メニュー
Phase 39.1 capability reviewer wrapper. Runs the deterministic editorial assertions against a compiled edition, surfaces blocking failures that should halt publish, and writes a markdown summary alongside the JSON.
デフォルトでは、最初にソースを確認する Prompt が選択されています。直接コマンドに切り替えるか、ローカルコピーをダウンロードすることもできます。
インストールを決める前に、SKILL.md と SkillsMP に表示されている付属ファイルをお読みください。
Codex または Claude でインストール この Prompt をコピーして Codex、Claude、または他のアシスタントに貼り付けると、Skill ページを確認してインストールできます。
直接コマンドでは確認用 Prompt が省略されます。実行前にソースを確認してください。
npx skills add https://github.com/pnils08/GodWorld --skill capability-reviewコマンドは1行のまま表示されます。コピー前に横へスクロールして全体を確認してください。
ローカルで確認しますか？SkillsMP が現在取得できるファイルをダウンロードできます。
Close a GodWorld external-lane session (Grok) cleanly: inventory work, land authorized commits if needed, rewrite only NEXT[grok] in SESSION_CONTEXT.md, commit that handoff path-specifically, report git stack / push status. Use when the user says session end, close session, handoff, wrap up, done for now, or runs /session-end. Not the Claude Code session-end skill (no PIN bump, no ROLLOUT sweep, no sessionEndMechanical.js).
Deputy Mayor Brenda Okoro's office. Generates operational statements on West Oakland Stabilization Fund, Community Development, and Economic Development (Osei-portfolio coverage). Carries Mayor's-office operational reality — not political framing.
Oakland Police Chief Rafael Montez. Generates public safety statements, OARI implementation responses, and crime data communications. Professional, measured, data-driven.
SKILL.md を表示中
SOC 職業分類に基づく
| name | capability-review |
| description | Phase 39.1 capability reviewer wrapper. Runs the deterministic editorial assertions against a compiled edition, surfaces blocking failures that should halt publish, and writes a markdown summary alongside the JSON. |
| version | 1.1 |
| updated | "2026-06-20T00:00:00.000Z" |
| tags | ["media","active"] |
| effort | low |
| disable-model-invocation | true |
Phase 39.1. Plugs into /write-edition as Step 3.5 (between Compile and Validation+Rhea). Catches structural editorial gaps — front page missing the highest-severity ailment, citizen names that don't resolve to canon, engine metrics leaking into journalism — before publish, not after.
A thin wrapper around scripts/capabilityReviewer.js. The script does the deterministic work (9 of 11 assertions, 2 deferred to the Haiku grader). The skill is responsible for:
node scripts/capabilityReviewer.js {CYCLE}
Fail loudly if exit code is non-zero. Required inputs (the script will error if missing):
editions/cycle_pulse_edition_{CYCLE}.txt — compiled edition from write-edition Step 3output/engine_audit_c{CYCLE}.json — produced by scripts/engineAuditor.js (Phase 38.1)scripts/capability-reviewer/assertions.json — declarative rubricoutput/capability_review_c{CYCLE}.json contains results[] (one entry per assertion) and summary with blockingFailures[] and advisoryFailures[].
Each result has id, category, tier, pass, confidence, reason, evidence, rubricSource.
Format for the user:
Capability Review — Cycle {N}
5/9 passed in 0.82s
category breakdown: coverage 1, three-layer 2, freshness 1, rubric-fidelity 3, representation 1
deferred (need Haiku key): 2
BLOCKING (would halt publish):
✗ front-page-leads-with-highest-severity-ailment
Temescal Community Health Center (cyclesInState=88) not covered.
rubric: story_evaluation.md §Priority Signals + §Varek Anti-Example
✗ no-engine-metrics-in-journalism
3 articles use forbidden tokens (e.g., "cycles" in narrative copy).
rubric: .claude/rules/newsroom.md
ADVISORY (ships with flag):
✗ canon-names-not-invented (Nn unresolved candidates — likely needs MCP get_roster wiring)
✗ at-least-three-female-citizens-non-official (Nn non-official; target 3)
For every entry in summary.blockingFailures:
evidence and rubricSource./sift if the failure is structural like a missing front-page topic). Re-run capability review after the fix.Advisory failures don't gate publish. They get logged into the production log so the next sift session sees them.
Three advisory assertions recur as false-positives every cycle — they are known non-blocking noise, not findings. Acknowledge and move past them; do not send a reporter back or re-run on their account. They are advisory (they never gate publish), but each reads as a finding every cycle and costs a re-investigation it doesn't warrant:
canon-names-not-invented — grabs headline fragments and flags them as unresolved citizen candidates. Its name-extraction pass treats capitalized headline tokens as person names, so most "unresolved candidates" it reports are headline fragments, not invented citizens. Real invented-name leaks are caught by Rhea's sourcing lane — trust that lane, not this advisory's candidate count.article-length-balance — reads body-merge concatenation as one over-long article. When two articles compile adjacent without the expected separator, the assertion measures their combined length and flags imbalance; the underlying articles are individually in range. Verify against the compiled section, not the advisory.names-index-completeness — expects a per-article names index, but the edition carries an edition-level NAMES INDEX per [[../../../docs/media/EDITION_FORMAT_TEMPLATE|EDITION_FORMAT_TEMPLATE]]. The per-article expectation is a spec mismatch with the actual format contract; the edition-level index is correct and complete.Documented here so each cycle's operator recognizes them on sight rather than re-diagnosing. The durable fix (re-scoping the three checks in scripts/capability-reviewer/assertions.json so they stop mis-firing) is an engine-sheet assertion-tuning item — file it if the noise ever becomes load-bearing; until then recognition is cheaper than re-tuning advisory-only checks.
Generate output/capability_review_c{CYCLE}.md from the JSON. Format:
# Capability Review — Cycle {N}
**Generated:** {timestamp}
**Reviewer version:** {reviewerVersion}
**Edition:** {edition filename}
**Audit JSON:** {audit filename}
**Runtime:** {elapsedSeconds}s
## Summary
- **{passed}/{total}** assertions passed
- **{blockingCount}** blocking failures
- **{advisoryCount}** advisory failures
- Deferred (need Haiku grader): {deferredCount}
## Blocking Failures
### {assertion id}
- **Question:** {question}
- **Reason:** {reason}
- **Rubric:** {rubricSource}
- **Evidence:** {evidence}
(repeat for each blocking failure)
## Advisory Failures
(same format as blocking, lower severity)
## Passed
(brief list, one line per — no need for evidence)
## Deferred Assertions
These need the Anthropic API key wired before they can run:
- {assertion id} — {rubricSource}
(this section explains why N/11 instead of 11/11 pass)
Step 3.5 in /write-edition. Order: pre-flight → engine-review → build-world-summary → city-hall-prep → sift → write-edition (steps 1–3 produce the compiled edition) → /capability-review (Step 3.5) → write-edition Step 4 (validation+Rhea) → Step 5 (Mara) → Step 6 (publish) → post-publish.
| File | Purpose |
|---|---|
output/capability_review_c{XX}.json | Structured results, consumed by the Final Arbiter agent (Phase 39.7, future). |
output/capability_review_c{XX}.md | Human-readable summary, included in the production log. |
Per docs/engine/archive/PHASE_39_PLAN.md §1, current verification asks "did the agent do its job correctly?" but no reviewer asks "was this the right job?" — capability verification. The Varek anti-example (E91 led with NBA expansion while Temescal ran four cycles uncovered) is the structural failure this catches at Step 3.5 instead of accepting after publish.
scripts/capability-reviewer/assertions.json lists 2 grader-only assertions under graderOnlyAssertions — they need an Anthropic API key wired for direct Haiku 4.5 calls. When that lands, they activate without code changes (the orchestrator already iterates the deferred list and writes them into output for visibility).
The 9 active assertions cover all 5 categories (coverage, representation, three-layer, freshness, rubric-fidelity), which is the §8 acceptance criterion #7 bar.
canon-names-not-invented, article-length-balance, names-index-completeness) documented as known non-blocking noise so each cycle's operator recognizes them on sight instead of re-diagnosing. Durable assertion re-scope deferred to engine-sheet. Source gap: output/production_log_c98_post_publish_gaps.md §G-W reviewer-handoff. Plan: [[../../../docs/archive/plans/2026-06-20-c98-gap-log-triage]] RB-4.