メニュー
Simulate peer review on an academic LaTeX paper draft. Generates 5 reviewer personas, runs independent reviews with 5-dimension scoring, devils-advocate stress tests, editorial synthesis decision.
Codex または Claude でインストール この Prompt をコピーして Codex、Claude、または他のアシスタントに貼り付けると、Skill ページを確認してインストールできます。
SOC 職業分類に基づく
Remove AI writing patterns from English text with academic-aware overrides. Auto-detects LaTeX context for passive voice, hyphenated compounds, title case, curly quotes handling.
Placeholder for Phase C bilingual annotator. Adds sentence-level Chinese %-comments to English LaTeX source files. Currently not implemented.
Process external reviewer comments on an academic paper submission. Parses comments, classifies Major/Minor/Editorial, builds RevisionRoadmap, drafts response letter in Reviewer-Action-Change format.
Manage references.bib in an academic LaTeX paper project. Add bibtex entries, validate natbib citation commands, check citation compliance (orphan citations, self-citation ratio, source currency).
Compile an academic LaTeX paper project with pdflatex and bibtex. Diagnoses LaTeX errors, checks page-limit compliance, runs bibtex, fixes undefined references and overfull-hbox warnings.
Generate publication-quality matplotlib or seaborn figures for an academic LaTeX paper. 11 EECS chart types (bar, line, heatmap, ROC, ablation, scaling). Output to figures/*.pdf.
| name | paper-review |
| description | Simulate peer review on an academic LaTeX paper draft. Generates 5 reviewer personas, runs independent reviews with 5-dimension scoring, devils-advocate stress tests, editorial synthesis decision. |
| argument-hint | [--sections=<list>] |
| paths | ["**/main.tex","**/sections/*.tex","**/.paper-config.yml"] |
| allowed-tools | Read Skill |
Simulate peer review on an academic LaTeX paper draft. Runs the full review pipeline: 5 reviewer personas -> 5-dimension scoring -> devils-advocate stress test -> editorial synthesis decision -> revision roadmap.
Same as paper-draft. If no .paper-config.yml is found, stop.
$ARGUMENTS for optional --sections=<comma-list> to limit review
to specific sections (default: review the whole paper).peer_reviewer agent. The agent:
subfieldReviewReport with
5-dimension scores (originality, rigor, evidence, coherence, writing)ReviewReport includes recommendation (accept/minor/major/reject)devils_advocate agent to run 7 stress tests on the same
draft (counter-arguments, cherry-picking detection, "So What?" test,
etc.). Output is a 6th ReviewReport with reviewer_id: DA.editorial_synthesizer agent to weight all 6 reports by
confidence and produce a final decision plus a RevisionRoadmap.build/review_report.md (using the
templates/review_report.md template format).This skill orchestrates multiple agents that produce:
ReviewReport (one per reviewer, 5+1 total)RevisionRoadmap (final, from editorial_synthesizer)See references/handoff_schemas.md for full schemas.
/paper-revise (when external reviewer comments arrive) to compare with
this simulated review/paper-draft <section> to address the highest-priority items from the
RevisionRoadmap