| name | feasibility-salvage-gate |
| description | 用于 P4 判断实验计划可实施性、预计论文级别、low-confidence 风险、失败后贡献重定位和最低补救方案。不用于拒稿信预演。 |
Feasibility Salvage Gate
Role
本 skill 是 P4 的策略门。它判断当前计划能不能做、能支撑什么论文级别、哪里低置信,以及失败后怎样换论文策略。
Method-call
/feasibility-salvage-gate(
snapshot,
experiment_matrix,
baseline_ablation_plan,
figure_table_plan,
target_level?,
output_root = knowledge/experiment-plan/
) -> feasibility_salvage_plan
Step 1: Feasibility Scan
按维度打标:
| Dimension | Question |
|---|
| data | 数据、案例、工况、截图是否可获取? |
| code/environment | 代码、工具、仿真、平台是否能跑? |
| baseline | 最低 baseline 和强 baseline 是否可实现? |
| metric | 指标是否可自动或半自动判定? |
| figure/table | 图表数据能否产出? |
| time/resource | 当前资源是否够做 must-have 实验? |
| paper_level | 证据链是否匹配目标级别? |
Step 2: Confidence and Level
输出:
current_support_level: <band>
target_level: <band or unknown>
confidence: high|medium|low
blocking_gaps: [...]
upgrade_path: [...]
minimum_salvage_path: [...]
low-confidence 不是失败;它必须附带最低补救方案。
Step 3: Salvage Strategy
优先从论文策略上补救:
- narrow scene: 从全局有效改为某场景/区域/约束下有效。
- switch metric: 精度不赢时转效率、鲁棒性、成本、稳定性、可解释性、可部署性。
- lower claim: 从方法创新改为应用验证、系统工程、对比改进、案例资源。
- acquire resource: 补数据、补 baseline、补日志、补截图、补仿真工况。
- downgrade paper level: 目标从 sci-mid 降到 sci-low / cn-general / master-thesis 等。
- ask user: 需要付费资源、不可逆改动、真实投稿目标裁决时让用户决定。
Step 4: Machine Artifact Schema
Write artifact expectations to:
knowledge/experiment-plan/machine/experiment-artifacts.schema.json
This schema should tell harness agents how to recognize results, plots, screenshots, metric files, and verifier outputs.
Step 5: Output Files
Write or update:
knowledge/experiment-plan/feasibility-salvage-plan.md
knowledge/experiment-plan/machine/experiment-artifacts.schema.json
Negative Boundary
Do not make rejection-letter simulation the core framing. The gate can mention likely reviewer concerns only when they directly map to evidence gaps, but the main frame is contribution repositioning and feasibility.
本 skill 的 deletion-spec
- 触发删除条件:当 paper-positioning plus req execution can jointly perform support-level, feasibility, and salvage judgment without a separate P4 gate, this skill can be removed.
- 禁用方式:删除
plugins/experiment-planning-suite/skills/feasibility-salvage-gate/,bump plugin 版本,刷新 marketplace/cache。
- 卸载清单:同步检查 orchestrator、README、req-experiment-handoff 和 any future P8 review/revision suite references。