review-by-oppfinalize

name	review-by-opp:finalize
description	Finalize the review session. Only succeeds if all blocking findings are resolved. Emits final verdict.
user-invocable	true

Finalize the review-by-opp session. This is the exit gate.

What to do

1. Load the ledger:

   • Read reviews/current.json
   • If missing, tell user: "No active session. Run /review-by-opp:start first."

2. Run the exit gate check: Check ALL of these conditions:

   a. No blocking findings open:

   • Get all findings where status === "open" and severity is in blockingSeverities
   • If any exist: BLOCK. List them and say: "Cannot finalize. {N} blocking finding(s) still open."

   b. No findings without resolution state:

   • Every finding must have a status other than just existing with no decision
   • If any finding has status === "open" and is blocking: BLOCK.

   c. No false completion claims:

   • Any finding marked fixed MUST have a resolution_note
   • If any fixed finding lacks a note: BLOCK. "Finding {id} is marked fixed but has no resolution note."

3. If blocked:

   • List all blocking reasons
   • Tell user: "Use /review-by-opp:fix to resolve remaining findings."
   • Do NOT finalize.

4. If clear to finalize:

   • Determine the final verdict:
     • clean - no open findings at all
     • clean_with_accepted_exceptions - only non-blocking findings remain open
     • max_rounds_reached - max rounds hit (but no blocking findings)
   • Set final_verdict in the ledger
   • Write the final state to reviews/current.json

5. Report final verdict: Show a summary:

   ## Final Verdict: {VERDICT}
   
   - Rounds completed: {N}
   - Total findings: {N}
   - Fixed: {N}
   - Won't fix: {N}
   - Not reproducible: {N}
   - Needs context: {N}
   - Duplicate: {N}
   - Superseded: {N}
   - Still open (non-blocking): {N}
   

6. Session is now closed. Tell user: "Session finalized. To start a new session, run /review-by-opp:start."

CRITICAL: This is the stop gate. You MUST NOT bypass it. If blocking findings remain, finalization MUST fail. This is the entire point of review-by-opp.

$ARGUMENTS