review-pr-comments

name	review-pr-comments
description	Review and respond to PR review comments.

/review-pr-comments

Review and respond to PR review comments.

Usage

/review-pr-comments [pr-number]

Arguments

Argument	Type	Required	Description
pr-number	integer	No	GitHub PR number (auto-detect from current branch if omitted)

Instructions

When the user invokes /review-pr-comments, follow these steps:

Step 1: Determine PR Number

If PR number is provided:

• Use the provided number

If not provided:

• Get current branch name
• Find PR for this branch:

  gh pr list --head <branch-name> --state open --json number --limit 1
  

Step 2: Fetch Comments

gh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/<number>/comments

Parse and group comments by thread/file.

Step 3: Display Comment Table

Present comments in a table format:

| Thread ID | File | Issue | Decision | Action |
|-----------|------|-------|----------|--------|
| PRRT_xxx | src/auth.py:10 | "Fix null check" | ? | - |
| PRRT_yyy | src/user.py:20 | "Consider error handling" | ? | - |

Step 4: Process Each Comment

For each comment, ask the user:

1. Accept - Make the suggested change
2. Reject - Reply with reason and resolve thread
3. Discuss - Reply asking for clarification
4. Skip - Leave for later

Step 5: Execute Actions

For accepted comments:

• Make the code changes
• Reply to thread: "Fixed in "
• Resolve the thread

For rejected comments:

• Reply with reason provided by user
• Resolve the thread

Step 6: Create Summary

Post a summary comment on the PR:

## Review Response Summary

### Accepted (2)
- [src/auth.py:10] Fixed null check
- [src/user.py:20] Added error handling

### Rejected (1)
- [src/api.py:5] Reason: Current approach is intentional for...

### Pending (0)
None

---
*Reviewed by Claude Code at YYYY-MM-DD HH:MM*

Step 7: Commit Changes

If changes were made:

git add .
git commit -m "address review comments"

Output Format

Comment List

## PR #100 - Review Comments

### Unresolved Comments (3)

| # | File | Line | Comment | Author |
|---|------|------|---------|--------|
| 1 | src/auth.py | 10 | "Add null check" | @reviewer |
| 2 | src/auth.py | 25 | "Consider edge case" | @reviewer |
| 3 | src/user.py | 15 | "Rename variable" | @lead |

For each comment, choose:
[A]ccept | [R]eject | [D]iscuss | [S]kip

Error Handling

Error	Action
PR not detected	No PR found for current branch
PR not found	Display error message
No comments	No review comments found
API error	Display error details

Tips

• Use --web to open PR in browser for context:

  gh pr view <number> --web
  

• Group related comments and address them together
• Explain rejections clearly to avoid back-and-forth