evidence-mapping

name	evidence-mapping
description	Systematic evidence map construction — search, classify, locate gaps, visualize. Combines concept-matrix-construction, gap-keyword-extraction, evidence-grading, and egm-construction SOPs.
execution	tactic
dependencies	{"sops":["concept-matrix-construction","deep-insight-paper-overview","deep-insight-paper-search","egm-construction","evidence-grading","gap-keyword-extraction"]}

Evidence Mapping

Systematically build evidence maps to reveal structural gaps.

Operations

• concept-matrix-construction — articles × concepts coverage visualization
• gap-keyword-extraction — gap-indicating sentence identification
• evidence-grading — quality assessment of available evidence
• egm-construction — structured evidence gap map output

Available SOPs

Subagent: concept-matrix-construction, gap-keyword-extraction, evidence-grading, egm-construction Import: paper-overview, paper-search

Execution Guidance

Build concept matrix first (articles × concepts), identify empty cells as gap candidates, verify with keyword extraction from full texts, grade evidence quality in populated cells, construct final EGM for structural view.

Minimum Yield

<HARD-GATE>
- concept-matrix: >= 1 constructed
- gap-keyword passes: >= 3
- evidence grading: >= 5 items graded
- EGM: >= 1 constructed
</HARD-GATE>

Available SOPs

Optional, no fixed order; the final leaf is always a sop.

SOP	When to use
concept-matrix-construction	Build articles × concepts coverage matrix to visualize research landscape and identify empty cells as gap candidates.
deep-insight-paper-overview	Paper metadata and abstract-level overview. Import of literature-engine/literature-overview skill. Abstracts only — no substantive claims without deeper reading.
deep-insight-paper-search	AI-powered paper summary and search. Import of literature-engine/literature-search skill. AI summary level — cite as "AI-extracted" not "paper states".
egm-construction	Build structured Evidence Gap Maps — define axes (intervention × outcome or method × domain), place gaps in cells, annotate with evidence density and quality.
evidence-grading	Assess evidence quality using GRADE/SOE framework. Rates certainty level and identifies downgrade reasons.
gap-keyword-extraction	Extract gap-indicating sentences and phrases from papers/reviews. Identifies linguistic markers of research gaps (e.g., "remains unclear", "has not been explored", "limited understanding").