promotion_decision: reject | iterate | shortlist | human_review
Common Pitfalls
- Scoring beauty instead of game usefulness.
- Ignoring IP/readability because the image looks cool.
- Failing to write mutation instructions.
Verification Checklist
