vote

name	vote
description	Evaluate code changes with 4 independent AI judges (like America's Got Talent). Each judge has a unique personality and expertise. Use PROACTIVELY when asked to review, evaluate, or vote on code changes, commits, or branches.

🎭 Code Jury

4 independent AI judges evaluate code changes — like America's Got Talent!

How It Works

1. Ask for quality mode (interactive menu or parse --mode flag)
2. Select 4 random judges from 10 personality types with localized names
3. Spawn 4 sub-agents in parallel with personality + name
4. Aggregate results with weighted voting + consensus detection

Step-by-Step

Step 0: Choose quality mode

Check for --mode flag in user's request:

• --mode lightning — 4× Haiku (швидко, дешево, для дрібних змін)
• --mode thorough — 4× Sonnet (ретельно, для важливих ревью)
• No flag → balanced (2× Sonnet + 2× Haiku, default)

Step 1: Get the code diff

Fallback chain — try each until one works:

1. git diff HEAD — unstaged changes with commits
2. git diff — changes vs index (no commits yet)
3. No .git → ask user which files to review

Step 2: Detect language & select judges

Detect language from user's conversation context, then run:

python3 .qwen/skills/vote/scripts/select_judges.py --lang <code> --mode <mode>

Step 3: Spawn 4 sub-agents

Use .qwen/agents/jury-judge.md for ALL 4 judges (model: inherit). Pass each judge their personality JSON + code diff.

Step 4: Aggregate results

Consensus detection:

• Extract issues from each judge's "❌ What I disliked"
• Issues mentioned by 3+ judges → consensus (high priority)
• Issues mentioned by 2 judges → shared (medium priority)

Weighted score:

• sum(score_i × vote_weight_i) / sum(vote_weight_i)
• Consensus penalty: -0.3 per issue with 3+ mentions (max -1.0)

Pass threshold: weighted "Yes" >= 60% of total weight

Judge Types

Personality	Weight	Focus
Strict Critic	1.7x	Architecture, errors, security
Supportive Mentor	1.0x	Potential, best practices
Detail-Oriented	1.2x	Style, docs, tests, DRY
Creative Engineer	1.0x	Creativity, performance
Security Expert	2.0x	Vulnerabilities, validation
Performance Optimizer	1.5x	Algorithms, memory, CPU
Testing Expert	1.6x	Unit tests, edge cases
Architecture Guru	1.8x	SOLID, patterns, modularity
UX Advocate	1.1x	API design, UX
Maintenance Focus	1.2x	Readability, tech debt

Files

• scripts/select_judges.py — selects 4 judges with localization
• scripts/judge_profiles/*.json — 9 language profiles
• .qwen/agents/jury-judge.md — sub-agent for each judge
• judges.json — source of truth for weights & models