| name | implement-pr-feedback |
| description | Fetch all review comments from a GitHub PR, categorize them by priority, present an implementation plan for user approval, then systematically implement each approved change. Does not commit or push — all git actions remain manual. Requires gh CLI. Usage: /skill:implement-pr-feedback <PR URL or number> |
Implement PR Feedback
Analyze GitHub PR comments and implement suggested changes.
PR URL: $ARGUMENTS
Steps:
-
Parse PR Information
- Extract owner, repo, and PR number from the provided URL
- Format:
https://github.com/{owner}/{repo}/pull/{number}
-
Fetch PR Details and Comments
gh pr view {number} --repo {owner}/{repo} --json title,body,state,filesgh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/{number}/comments - Review commentsgh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/issues/{number}/comments - Issue commentsgh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/{number}/reviews - PR reviews- Handle API failures gracefully:
- Check if
gh is authenticated: gh auth status
- Verify repo access permissions
- Provide clear error messages if API calls fail
-
Analyze Feedback
- Extract actionable suggestions from comments
- Identify code change requests
- Note any requested improvements or fixes
- Filter out resolved conversations
-
Categorize Feedback
- Must Fix: Blocking issues, bugs, security concerns
- Should Fix: Code quality, best practices, performance
- Consider: Style preferences, minor improvements
-
Implementation Plan
- Create a todo list of all actionable items
- Prioritize based on feedback importance
- Group related changes together
- Present the plan to the user with:
- List of all actionable feedback
- Priority levels for each item
- Estimated complexity
-
User Confirmation
- PAUSE for user input
- Ask: "Review the implementation plan above. Would you like to proceed with these changes? (yes/no/edit)"
- Allow user to:
- Approve and continue
- Skip certain items
- Add additional context
- Cancel the operation
-
Create Safety Backup (Optional)
- Ask user: "Create a backup branch before making changes? (recommended)"
- If yes:
git checkout -b {branch-name}-feedback-backup
- Return to PR branch:
git checkout {branch-name}
-
Execute Changes
- Checkout the PR branch locally
- Implement each approved feedback item
- Mark todos as completed after each change
- Run tests after modifications
- Stage changes and prepare commit messages (but DO NOT commit - this is always manual)
-
Prepare Summary for User
-
Generate a summary of all implemented changes
-
List any skipped feedback with reasoning
-
Prepare summary comment text for the PR:
## Feedback Implementation Summary
✅ Implemented:
- [Item 1]: Fixed in commit abc123
- [Item 2]: Updated in commit def456
⏭️ Skipped (with reasoning):
- [Item 3]: Not applicable because...
All requested changes have been addressed.
-
Final Instructions for User
- Display summary of changes made
- Remind user to:
- Review the changes
- Run tests locally
- Push when ready:
git push
- Post the summary comment on the PR
- IMPORTANT: DO NOT commit or push changes - these are always manual processes
Additional Features:
Dry Run Mode
Add --dry-run flag to preview changes without implementing:
/skill:implement-pr-feedback https://github.com/acme/project/pull/123 --dry-run
- Shows what would be changed
- Lists files that would be modified
- No actual changes made
Error Handling
- Validates PR URL format before proceeding
- Checks GitHub CLI authentication
- Verifies repository access
- Handles rate limiting gracefully
- Provides clear error messages
Notes:
- Requires GitHub CLI (
gh) to be installed and authenticated
- Will automatically checkout the PR branch if not already on it
- Focuses only on actionable feedback, ignoring discussion comments
- Creates backup branch option for safety
- Supports marking comments as resolved
