shadcn-agents-cva-validator

name	shadcn-agents-cva-validator
description	Use when reviewing, validating, or auditing a shadcn ui component that uses class-variance-authority (cva), when an LLM has just produced a Button-like, Badge-like, Alert-like, or any other cva-driven component and you must verify the variant API before accepting the diff, when a consumer className does not visually win and you suspect cva merge order or a missing cn() call, when extending an existing shadcn component with a new variant or compoundVariant and you want a deterministic checklist before commit, when porting a hand-written variants-via-if-branches component to cva, when writing a custom primitive that should follow the shadcn convention, when verifying that VariantProps inference is exported so consumers can extend the component type, or when running a code-review pass on AI-generated cva code to catch the canonical mistakes (nested cn inside cva, compoundVariants placed before variants, missing defaultVariants, raw className concatenation, asChild without Slot, variant key typos that silently disable a default). Prevents the seven canonical cva failures : (1) variant definition shape wrong (string instead of class string or array), (2) compoundVariants placed in the wrong object position so the parser silently accepts but defaults never resolve, (3) defaultVariants missing or with a typo that no TypeScript check catches because cva values are stringly-typed, (4) VariantProps export missing so consumers cannot extend, (5) caller className concatenated via template string instead of merged via cn() so twMerge is bypassed and duplicate utilities leak, (6) asChild rendered without Radix Slot so polymorphic composition silently breaks, (7) cn() called INSIDE a cva variant string (no-op, cva already runs clsx internally on its inputs). Covers the 7-point validator checklist (base, variants shape, compoundVariants order, defaultVariants, VariantProps export, cn() merge, asChild Slot), per-checkpoint pass and fail criteria with verbatim code patterns, sample-code-to-verdict mappings for at least a dozen common cva shapes, the canonical shadcn Button reference template that all checks reduce to, the cva evaluation order (defaults, then variants, then compoundVariants, then caller className) and how to verify it from the diff alone, and the Companion Skills cross-links to shadcn-syntax-variant-cva (B3, reference) and shadcn-errors-styling-conflicts (B11, debugging). Keywords: cva validator, validate cva component, variant API check, cva correctness check, VariantProps validation, cn helper validation, compoundVariants order check, defaultVariants typo, validate variant code, review cva component, cva self-check, how do I verify a cva component, is my cva component correct, cva checklist, cva audit, class-variance-authority review, shadcn variant audit, variant code review, cva diff review, asChild Slot check, missing defaultVariants, variant prop not applying, override className not winning, template string concat variant, raw className concatenation, nested cn inside cva, cva inside cva, compoundVariants before variants, VariantProps not exported, why is my variant not applying, audit variant component before commit, pre-commit cva check.
license	MIT
compatibility	Designed for Claude Code. Requires shadcn ui evergreen-2026.
metadata	{"author":"OpenAEC-Foundation","version":"1.0"}

shadcn ui Agent : cva Variant API Validator

This skill is the deterministic checklist a code-review or pre-commit agent uses to verify that any cva-driven shadcn component is shaped correctly. It is a VALIDATOR, not a tutorial. For the underlying cva theory, ALWAYS read shadcn-syntax-variant-cva first. For debugging a className override that does not visually win, ALWAYS read shadcn-errors-styling-conflicts.

The validator answers exactly one question per checkpoint : PASS or FAIL. It does not propose creative refactors. When a check fails, the verdict cites the failing line and points to the canonical fix.

Quick Reference

Validator workflow (top of every review)

1. Locate the cva call (search for cva( in the diff or file).
2. Run the 7-point checklist from top to bottom in declared order.
3. Stop at the first FAIL and emit the verdict with line reference.
4. If all 7 pass, emit VERDICT: PASS plus a one-line summary.
5. When called on a multi-file diff, repeat per component file independently.

The 7 checks are ordered by failure frequency observed in real shadcn projects : base, variants shape, compoundVariants order, defaultVariants, VariantProps export, cn() merge, asChild Slot. The first three catch over half of every cva regression seen in shadcn-ui/ui issues.

The 7-point checklist (memorize)

#	Check	One-line pass criterion
1	Base	First positional argument to cva is a string OR a string array
2	Variants shape	Every variant value is a string OR a string array, never a function, never nested cn()
3	compoundVariants order	compoundVariants declared AFTER variants in the config object literal
4	defaultVariants	Every variant axis has an entry in defaultVariants (or explicit null)
5	VariantProps export	The cva return value is exported AND VariantProps<typeof X> is in the props type
6	cn() merge	Component returns className={cn(xVariants({ ..., className }))}, NEVER template-string concat
7	asChild Slot	If asChild?: boolean is in props, body renders <Slot.Root> (or <Slot>) when true, native tag when false

When the answer to any of the seven is "no" the verdict is FAIL ; cite the exact line, name the check, and reference the canonical pattern in references/examples.md.

One-glance verdict format

Every validator pass MUST emit the verdict in this exact shape so downstream pipes can grep it :

VERDICT: PASS (or FAIL)
COMPONENT: <file path>:<line of cva call>
FAILED CHECK: <check number and name>   ← omit on PASS
REASON: <one sentence>                  ← omit on PASS
CANONICAL FIX: references/examples.md § <section name>   ← omit on PASS

The 7 checkpoints in detail

Check 1 : Base classes shape

PASS if the first argument to cva is a string literal, a template literal without interpolation, or an array of those :

cva("inline-flex items-center")                 // PASS : string
cva(["inline-flex", "items-center"])            // PASS : array
cva(`inline-flex items-center`)                 // PASS : template, no interp

FAIL if any of these shapes appear :

cva(cn("inline-flex", "items-center"), { ... })          // FAIL : cn nested inside cva ; cva already runs clsx
cva(twMerge("inline-flex", "items-center"), { ... })     // FAIL : twMerge has nothing to merge
cva("inline-flex" + " " + "items-center", { ... })       // FAIL : plus-concat ; use array
cva(getBaseClasses(), { ... })                           // FAIL : dynamic base defeats static analysis

REASON the nested cn() and twMerge cases fail : cva internally passes its argument through clsx, so a pre-flattened string adds no value and obscures static analysis. The plus-concat case fails because TypeScript loses the literal type and the array form is the documented convention.

Check 2 : Variants object shape

PASS if every leaf value under variants.<axis>.<value> is a string or a string array. Quoted keys, no boolean keys, no nested objects :

variants: {
  variant: {
    default: "bg-primary text-primary-foreground",
    outline: ["border", "bg-background", "hover:bg-accent"],
  },
  size: {
    default: "h-9 px-4 py-2",
    sm: "h-8 rounded-md px-3",
  },
}

FAIL on any of these shapes :

// FAIL : nested cn() ; cva already calls clsx
variant: { default: cn("bg-primary", "text-primary-foreground") }

// FAIL : function instead of class string ; cva does not invoke variant values
variant: { default: () => "bg-primary" }

// FAIL : object nesting ; cva expects a flat string-to-string map
variant: { default: { base: "bg-primary", hover: "hover:bg-primary/90" } }

// FAIL : unquoted boolean key ; cva accepts but VariantProps inference becomes awkward
variant: { true: "bg-primary", false: "bg-secondary" }

REASON : cva runs each value through clsx once, NOT recursively. Functions, nested objects, and pre-merged cn() strings either no-op or break TypeScript inference.

Check 3 : compoundVariants order and shape

PASS if compoundVariants is declared AFTER variants and BEFORE defaultVariants in the config-object source order, and every entry is { ...matchKeys, class: "..." } (or className: "..." ; both are valid per cva docs) :

const buttonVariants = cva("inline-flex", {
  variants: { /* ... */ },
  compoundVariants: [
    { variant: "outline", size: "sm", class: "ring-1 ring-ring/20" },
    { variant: "outline", size: "lg", class: "ring-2 ring-ring/30" },
  ],
  defaultVariants: { variant: "default", size: "default" },
})

FAIL on :

// FAIL : compoundVariants BEFORE variants ; cva still parses but readability and merge-debugging suffer
cva("inline-flex", {
  compoundVariants: [{ variant: "outline", size: "sm", class: "ring-1" }],
  variants: { /* ... */ },
})

// FAIL : entry missing class or className key
compoundVariants: [{ variant: "outline", size: "sm" }]

// FAIL : entry references a variant or value name that does not exist in variants
compoundVariants: [{ variant: "ghostly", size: "sm", class: "ring-1" }]

REASON : cva is permissive on parse order, but compound-before-variants is the canonical reading-order anti-pattern called out in shadcn-errors-styling-conflicts. A reviewer reading top-to-bottom sees a compound match for variants that have not been defined yet and is more likely to miss a typo in the match-keys. Misspelled match-keys silently never match ; cva does NOT throw and TypeScript does NOT catch a stringly-typed mismatch unless the consumer also runs VariantProps validation downstream.

Check 4 : defaultVariants completeness

PASS if defaultVariants exists AND every axis declared in variants has either a string value OR an explicit null in defaultVariants :

defaultVariants: { variant: "default", size: "default" }      // PASS : both axes covered
defaultVariants: { variant: "default", size: null }            // PASS : size opted out explicitly

FAIL if :

// FAIL : missing defaultVariants entirely ; every undefined prop yields no class for that axis
const x = cva("inline-flex", { variants: { variant: { default: "..." } } })

// FAIL : typo in axis name ; cva treats "varient" as an unknown axis and silently ignores it
defaultVariants: { varient: "default", size: "default" }

// FAIL : typo in value name ; cva looks up variants.variant["defualt"] and finds undefined ; no classes
defaultVariants: { variant: "defualt", size: "default" }

REASON : cva is stringly-typed inside the config object. TypeScript does NOT catch axis-name typos in defaultVariants because the config is a structural object literal accepted as Config. The typo silently disables the default and components render unstyled when the consumer omits the prop. The validator MUST cross-check each defaultVariants key against the variants keys, and each value against the value-keys of the matching axis.

Check 5 : VariantProps export

PASS if BOTH of the following hold :

1. The cva return value is exported (export { Button, buttonVariants } OR export const buttonVariants = cva(...)).
2. The component props type intersects VariantProps<typeof buttonVariants> directly OR via a type alias.

import { cva, type VariantProps } from "class-variance-authority"

const buttonVariants = cva(/* ... */)

type ButtonProps =
  React.ComponentProps<"button"> &
  VariantProps<typeof buttonVariants> &
  { asChild?: boolean }

function Button({ variant, size, className, ...props }: ButtonProps) { /* ... */ }

export { Button, buttonVariants }

FAIL if :

// FAIL : variants object not exported ; consumer cannot reuse classes for a link styled as a button
const buttonVariants = cva(/* ... */)
export { Button }

// FAIL : variant union hand-written ; loses type-sync if a variant value is renamed
type ButtonProps = { variant?: "default" | "outline", ... }

// FAIL : VariantProps reference missing entirely ; component accepts the prop but type has no union
type ButtonProps = React.ComponentProps<"button"> & { variant?: string }

REASON : without VariantProps<typeof buttonVariants> the consumer surface is detached from the cva source of truth. Renaming outline to outlined then no longer surfaces as a TypeScript error at the call site, and the runtime simply silently produces no classes.

Check 6 : cn() merge of consumer className

PASS if the component renders className as cn(xVariants({ ..., className })) (the canonical shadcn pattern, passing className as a key of the variants call) OR cn(xVariants({ ... }), className) (the older pattern, passing className as a second argument to cn) :

// PASS : canonical evergreen-2026 pattern
<Comp className={cn(buttonVariants({ variant, size, className }))} {...props} />

// PASS : older but valid pattern (still seen in older shadcn revisions)
<Comp className={cn(buttonVariants({ variant, size }), className)} {...props} />

FAIL on any of these :

// FAIL : template-string concat ; twMerge bypassed, duplicate utilities leak to DOM
<button className={`${buttonVariants({ variant, size })} ${className}`} />

// FAIL : plus-concat ; same problem ; also brittle on undefined className
<button className={buttonVariants({ variant, size }) + " " + (className ?? "")} />

// FAIL : caller className dropped entirely
<button className={buttonVariants({ variant, size })} />

// FAIL : double cn() ; redundant, indicates the author misunderstands the API
<button className={cn(cn(buttonVariants({ variant, size }), className))} />

REASON : cn() is the only path that runs tailwind-merge. Without twMerge a caller className="bg-red-500" and a variant class "bg-primary" both appear in the DOM ; CSS specificity decides arbitrarily by source order. The shadcn convention is that caller className ALWAYS wins.

Check 7 : asChild Slot pattern

If the component accepts asChild?: boolean, PASS only if all three hold :

1. The component imports Slot from radix-ui (evergreen-2026 unified package) OR from @radix-ui/react-slot (pre-Feb-2026 packages still on the legacy split layout).
2. The body picks Slot.Root (unified) or Slot (legacy) when asChild === true, and the native tag string otherwise.
3. The same className expression (the cn(xVariants(...)) call) wraps both branches.

import { Slot } from "radix-ui"     // evergreen-2026

function Button({ className, variant, size, asChild = false, ...props }: ButtonProps) {
  const Comp = asChild ? Slot.Root : "button"
  return (
    <Comp
      data-slot="button"
      className={cn(buttonVariants({ variant, size, className }))}
      {...props}
    />
  )
}

FAIL on any of these :

// FAIL : asChild prop accepted but never branched ; renders <button> regardless
function Button({ asChild = false, ...props }) { return <button {...props} /> }

// FAIL : Slot not imported ; runtime ReferenceError
function Button({ asChild }) { const Comp = asChild ? Slot.Root : "button"; ... }

// FAIL : className applied only to one branch ; asChild path loses variant classes
return asChild ? <Slot.Root {...props} /> : <button className={cn(...)} {...props} />

REASON : the asChild pattern only works because Radix Slot forwards the parent's className, ref, and onClick into the child. Skipping Slot makes asChild non-functional ; applying className to only one branch silently produces unstyled output exactly half the time.

Sample-code-to-verdict mapping (illustrative)

The full table lives in references/methods.md § Sample-code-to-verdict. A few high-yield examples summarised here :

Symptom	Likely failed check	Verdict pointer
cn() appears INSIDE a variants.variant.default string	Check 2	examples.md WRONG-A
compoundVariants declared as the first key in the cva config	Check 3	examples.md WRONG-B
defaultVariants: { varient: "default" } (typo)	Check 4	examples.md WRONG-C
Consumer className passed but cn not called	Check 6	examples.md WRONG-D
asChild prop in interface but body always renders <button>	Check 7	examples.md WRONG-E
export { Button } without buttonVariants	Check 5	examples.md WRONG-F

Cross-check with downstream skills

This validator alone CANNOT detect runtime issues caused by Tailwind v3-vs-v4 class semantics ; that diagnosis lives in shadcn-errors-styling-conflicts (B11). When Check 6 PASSES but the caller still reports "override does not visually win", redirect the user to that skill for the merge-order debug. The B11 skill enumerates the arbitrary-vs-preset, important-modifier, and v3-vs-v4-rename traps that survive a correct cn() call.

Companion Skills

• shadcn-syntax-variant-cva (B3, reference for the underlying API : signature, base, variants, compoundVariants, defaultVariants, VariantProps, evaluation order, asChild Slot, the cn() helper composition). ALWAYS read it BEFORE writing or auditing a cva component for the first time.
• shadcn-errors-styling-conflicts (B11, debugging for the case where the validator passes all 7 checks but the consumer still sees a visual override failure). Read it AFTER a PASS verdict if the bug persists.
• shadcn-agents-component-selector (sibling agent : picks the correct shadcn primitive in the first place ; out of scope for this validator).
• shadcn-impl-extending-components (impl-layer recipe for adding a new variant or compoundVariant to an existing shadcn component without breaking VariantProps inference).

Reference files

• references/methods.md : the 7 checks as a numbered enforcement spec plus the sample-code-to-verdict table.
• references/examples.md : one WRONG cva component with multiple violations and the verdict, one RIGHT cva component verified, and edge cases (variant value as class-array, compoundVariants with multiple match keys, custom variant extension via spread).
• references/anti-patterns.md : at least six observed cva anti-patterns from real shadcn projects with the verdict and the canonical fix.