drift-adr-workflow

name	drift-adr-workflow
description	Drift-specific ADR workflow for signal, scoring, output, and architecture decisions. Use when creating, updating, or validating ADRs before implementation. Keywords: ADR, decision record, proposed, signal design, scoring change, architecture boundary, output format, Decision trailer.
argument-hint	Describe the planned change and whether you need a new ADR, an ADR update, or validation of an existing draft.

Drift ADR Workflow Skill

Use this skill when a Drift change needs a documented architectural or product decision before implementation.

When To Use

• A signal is added or materially changed
• Scoring logic or weights are changed
• Output formats or output contracts are changed
• An architecture boundary, trust boundary, input path, or output path changes
• An existing ADR draft must be completed or validated

Core Rules

1. Run the Drift Policy Gate first. If the task is not admissible, stop.
2. ADR first, implementation second. For signal, scoring, output-format, or architecture-boundary changes, prepare the ADR before coding.
3. Agents may draft, not accept. Agents may create or update ADRs with status proposed; only the maintainer changes status to accepted or rejected.
4. Validation must be testable. Every ADR needs a concrete validation section with measurable checks or outcomes.
5. Do not blur bugfixes and architectural decisions. Pure bugfixes and pure refactorings do not automatically require a new ADR.

Step 0: Run The Drift Policy Gate

Before drafting an ADR, use the mandatory gate format from .github/instructions/drift-policy.instructions.md.

If the task fails the gate, do not create an ADR to legitimize inadmissible work.

Step 1: Decide Whether An ADR Is Required

Create or update an ADR when the change affects one of these categories:

• signal design or signal behavior
• scoring or prioritization logic
• output schema or result format
• architecture or trust boundaries

Do not force a new ADR for:

• typo fixes
• isolated test-only work
• pure refactors without behavior change
• contained bugfixes that preserve the existing design decision without materially changing signal behavior, scoring logic, output contracts, or trust assumptions

If unsure, prefer a draft ADR that states the uncertainty explicitly.

Interface-Design-Tipp: Vor dem Festschreiben eines Signal- oder API-Interface-Designs lohnt es sich, 2–3 Sub-Agenten mit explizit verschiedenen Constraints parallel zu spawnen (z. B. „minimiere das Interface", „maximiere Flexibilität", „optimiere für den häufigsten Caller"). Radikale Constraint-Divergenz erzwingt qualitativ unterschiedliche Designs — parallele Agenten ohne Vorgaben konvergieren meist zu ähnlichen Lösungen. Das subagent-driven-development-Skill liefert den operativen Rahmen.

Step 2: Choose The Right Template

Use the general template in docs/decisions/templates/adr-template.md for broad architecture or workflow decisions.

When the decision is primarily about a signal, you must use docs/decisions/templates/signal-design-template.md and complete its signal-specific fields. That template already forces the critical fields:

• problem class
• heuristic
• scope
• expected FP classes
• expected FN classes
• fixture plan
• FMEA pre-entry
• validation criterion

Step 3: Create Or Update The ADR File

Create the next ADR under docs/decisions/ using the repository numbering sequence:

docs/decisions/ADR-NNN-short-slug.md

Required YAML frontmatter fields at the top of the file:

• id
• status: proposed
• date
• supersedes

Signal-design ADRs must also carry:

• type: signal-design
• signal_id

Do not invent custom status values.

Step 4: Write The Decision Clearly

The ADR body must answer all of these questions:

• What problem or uncertainty is being addressed?
• What is being done?
• What is explicitly not being done?
• Why was this option chosen over alternatives?
• What trade-offs or consequences are accepted?
• How will the decision be validated?

For signal-related ADRs, be explicit about:

• why the problem maps to Drift's product purpose
• whether the signal is file_local, cross_file, or git_dependent
• expected false-positive and false-negative classes
• what minimal fixtures must exist before implementation is considered credible

Step 5: Connect The ADR To Evidence

An ADR is not complete if it floats without validation hooks.

Reference the concrete artifacts the later implementation must touch, for example:

• tests under tests/
• fixture definitions under tests/fixtures/ground_truth.py
• audit artifacts under audit_results/
• evidence artifacts under benchmark_results/

If the decision changes a signal or architecture boundary, state which audit artifacts must be updated alongside the implementation.

Step 6: Define Validation And Outcome Semantics

The Validation section must contain concrete checks, for example:

pytest tests/test_precision_recall.py -v
python scripts/check_risk_audit.py --diff-base origin/main
drift analyze --repo . --format json --exit-zero

Also state the expected learning-cycle result using the policy vocabulary used in Drift decision review:

• bestaetigt
• widerlegt
• unklar
• zurueckgestellt

Step 7: Prepare Commit Linkage

When implementation follows the ADR, the commit body should carry the decision trailer:

Decision: ADR-NNN

Do not change ADR status to accepted as part of the agent workflow.

Review Checklist

• Policy Gate passed for the underlying task
• ADR requirement was correctly identified
• The right template was used
• Status is proposed
• Decision and non-goals are explicit
• Validation is concrete and testable
• Signal-related ADRs name FP/FN classes, scope, and fixture plan
• References to tests, audit artifacts, or evidence files are concrete
• Maintainer-only status boundaries are respected

References

• .github/instructions/drift-policy.instructions.md
• .github/instructions/drift-quality-workflow.instructions.md
• .github/skills/drift-commit-push/SKILL.md
• docs/decisions/templates/adr-template.md
• docs/decisions/templates/signal-design-template.md
• DEVELOPER.md
• CONTRIBUTING.md