clodex-adversarial-review

name	clodex-adversarial-review
description	Runs an adversarial review cycle against a PR (Claude implements/fixes, Codex or a subagent stand-in reviews), up to 5 iterations. Read-only on the real PR — drafts fixes, never pushes them.

clodex-adversarial-review procedure

The prompt carries intent; this skill carries the procedure — keep it a checklist, not an essay. Adapted from Forward Future Loop Library #9 (Lukas Kucinski) to this library's L1-first, report-only shape.

1. Read — the PR diff and clodex-adversarial-review-state.md's iteration history for this PR.
2. Review — run an adversarial review against the diff: the real codex CLI if available, otherwise invoke the loop-verifier subagent as a genuinely separate reviewer (never the same pass that wrote the code).
3. Fix findings above threshold — for each finding at or above the severity threshold (medium by default): in a throwaway worktree, draft a fix.
4. Re-review — repeat steps 2–3 until the reviewer approves, only accepted findings remain, no progress for 2 consecutive iterations, or 5 iterations are reached.
5. Report honestly — write clodex-review-report.md: the PR, checks, verdict, and remaining findings. Never describe an errored or exhausted run as approved — an iteration-cap exit with open findings is exhausted, say so plainly.
6. Record — update clodex-adversarial-review-state.md's iteration count and findings history (resumable), append one line to loop-run-log.md, commit both. Discard the throwaway worktree.
7. Take NO other action — never push a commit to the real PR branch. This loop is L1 report-only until a human promotes it.