メニュー
Reviewer 评论流水线：分类 → 找 supporting evidence → 写 rebuttal → cross-model review → submit。3 道 safety gate：no fabrication / no overpromise / full coverage。Use when user says "rebuttal", "reviews", "reviewer 来了", "反驳", "答辩", "OpenReview comment".
Codex または Claude でインストール この Prompt をコピーして Codex、Claude、または他のアシスタントに貼り付けると、Skill ページを確認してインストールできます。
SOC 職業分類に基づく
大改动 (>3 文件) 之前先画依赖图 + 改动计划，确认后再动手。**所有外部 ref（line# / API / partition / env var）必须配 _verify 守门函数 runtime fail-loud**，不能盲信 WebFetch 结果。Use when user says "arch plan", "改动计划", "画依赖图", "重构前", "big change", "多文件改", "先规划", "monkey patch", "插入点".
Driver Claude（通常通过 /remote-drive 控制 sub-agent CC）跑实战发现新 bug / 配置问题 / 架构选择需重新拍板时，把 findings 标准化写到 .driver_findings_<round>_<context>.md，让 sub-agent 读了去 patch。比 send-keys 长 message 可靠 100 倍。Use when user says "driver findings", "findings file", "round N 反馈", "远程发现", "hpcc 验证发现", "driver patch", "sub-agent 修 bug".
用一个 Claude (driver) 通过 tmux 远程控制另一个 Claude Code session (sub-agent CC) 走完 pipeline。把 sub-agent 当 worker 用：driver brief 任务 → send-keys 输入 → capture-pane 监听 → 处理 AskUserQuestion → 等下次 idle。Use when user says "remote drive", "驱动另一个 cc", "sub-agent cc", "控制别的 claude", "tmux drive", "我已经开了 cc 你来控制".
起任何实验/sprint 前必须填 Karpathy 5-tuple: Goal / Scope / Metric / Verify / Guard。不填拒绝起训练。Stage 4 → 5 之间 RESOURCE gate 的一部分。用户说 'contract' / '5-tuple' / '签合同' / 'sprint plan' 时调用。
把本地 project 推到远程 compute host（hpcc / bcc / tasl-labserver）+ 远端 bootstrap auto-production framework + 验证 stubs import 通。给 driver 用，跟 /cross-host-sync (run sync) 互补——后者管 run state，本 skill 管 code state。Use when user says "sync to remote", "部署到 hpcc", "推到集群", "rsync project", "远程跑", "hpcc 上验证", "deploy 上去".
写完代码先用 AST parser 做静态分析（import 完整性、签名匹配、未定义符号），过了才执行。防 "跑了 30 秒才发现 ImportError"。Use when user says "ast validate", "静态分析", "先检查", "语法检查", "import 验证", "static check".
| name | rebuttal |
| description | Reviewer 评论流水线：分类 → 找 supporting evidence → 写 rebuttal → cross-model review → submit。3 道 safety gate：no fabrication / no overpromise / full coverage。Use when user says "rebuttal", "reviews", "reviewer 来了", "反驳", "答辩", "OpenReview comment". |
| argument-hint | [paper-dir-with-reviews] [--venue ICML] [--char-limit 5000] |
| allowed-tools | Bash(*), Read, Write, Edit, Agent, Skill, WebSearch |
借鉴 ARIS
/rebuttal。Stage 9 / acceptance loop。
5 阶段：
paper/reviews/parsed.json（per-reviewer concerns 列表）factual-question / request-for-experiment / clarification / subjective-criticism/cross-review --rounds 2PASTE_READY.txt（精确字符数）+ REBUTTAL_DRAFT_rich.md（rich text，留 manual edit）VENUE=${VENUE:-ICML}
CHAR=${CHAR_LIMIT:-5000}
python3 tools/rebuttal.py parse paper/reviews/*.md > paper/reviews/parsed.json
# loop 5 stages...
paper/reviews/parsed.jsonpaper/rebuttal/draft.mdpaper/rebuttal/PASTE_READY.txtpaper/rebuttal/REBUTTAL_DRAFT_rich.md/kill-argument 准备反驳武器/cross-review 二审/experiment-bridge (未实现，placeholder)