cookbook-review-pr

name	cookbook-review-pr
description	Review a pull request against the SGLang Cookbook (docs_new/, Mintlify) contribution checklist — the config-driven format (per-model config + benchmarks JSX consumed by the shared _deployment.jsx / _playground.jsx engines). Run with /cookbook-review-pr <PR number>.

Cookbook Review PR

Fetch the diff, run the checklist, report what you find. The cookbook is config-driven: shared engines (_deployment.jsx, _playground.jsx) with NO model-specific code; each model is a data config (+ optional benchmarks) under src/snippets/configs/<vendor>/ plus an MDX page. This checklist targets that layout. Field-schema detail lives in .claude/skills/cookbook-add-model/references/authoring-reference.md — defer to it rather than restating.

Usage

/cookbook-review-pr <PR number>

Steps

1. gh pr view <N> --repo sgl-project/sglang --json title,body,files,author,baseRefName,headRefName,commits,reviews
2. gh pr diff <N> --repo sgl-project/sglang
3. gh pr list --repo sgl-project/sglang --state open --search "<model name>" (duplicate check)
4. Run every checklist item against the diff.
5. Output per-file verdicts + overall recommendation.

Checklist

1. File hygiene

• A cookbook PR should only touch: docs_new/src/snippets/configs/<vendor>/*.jsx (config + benchmarks), docs_new/cookbook/**/*.mdx, docs_new/docs.json, docs_new/cookbook/<category>/intro.mdx (vendor card), docs_new/cards/logos/<vendor>.png (new vendor only). Flag stray files (settings.local.json, lockfiles, IDE configs).
• Pages must be .mdx, not .md. Files end with a trailing newline. Check commit history for unrelated commits accidentally included.
• Engines untouched: _deployment.jsx / _playground.jsx should NOT change in a model-add PR (adding a model is data-only). Engine edits = a separate axis/feature PR (see cookbook-add-model/references/engine-axis.md); review them against that checklist.

2. Config quality (the per-model config)

• Single export const config = { ... } literal — no function calls, spreads, fragment refs, or IIFE (Mintlify re-evals at hydration → ReferenceError).
• No !(x in y) anywhere (Mintlify AST walker crashes) — use obj.key === undefined.
• supportedHardware ⊆ HARDWARE_CATALOG (in _deployment.jsx) ∪ config.hardware. A model-specific GPU the shared catalog lacks must be declared in config.hardware ({id,label,vram,vendor}), not added to the engine catalog.
• placeholders declares every {{KEY}} used in curl or any cell.
• modelNames covers every cell (by hw|variant|quant triple or variant|quant pair).
• strategies count matches the page's operating points — 1 recipe → a single balanced; 2 → low-latency + high-throughput; 3 → the full trio. Tiers apply per (hw × variant × quant) combination: a single-recipe combination must park under its semantically honest tier (clear slant → that tier, e.g. a workstation card under low-latency; no slant → balanced, e.g. a CPU platform) — flag a no-slant recipe parked under low-latency/high-throughput. Mixed unions like [low-latency, balanced, high-throughput] with per-selection greying are fine. Also flag model-specific ids (e.g. mtp), and flag an INVERTED speculative mapping — the deterministic default is MTP/spec-decoding ON → low-latency, OFF → high-throughput (at saturation the draft+verify overhead outweighs the speedup); the reverse needs an explicit maintainer-confirmed justification in the PR. The MDX strategy bullets describe serving semantics in the DSv4 style (single-user chat / typical multi-user / batch jobs), not internal toggles.
• dockerImages covers the hw ids that have cells (else users hit the :dev fallback); a hw|quant key (resolved before the plain hw) is valid when one quant on a shared GPU needs a different image (e.g. an FP4 dev build) — don't flag those.
• multiNodeHints present ONLY for hw whose fabric needs manual NIC env (e.g. gb200 NVL72) — NOT every multi-N hw (standard-IB DeepEP / Marlin multi-node don't need it).
• github.cookbookModel is set to the model's HF id (<hf-org>/<model-slug>). The issue template's model field is a free-form input prefilled from this value; if the config omits the github block, the engine falls back to deepseek-ai/deepseek-v4 and the page's submissions get mislabeled.
• playgroundFeatures is opt-OUT: the general axes ship on every cookbook by default (attention TP/CP/DP-Attn, moe backend+EP for MoE models, parsers, speculative, pdDisagg, hicache) — flag a missing general axis unless the model genuinely cannot use it. Model-specific axes only where applicable (MegaMoE backend + megamoeQuant only on Blackwell MoE, gated by requiresHw; hisparse only DSA-style). Knobs that are meaningless for a subset of variants/hw are disabled with a reason, not silently live (e.g. MoE knobs greyed on dense variants). No empty/stub axes.
• No leftover __TOKEN__ — the config was stamped from the template and every placeholder is filled (grep -rn '__[A-Z_]*__' on the new config/benchmarks/MDX returns nothing).
• All-hardware considered: every supportedHardware id (from the catalog or config.hardware) has ≥1 cell OR is a deliberate greyed "coming soon"; AMD was pruned or kept on purpose (not a leftover template family).

3. Cells / 5-dim matrix

• Every cell match has EXACTLY the 5 keys (hw, variant, quant, strategy, nodes).
• env / flags are flat literals (only {{PLACEHOLDER}} subst) — no shared commonFlags reference (Mintlify won't inline it).
• NO --nnodes / --node-rank / --dist-init-addr literals in multi-node cells (the renderer injects them from match.nodes).
• NO literal --host / --port — use {{HOST_IP}} / {{PORT}}.
• NO --reasoning-parser / --tool-call-parser in any cell — parsers are a Playground-only feature added on top of the base command (DSv4 convention); flag any cell that bakes them in.
• Accuracy-degrading flags in cells — runtime quant below the checkpoint (e.g. MegaMoE W4A4 — DSv4 gates it behind the Playground's megamoeQuant) and lossy --kv-cache-dtype (e.g. fp8_e4m3 over a higher-precision-KV checkpoint): flag for explicit maintainer confirmation. Output quality should be exactly what the quant chip declares, so absent a recorded sign-off in the PR (e.g. carried verbatim from a measured legacy recipe's default command), request the flag move to Playground/tips.
• Flag order: --model-path first (an optional --trust-remote-code may precede it — the DSv4 cells do), then parallelism, then MoE, then tuning, --host/--port last (the playground's insert anchors assume this).
• TP/memory sanity: model_weight_GB / (tp × gpu_mem) fits with ~20–30% headroom (BF16 ≈ params×2 GB, FP8 ≈ ×1, FP4 ≈ ×0.5; MoE uses total weight, not active params).

4. Benchmarks

• Each benchmarks[] entry's match tuple corresponds to a real cell.
• accuracyLabels is present whenever the benchmarks carry accuracy data — the engine ships NO default eval set; without it the accuracy rows silently don't render. defaultAccuracy / per-cell accuracy / benchmarkCommands.accuracy keys all ∈ config.accuracyLabels.
• A benchmark's quantization must match a variant actually listed — (BF16) on a model that only released FP8/FP4 is a factual bug.
• benchmarkCommands.speed is python3 -m sglang.bench_serving (the workload), separate from the sglang serve deploy command.
• sglang_version is a real build the author ran (a release, or dev/nightly) — not a guessed/placeholder value (no leftover 0.0.0).
• Latency percentile: config.latencyPercentile (default "P50", or "Mean") matches the percentile the TTFT/TPOT values actually are — the card renders TTFT (<pct>). ("Mean" is temporary — legacy data is being re-measured to P50.)
• Throughput convention: tokens_per_sec_per_gpu is stored as total (in+out)/GPU = output tok/s/GPU × (isl+osl)/osl, shown by the card as-is. Flag output-only values.
• Consistent accuracy harness across entries: every value under one accuracyLabels column must be produced by the SAME harness — flag a page that, say, measures one platform's GSM8K with few_shot_gsm8k --num-questions 200 and another's with run_eval --eval-name gsm8k --num-examples 1319 and shows both as one "GSM8K %" (the scores aren't comparable). Either standardize on one harness (matching benchmarkCommands.accuracy) or require an explicit per-entry note. Common when folding a second contributor's measurements (e.g. an AMD/ROCm PR) into the page.

5. Doc ↔ config parity (the #1 finding)

• Any sglang serve command shown in MDX prose (config tips, benchmark section) must equal what the engine emits from the corresponding cell — same flags, same order. Drift here is the most common review miss.

6. Commands / port

• Launch uses sglang serve — flag any python -m sglang.launch_server / python3 -m sglang.launch_server (deprecated). The engine already emits sglang serve; guard against prose/cells reintroducing the old launcher.
• Port 30000 everywhere (launch, curl, client base_url, bench) — flag 8000. Launch port must match client/curl port on the same page.

7. Frontmatter

• Every new MDX page has title: and a top-level description: (a real one-line value prop, not copied from another vendor) — NOT metatags.description (non-canonical; the top-level field is what renders as the subtitle and SEO meta — see mintlify-authoring).
• No mode: wide on a model page — it hides the right-hand "On this page" ToC that every other model page has. Leave mode unset (the Deploy/Playground panels self-cap at 900px, so the default column holds them fine). mode: wide belongs only on category intro.mdx grids.
• tag: NEW only for genuine new launches; when one is added, stale tag: NEW on older pages should be dropped in the same PR (grep -RlE "^tag: NEW" docs_new/cookbook/).
• MDX imports BOTH Deployment and Playground from /src/snippets/... (absolute).
• Deploy heading slugs to deployment (or deploy), Playground to playground — so "↑ Switch base" and "Open the Playground →" scroll. No numbered headings for these two.

8. Navigation & homepage

• New page → docs_new/docs.json updated: under the right vendor group inside navigation → Cookbook → Autoregressive Models, root-relative, no .mdx: cookbook/<category>/<Vendor>/<Model>.
• Homepage <Card href> in docs_new/cookbook/<category>/intro.mdx points to the vendor's flagship; new vendors get a new <Card> + a logo at docs_new/cards/logos/<vendor>.png — 940×525 RGBA transparent, icon-only (no wordmark), lowercase filename, tracked via git add -f (*.png is gitignored repo-wide). Card order matches the docs.json nav order.
• Don't change docs_new/cookbook/intro.mdx for individual model adds (top-level only).

9. Links & factual

• HuggingFace URLs resolve to a real model. License section matches the actual HF license (don't copy from another model). Docker images from lmsysorg/sglang; no sgl-project-dev. The image tag is a real build (a release the author ran, or :dev/nightly) — not a guessed version.
• Internal links root-relative, no extension (/cookbook/.../<Model>); flag .md/.mdx or ../-relative links. docs.sglang.io is canonical.
• No Google-Drive image links (don't render). Shell placeholders are export VAR=<value>, not ${VAR} (a bash no-op).
• Parser ids must exist in the code registries on the PR's target branch: every --reasoning-parser X / --tool-call-parser Y named in prose or in playgroundFeatures.parsers flags is a registered key in python/sglang/srt/parser/reasoning_parser.py (DetectorMap) / python/sglang/srt/function_call/function_call_parser.py (ToolCallParserEnum) — prose naming a near-miss id (e.g. the reasoning id where the tool id differs) is a factual bug. --…-parser auto is acceptable ONLY if the template-detection rules (python/sglang/srt/managers/template_detection.py) actually resolve THIS model's chat template to the right parser — no rule match means auto silently disables the parser; when in doubt require explicit ids (the DSv4 page pins explicit ids).

9b. MDX authoring (Mintlify) — detail in cookbook-add-model/references/mintlify-authoring.md

• Forbidden syntax: no Docusaurus admonitions (:::), @site/@theme, GitHub alert blocks (> [!NOTE]), markdown pipe tables (use JSX <table>), inline <details>, or unknown components. <CardGroup>/<Card> only on category intro.mdx, not model pages.
• Code fences are labeled (e.g. python Example / bash Command / text Output after the opening fence); a fenced block nested inside another uses four backticks outside.
• §3 commands and outputs are collapsible (DeepSeek-V4 pattern): every runnable example wrapped in an <Accordion>, its real output in a following <Accordion title="Example Output"> (Pending update... only with user acknowledgement). Flag bare/inline example blocks and **Output Example:** headings.
• Reasoning-parser example matches the parser's output shape: separate-field (reasoning_content + content) vs inline <think> tags parsed out of content.
• No hardcoded sampling params (temperature / top_p) in sample code (SGLang uses generation_config.json defaults); listing them in §1 informationally is fine.

10. Quantization rules

• NVFP4 checkpoints are Blackwell-only (B200/B300/GB300) — never AMD. An AMD FP4 cell is legitimate ONLY when the vendor published an MXFP4 checkpoint for it (e.g. amd/Qwen3.5-397B-A17B-MXFP4 on MI355X) — verify the HF repo resolves; otherwise the AMD FP4 chip must be absent/disabled.
• BF16 / FP8 work on NVIDIA and AMD. --kv-cache-dtype fp8_e4m3 in a cell is an accuracy-degrading flag — see §3 (needs explicit maintainer sign-off; default home is Playground/tips).

11. Scope

• Changes match the PR title. Flag global changes hiding behind a platform-specific title (e.g. an "H200 FP8" PR that adds a flag to ALL cells). Unmentioned side-fixes belong in the PR body.

12. Duplicate PRs

• Another open PR for the same model? Flag it; compare completeness; note merge-conflict risk on docs.json + the vendor card; flag a superseded older PR by the same author.

13. Build / validate

cd docs_new
mint validate
mint broken-links

Optional: mint dev for a visual smoke test.

14. Reviewer feedback

• gh api repos/sgl-project/sglang/pulls/<N>/comments — have prior reviewer requests been addressed? Unresolved requested-changes should be flagged.

15. Grammar & spelling

• Check added/changed prose for typos and grammar (e.g. "recommend" vs "recommended"). Flag each with the exact wrong text + correction.

Output

Per file:

• ✅ PASS
• ⚠️ ISSUE: <what>
• 🔴 BLOCK: <what>

Overall: APPROVE / REQUEST CHANGES / BLOCKED