create-template

name	create-template
description	Create a template for checks and remediations
argument-hint	template-name

Create Template

Create a new template in shared/templates/. Templates generate checks (OVAL) and remediations (Bash, Ansible, etc.) from parameters, reducing code duplication across similar rules.

Template name: $ARGUMENTS

Tool Strategy

Prefer mcp__content-agent__* tools when available. When the MCP server is not configured, use the filesystem-based alternatives noted as Fallback in each step. See .claude/skills/shared/mcp_fallbacks.md for detailed fallback procedures.

Term Definitions

• Template: Parameterized checks, remediations, and metadata in shared/templates/<name>/.
• Templated content: Checks (OVAL) and remediations (Bash, Ansible, etc.) generated at build time by substituting parameters into templates. Not stored in git.
• Static content: Checks and remediations stored directly in rule subdirectories (e.g., oval/shared.xml, bash/shared.sh). The build system prefers static content over templated content when both exist.
• Templated rule: A rule with a template: key in rule.yml that generates content from a template instead of using static content.

Phase 1: Design the Template

1.1 Read Existing Templates

Read the Template Reference to understand existing templates, their parameters, and structure.

Use mcp__content-agent__list_templates to get the full list of available templates. Fallback: Run ls shared/templates/ to list template directories.

1.2 Validate the Template Name

Verify the template name $ARGUMENTS:

• Must be lowercase_with_underscores (no hyphens, no uppercase)
• Must be short and descriptive
• Must NOT conflict with an existing template name

Use mcp__content-agent__get_template_schema with template_name=$ARGUMENTS to check if the name already exists. Fallback: Check if shared/templates/$ARGUMENTS/ already exists.

If the name already exists, inform the user and stop.

1.3 Design the Template Interface

Discuss and agree on the following with the user:

1. Description: What the template checks and/or remediates, as a short sentence.
2. Parameters: For each parameter, define:
   • Name (lowercase_with_underscores)
   • Required or optional (with default value if optional)
   • Data type and valid values
   • Whether it should be backed by an XCCDF Variable — use XCCDF Variables when the value should be changeable by the user or differ between profiles (e.g., password length, banner texts, hostnames)
3. Supported languages: Which output languages the template should generate. Common combinations:
   • Ansible, Bash, OVAL — most common for Linux rules
   • OVAL only — check-only, no remediation
   • Ansible, Bash, Kubernetes, OVAL — for Kubernetes/OpenShift rules

Design Principles

• Keep parameters between 1 and 5. More than 5 suggests the rules should use static content instead.
• Only create a template when multiple similar rules would benefit from it. A template for a single rule is not justified.
• Identify at least 2-3 existing rules that could use the template by searching for similar rules: Use mcp__content-agent__search_rules with a query matching the template's purpose. Fallback: grep -rl in linux_os/guide/ or applications/openshift/ for similar patterns.

1.4 Document the Template

Add the new template to Template Reference, matching the existing format exactly:

#### $ARGUMENTS
-   Description of what the template checks/remediates.

-   Parameters:

    -   **param_name** - description of the parameter

    -   **optional_param** - (optional) description. Default: `"default_value"`.

-   Languages: Ansible, Bash, OVAL

Insert the entry in alphabetical order among the existing templates, before the "Creating Templates" section.

Phase 2: Create Template Skeleton

All template files go in shared/templates/$ARGUMENTS/.

2.1 Create template.yml

List all languages the template supports. The build system only generates content for languages listed here.

Valid language identifiers: anaconda, ansible, bash, blueprint, bootc, ignition, kickstart, kubernetes, oval, puppet, sce-bash.

supported_languages:
  - ansible
  - bash
  - oval

2.2 Create template.py

This Python file preprocesses template parameters before they reach the Jinja2 engine. Every template must have a template.py with a preprocess(data, lang) function, even if it only returns data unchanged.

The function:

• Receives data: a dictionary of template parameters from the rule's template.vars, plus the implicit _rule_id key
• Receives lang: the language being generated (e.g., "oval", "bash", "ansible")
• Must return the data dictionary (a missing return silently breaks preprocessing)

Use the preprocessor to:

1. Set default values for optional parameters
2. Validate required parameters and their formats
3. Transform parameters (escape special characters, convert types, compute derived values)
4. Create test parameters — values used by templated test scenarios (e.g., test_correct_value, test_wrong_value)
5. Perform language-specific transformations by branching on lang

You can import helper functions from ssg.utils (e.g., ssg.utils.escape_id()).

Minimal template.py

def preprocess(data, lang):
    return data

Typical template.py with Defaults, Validation and Test Data

def preprocess(data, lang):
    # Validate required parameters
    if "key" not in data:
        raise ValueError(
            "Rule {0} is missing required 'key' parameter".format(
                data["_rule_id"]))

    # Set defaults for optional parameters
    if "separator" not in data:
        data["separator"] = "="

    # Language-specific transformations
    if lang == "oval":
        data["escaped_key"] = data["key"].replace(".", "_")

    # Create test scenario parameters
    data["test_correct_value"] = str(data.get("value", "correct_value"))
    data["test_wrong_value"] = "wrong_value"

    return data

Common patterns in existing preprocessors:

• package_installed: validates evr format with regex
• key_value_pair_in_file: sets defaults for sep, sep_regex, prefix_regex, app, creates test_correct_value/test_wrong_value
• sysctl: uses ssg.utils.escape_id() for ID sanitization, detects IPv6 from variable name, generates test values based on datatype
• service_disabled: sets packagename and daemonname defaults from servicename

Implicit Variables Available in Templates

The build system injects these variables into every template (available in both template.py and .template files):

Variable	Description
_rule_id	The rule ID of the rule using the template
rule_id	Same as _rule_id, available in Jinja context
rule_title	The rule's title from rule.yml
product	Current product being built (e.g., rhel9)
pkg_system	Package system for the product (e.g., rpm, dpkg)

Casing note: _rule_id is a template parameter, so it becomes _RULE_ID in .template files (like all parameters). The others (rule_id, rule_title, product, pkg_system) are environment/context variables that stay lowercase. In practice, both {{{ _RULE_ID }}} and {{{ rule_id }}} resolve to the same rule ID — use whichever is conventional for the context (existing templates typically use _RULE_ID in OVAL id= attributes and rule_id in macro arguments).

Phase 3: Create Template Files for Checks and Remediations

For each language in template.yml, create a <lang>.template file. The file name must match the language identifier exactly.

Jinja2 Conventions

This project uses custom Jinja2 delimiters (defined in ssg/jinja.py). Standard Jinja2 syntax will NOT work:

• Expressions: {{{ expr }}} (triple braces), NOT {{ expr }}
• Statements: {{% stmt %}}, NOT {% stmt %}
• Comments: {{# comment #}}, NOT {# comment #}

Critical — variable casing in .template files:

• Template parameters from rule.yml vars (and those set in template.py) must be in UPPERCASE. The build system converts all parameter keys to uppercase automatically. Example: package_name in rule.yml becomes PACKAGE_NAME in the template.
• Environment/context variables (rule_id, rule_title, product, pkg_system) stay lowercase.
• Special case: _rule_id is a parameter (becomes _RULE_ID), while rule_id is a context variable (stays lowercase). Both resolve to the same value.

Remediation Template Headers

Bash and Ansible templates must start with these metadata comments:

# platform = multi_platform_all
# reboot = false
# strategy = configure
# complexity = low
# disruption = low

Adjust platform to match the template's applicability. Use specific platforms (e.g., multi_platform_rhel,multi_platform_fedora) if the template only applies to certain products.

Bash Template (bash.template)

Use macros from shared/macros/bash.jinja for common operations:

# platform = multi_platform_all
# reboot = false
# strategy = configure
# complexity = low
# disruption = low

{{{ bash_replace_or_append(CONFIG_FILE, KEY, VALUE) }}}

Common Bash macros:

• {{{ bash_package_install(package=PKGNAME) }}}
• {{{ bash_package_remove(package=PKGNAME) }}}
• {{{ bash_replace_or_append(config_file, key, value) }}}
• {{{ bash_instantiate_variables(XCCDF_VARIABLE) }}}
• {{{ set_config_file(path, key, value, ...) }}}

Ansible Template (ansible.template)

Use macros from shared/macros/ansible.jinja:

# platform = multi_platform_all
# reboot = false
# strategy = configure
# complexity = low
# disruption = low

- name: Ensure {{{ KEY }}} is set to {{{ VALUE }}}
  ansible.builtin.lineinfile:
    path: "{{{ CONFIG_FILE }}}"
    regexp: '^{{{ KEY }}}'
    line: "{{{ KEY }}}={{{ VALUE }}}"
    state: present
    create: true

Common Ansible macros:

• {{{ ansible_instantiate_variables(XCCDF_VARIABLE) }}}
• {{{ ansible_set_config_file(msg, path, key, value, ...) }}}

OVAL Template (oval.template)

OVAL templates use shorthand format. Use macros from shared/macros/oval.jinja:

<def-group>
  <definition class="compliance" id="{{{ _RULE_ID }}}" version="1">
    {{{ oval_metadata("Description of what is checked.", affected_platforms=["multi_platform_all"], rule_title=rule_title) }}}
    <criteria>
      <criterion comment="check description"
      test_ref="test_{{{ _RULE_ID }}}" />
    </criteria>
  </definition>
  <!-- Add OVAL tests, objects, and states here -->
</def-group>

Common OVAL macros:

• {{{ oval_metadata(description, affected_platforms, rule_title) }}}
• {{{ oval_test_package_installed(package, evr, test_id) }}}
• {{{ oval_check_config_file(path, parameter, value, ...) }}}

Product-Specific Branching in Templates

Use Jinja conditionals for product-specific behavior:

{{% if product in ["sle12", "sle15"] %}}
# SUSE-specific implementation
{{% elif product in ["ubuntu2204", "ubuntu2404"] %}}
# Ubuntu-specific implementation
{{% else %}}
# Default implementation
{{% endif %}}

XCCDF Variable Handling

Templates that support XCCDF variables typically branch on whether the variable is set:

{{% if XCCDF_VARIABLE %}}
{{{ bash_instantiate_variables(XCCDF_VARIABLE) }}}
# Use $XCCDF_VARIABLE
{{% else %}}
# Use hardcoded VALUE
{{% endif %}}

Phase 4: Create Test Scenarios

Create templated test scenarios in shared/templates/$ARGUMENTS/tests/. These tests are automatically inherited by all rules using the template.

4.1 Design Test Scenarios

Every template needs at minimum:

• 1 pass scenario (system is compliant)
• 1 fail scenario (system is non-compliant but remediable)

Common test scenarios:

• correct_value.pass.sh — correct configuration is present
• wrong_value.fail.sh — incorrect value is configured
• missing_value.fail.sh — required configuration is absent
• missing_file.fail.sh — configuration file does not exist
• duplicate_values.pass.sh — multiple correct entries (if applicable)
• conflicting_values.fail.sh — correct and incorrect entries both present (if applicable)
• commented_value.fail.sh — correct value is commented out (if applicable)

4.2 Write Test Scenario Files

Test scenarios are Bash scripts with Jinja2 templating. They use the same custom delimiters as .template files, and template parameters must be in UPPERCASE.

Use test-specific parameters created in template.py (e.g., TEST_CORRECT_VALUE, TEST_WRONG_VALUE) rather than the rule's actual values — this ensures tests work correctly across all rules using the template.

Pass scenario example (correct_value.pass.sh):

#!/bin/bash

mkdir -p $(dirname {{{ PATH }}})
echo "{{{ KEY }}}{{{ SEP }}}{{{ TEST_CORRECT_VALUE }}}" > "{{{ PATH }}}"

Fail scenario example (wrong_value.fail.sh):

#!/bin/bash

mkdir -p $(dirname {{{ PATH }}})
echo "{{{ KEY }}}{{{ SEP }}}{{{ TEST_WRONG_VALUE }}}" > "{{{ PATH }}}"

XCCDF variable handling in tests:

#!/bin/bash

{{%- if XCCDF_VARIABLE %}}
# variables = {{{ XCCDF_VARIABLE }}}={{{ TEST_CORRECT_VALUE }}}
{{% endif %}}

mkdir -p $(dirname {{{ PATH }}})
echo "{{{ KEY }}}{{{ SEP }}}{{{ TEST_CORRECT_VALUE }}}" > "{{{ PATH }}}"

The # variables = VAR_NAME=value comment tells the test framework to set the XCCDF variable to the specified value during the test.

4.3 Test File Conventions

• File naming: description.pass.sh or description.fail.sh
• Do NOT make test files executable — the test framework handles this
• Pass scenarios set up a compliant state; no remediation runs
• Fail scenarios set up a non-compliant state that the remediation can fix — never create fail scenarios that the remediation cannot remediate
• Use Bash macros (e.g., {{{ bash_package_install(PKGNAME) }}}) when available
• Always clean up prior state before writing test values (e.g., use sed to remove existing config entries)

Phase 5: Verify Template by Using It in a Rule

5.1 Find or Create a Rule

Ask the user for a rule ID to use with the template.

If no suitable rule exists, suggest using the create-rule skill to create one.

5.2 Add Template to a Rule

Add the template key to the rule's rule.yml:

template:
    name: $ARGUMENTS
    vars:
        param1: value1
        param2: value2

Use @product syntax for product-specific parameter values:

template:
    name: $ARGUMENTS
    vars:
        param1: value1
        param1@rhel9: different_value
        param1@ubuntu2404: another_value

5.3 Remove Conflicting Static Content

If the rule has static content (files in oval/, bash/, ansible/ subdirectories), those files override templated content. Remove any static files that the template now generates, unless the rule intentionally needs static content to override the template for a specific language.

5.4 Build and Test

1. Build the product to verify the template generates correctly:

   ./build_product <product> --datastream --rule-id <rule_id>
   

2. Verify correct template expansion in the rendered output: Use mcp__content-agent__get_rendered_rule with product=<product> and rule_id=<rule_id>. Fallback: Inspect build/<product>/rules/<rule_id>/ for generated content.

3. Run tests using the test-rule skill to verify that both checks and remediations work correctly.

Phase 6: Report

Report to the user:

• All created files (list with paths)
• Template parameters and their defaults
• Supported languages
• Test scenarios created
• Rule(s) updated to use the template
• Next steps:
  • "Use /build-product <product> to build"
  • "Use /test-rule <rule_id> to run tests"
  • "Convert other similar rules to use this template"

Common Issues

• Parameters not substituted: Template parameters must be UPPERCASE in .template files. The build system converts parameter keys to uppercase automatically.
• Template output missing for a language: The .template file exists but the language is not listed in template.yml. Every supported language must be listed there.
• Preprocessing not applied: The preprocess function in template.py must return data. A missing return statement silently breaks preprocessing.
• Static content overrides template: If a rule has both static content (e.g., oval/shared.xml) and a template, static content takes priority. Remove static files when switching to a template.
• Wrong Jinja delimiters: Use {{{ }}} for expressions, {{% %}} for statements. Standard Jinja2 {{ }} / {% %} will NOT work.
• Test scenarios use hardcoded values: Use test-specific parameters from template.py (e.g., TEST_CORRECT_VALUE) instead of the rule's actual values to ensure tests work across all rules using the template.

File Structure Summary

After completion, the template directory should look like:

shared/templates/$ARGUMENTS/
    template.yml          # Supported languages
    template.py           # Parameter preprocessing
    ansible.template      # Ansible remediation (if supported)
    bash.template         # Bash remediation (if supported)
    oval.template         # OVAL check (if supported)
    tests/
        correct_value.pass.sh    # At least 1 pass scenario
        wrong_value.fail.sh      # At least 1 fail scenario
        ...                      # Additional scenarios