spec-driven-ideation

name	spec-driven-ideation
description	Transform business ideas into structured requirements through guided discovery with structural anti-skip enforcement (Execute-Verify-Gate pattern). Applies per-phase reference loading, checkpoint persistence, and artifact verification to every step of the 7-phase ideation process. Prevents token optimization bias through lean orchestration. Use when users say "I have a business idea", "help me define requirements", "let's explore what to build", or runs /ideate. Do NOT use when user wants to brainstorm a vague problem (use spec-driven-brainstorming) or wants a business plan directly (use planning-business).
allowed-tools	["Read","Write","Edit","Glob","Grep","AskUserQuestion","Task","Skill"]
model	opus
effort	High
version	1.0.0
topics	requirements, ideation, discovery, spec-driven, anti-skip, elicitation

Spec-Driven Ideation

Transform business ideas into structured, actionable requirements through guided interactive questioning with structural anti-skip enforcement.

Output: devforgeai/specs/requirements/{project-name}-requirements.md (YAML per F4 schema) Feeds Into: /create-solution-architecture command for epic generation, /create-system-architecture for architecture

---

Anti-Skip Enforcement Contract

Enforced structurally outside LLM control, not by this prose — by the framework's deterministic gates wired for this workflow: the devforgeai-validate phase gates, the settings.json-registered .claude/hooks/ scripts, and .claude/hooks/phase-steps-registry.json (ADR-076).

Layer 4 (CLI phase-gate) is wired as of gh#283: ideation is registered in phase_state.py WORKFLOW_SCHEMAS, and Phase 00 + every phase file call phase-init / phase-check / phase-record / phase-complete. The active boundary enforcer is pre-phase-complete-boundary-check.sh (PreToolUse exit 2 when a BLOCK-policy phase file [phases 01–06] was never Read() during the story — ADR-132; phase-07 is EXEMPT as the terminal handoff phase; phase-entry-validator.sh is now PostToolUse telemetry). There are no [MANDATORY] reference manifests — ideation's reference reads stay advisory/graceful (phase-01 degrades without halting) and the generated requirements are validated downstream by validate-pm-plan. Step- and subagent-count enforcement stays deferred (empty steps_required / subagents_required, per ADR-110 / ADR-073).

---

Parameter Extraction

Extract from conversation context:

Parameter	Source	Default
$BUSINESS_IDEA	Text from /ideate command or <business-idea> XML	null (will ask in Phase 02)
$BRAINSTORM_FILE	<brainstorm-file> XML element from /ideate	null (no brainstorm input)
$PROJECT_MODE	<project-mode> XML element from /ideate	"auto-detect"
$RESUME_ID	--resume IDEATION-NNN argument	null (new session)
$MODE	Derived from above	"new" or "resume"

---

Phase 00: Initialization [INLINE - Bootstraps State]

This phase runs inline because it creates the state that all other phases depend on.

Step 0.1: Parse Arguments

IF conversation contains "--resume IDEATION-":
  Extract IDEATION_ID from argument
  MODE = "resume"
ELSE IF conversation contains "<ideation-context>":
  Extract BUSINESS_IDEA from <business-idea> element
  Extract BRAINSTORM_FILE from <brainstorm-file> element
  Extract PROJECT_MODE from <project-mode> element
  MODE = "new"
ELSE IF conversation contains business idea text after /ideate:
  BUSINESS_IDEA = extracted text
  MODE = "new"
ELSE:
  MODE = "new"
  BUSINESS_IDEA = null

Step 0.2: Handle Resume Mode

IF MODE == "resume":
  checkpoint_results = Glob(pattern="devforgeai/specs/ideation/${IDEATION_ID}.checkpoint.json")

  IF found:
    Read(file_path="devforgeai/specs/ideation/${IDEATION_ID}.checkpoint.json")
    Restore session state from checkpoint
    CURRENT_PHASE = checkpoint.progress.current_phase
    Display: "Resuming ${IDEATION_ID} from Phase ${CURRENT_PHASE}"
    GOTO Phase Orchestration Loop at CURRENT_PHASE
  ELSE:
    Display: "No checkpoint found for ${IDEATION_ID}."
    AskUserQuestion:
      Question: "No checkpoint found. What would you like to do?"
      Header: "Resume"
      Options:
        - label: "Start a new ideation session"
          description: "Begin fresh session"
        - label: "Check for completed requirements"
          description: "Look for existing requirements files"
    IF "Start new": MODE = "new", continue below
    IF "Check completed": Glob for existing requirements files, display results

Step 0.3: Brainstorm Context Detection

The brainstorm file may be either format. Branch on file extension BEFORE any field extraction so the wrong parser is never run against the wrong format:

• .brainstorm.html -> v2.0 (ADR-065): extract the embedded JSON data island.
• .brainstorm.md -> v1.0 (legacy): parse YAML frontmatter.

The extension-branching extractor lives in references/brainstorm-handoff-workflow.md §2.1 (extract_brainstorm_data). Step 0.3 calls it -- it never field-extracts inline.

IF BRAINSTORM_FILE is not null and BRAINSTORM_FILE != "none":
  # Validate brainstorm file exists
  brainstorm_exists = Glob(pattern=BRAINSTORM_FILE)
  IF found:
    # Load the handoff workflow reference, then extract via its extension-branching
    # extractor. Do NOT field-extract inline -- the extractor handles both .html and .md.
    Read(file_path=".claude/skills/spec-driven-ideation/references/brainstorm-handoff-workflow.md")
    brainstorm_context = extract_brainstorm_data(BRAINSTORM_FILE)   # branches on .html / .md
    brainstorm_context = validate_brainstorm_context(brainstorm_context)

    Display: "Brainstorm loaded ({brainstorm_context.source_format})."

    # Pre-populate session from the extracted context
    session.brainstorm_input = {
      brainstorm_id: brainstorm_context.brainstorm_id,
      confidence_level: brainstorm_context.confidence_level,
      source_format: brainstorm_context.source_format,
      pre_populated_fields: [problem_statement, personas, constraints, must_haves]
    }
    session = apply_brainstorm_to_ideation(brainstorm_context)   # handoff-workflow.md §3.1
  ELSE:
    Display: "Brainstorm file not found. Starting fresh."
    BRAINSTORM_FILE = null

Step 0.4: Generate Session ID (New Session)

IF MODE == "new":
  # Scan for highest existing ID
  Glob(pattern="devforgeai/specs/ideation/IDEATION-*.checkpoint.json")
  Glob(pattern="devforgeai/specs/requirements/*-requirements.md")

  # Extract highest NNN, increment
  IDEATION_ID = "IDEATION-{NNN+1}" (zero-padded to 3 digits minimum)

  # Ensure output directories exist
  Glob(pattern="devforgeai/specs/ideation/.gitkeep")
  IF not found: Write(file_path="devforgeai/specs/ideation/.gitkeep", content="")

Step 0.5: Create Initial Checkpoint

checkpoint = {
  "checkpoint_version": "2.0",
  "session_id": IDEATION_ID,
  "created_at": "current ISO 8601 timestamp",
  "updated_at": "current ISO 8601 timestamp",
  "status": "in_progress",
  "business_idea": BUSINESS_IDEA,
  "project_mode": PROJECT_MODE or "auto-detect",
  "brainstorm_input": {
    "brainstorm_id": session.brainstorm_input.brainstorm_id or null,
    "confidence_level": session.brainstorm_input.confidence_level or null,
    "pre_populated_fields": session.brainstorm_input.pre_populated_fields or []
  },
  "progress": {
    "current_phase": 0,
    "phases_completed": [],
    "completion_percentage": 0,
    "total_questions_asked": 0
  },
  "phases": {},
  "completed_outputs": {
    "project_type": null,
    "problem_statement": BUSINESS_IDEA or null,
    "user_types": [],
    "personas": [],
    "business_goals": [],
    "scope_boundaries": {},
    "complexity_assessment": null,
    "functional_requirements": [],
    "nfr_requirements": [],
    "data_entities": [],
    "integrations": [],
    "adr_prerequisites": [],
    "requirements_file_path": null,
    "validation_status": null,
    "next_action": null
  }
}

Write(file_path="devforgeai/specs/ideation/${IDEATION_ID}.checkpoint.json", content=checkpoint)

VERIFY: Glob(pattern="devforgeai/specs/ideation/${IDEATION_ID}.checkpoint.json") IF not found: HALT -- "Initial checkpoint was NOT created."

Step 0.5b: Initialize Phase-State CLI

Initialize the phase-state machine that backs the boundary gate (ADR-132). This is the activation switch: it creates devforgeai/workflows/${IDEATION_ID}-ideation-phase-state.json, which the reference-reads producer resolves so the boundary gate can verify each phase file was loaded.

devforgeai-validate phase-init ${IDEATION_ID} --workflow=ideation --project-root=. 2>&1

Exit Code	Action
0	New workflow initialized — proceed
1	Existing workflow — resume (the checkpoint.json drives resume; continue)
127	CLI not installed — proceed without enforcement (graceful degradation)
Other	HALT — phase-state initialization error

The CLI state file (${IDEATION_ID}-ideation-phase-state.json) backs the boundary gate; the skill's own ${IDEATION_ID}.checkpoint.json backs --resume. They coexist — do NOT unify them. On a resumed session the existing-workflow exit (1) is expected and non-fatal.

Step 0.6: Display Session Banner

Display:
"━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
  DevForgeAI Ideation Session
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━

Session: ${IDEATION_ID}
Mode: ${MODE == 'resume' ? 'Resumed' : 'New Ideation'}
Business Idea: ${BUSINESS_IDEA || 'To be discovered in Phase 2'}
Brainstorm Input: ${BRAINSTORM_FILE || 'None'}
Project Mode: ${PROJECT_MODE || 'Auto-detect'}

Phases: 7 (Pre-Flight > Discovery > Elicitation > Compliance > Artifacts > Validation > Handoff)
Estimated Duration: 30-90 minutes
━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━"

Set CURRENT_PHASE = 1.

---

Phase Orchestration Loop

FOR phase_num in range(CURRENT_PHASE, 8):  # Phases 01-07

    1. LOAD: Read(file_path=".claude/skills/spec-driven-ideation/phases/{phase_files[phase_num]}")
       Load the phase file FRESH. Do NOT rely on memory of previous reads.

    2. REFERENCE: Read the phase's reference files as specified in the phase Contract section.
       Each phase references files in .claude/skills/spec-driven-ideation/references/.
       Load ALL listed references. Do not skip any.

    3. EXECUTE: Follow EVERY step in the phase file using EXECUTE-VERIFY-RECORD triplets.
       - Each step's EXECUTE tells you exactly what AskUserQuestion to call or action to take
       - Each step's VERIFY tells you how to confirm the data was captured
       - Each step's RECORD tells you how to update the checkpoint

    4. EXIT CRITERIA: Verify ALL phase exit criteria are met before proceeding.
       IF any required data key is null or empty: HALT.
       IF questions_answered < minimum_questions: HALT.

    5. CHECKPOINT: Update checkpoint JSON with phase completion.
       Write updated checkpoint to disk.
       Verify write via Glob().

    6. CONTEXT CHECK: If estimated context > 70%, offer save-and-resume via AskUserQuestion.
       IF user chooses "Save and resume later":
         Write final checkpoint, display resume command, EXIT skill.
         Display: "Run /ideate --resume ${IDEATION_ID} to continue."

---

Phase Table

Phase	Name	File	Min Qs	Required Data
00	Initialization	(inline above)	0-1	session_id, checkpoint on disk
01	Pre-Flight & Context Detection	phases/phase-01-preflight.md	0-3	project_type, user_input_patterns_loaded
02	Discovery & Problem Understanding	phases/phase-02-discovery.md	5	problem_statement, user_types[>=1], business_goals[>=1], scope_boundaries
03	Requirements Elicitation	phases/phase-03-elicitation.md	10	functional_requirements[>=5], nfr_requirements[>=1], data_entities[>=1]
04	Constitutional Compliance	phases/phase-04-compliance.md	0	compliance_checked=true, adr_prerequisites (list)
05	Artifact Generation	phases/phase-05-artifacts.md	0-2	requirements_file_path (non-null, file on disk, F4 fields present)
06	Self-Validation	phases/phase-06-validation.md	0-1	validation_status in [PASSED, PASSED_WITH_WARNINGS]
07	Completion & Handoff	phases/phase-07-handoff.md	1-3	completion_summary_displayed=true, next_action_determined=true

---

Required Subagents

Phase	Subagent	Enforcement
01	internet-sleuth	CONDITIONAL (if user opts for market research enrichment)
04	context-validator	CONDITIONAL (if context files exist for brownfield check)

---

State Persistence

• Checkpoint: devforgeai/specs/ideation/${IDEATION_ID}.checkpoint.json
• Output: devforgeai/specs/requirements/{project-name}-requirements.md
• References: .claude/skills/spec-driven-ideation/references/ (shared read, not duplicated)
• Templates: .claude/skills/spec-driven-ideation/assets/templates/ (shared read)
• Scripts: .claude/skills/spec-driven-ideation/scripts/ (shared read)

---

Workflow Completion Validation

IF phases_completed < 7: HALT "WORKFLOW INCOMPLETE - {completed_count}/7 phases"
IF requirements_file not on disk (Glob returns empty): HALT "Requirements document not generated"
IF validation_status not in [PASSED, PASSED_WITH_WARNINGS]: HALT "Validation did not pass"
IF checkpoint still exists: Mark checkpoint status = "complete"

---

Error Handling

Load error recovery patterns from: .claude/skills/spec-driven-ideation/references/error-handling-index.md

Error Type Files (load on-demand):

1. error-type-1-incomplete-answers.md - Vague/incomplete user responses
2. error-type-2-artifact-failures.md - File write/permission errors
3. error-type-3-complexity-errors.md - Complexity assessment errors
4. error-type-4-validation-failures.md - Quality validation issues
5. error-type-5-constraint-conflicts.md - Brownfield constraint conflicts
6. error-type-6-directory-issues.md - Directory structure issues

Graceful Degradation Priority:

1. User answers (highest - never lose)
2. Problem statement
3. Functional requirements
4. Non-functional requirements
5. Data entities
6. Integrations (lowest - can be discovered later)

---

Success Criteria

• All 7 phases executed (no skipping)
• requirements.md exists on disk with all F4 schema sections
• Validation passed (PASSED or PASSED_WITH_WARNINGS)
• User validated requirements accuracy
• Checkpoint marked as complete
• Next steps displayed to user